Project Management

Top-Down Leadership Doesn't Always Work in Today's Complex World

From the Voices on Project Management Blog
by , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Voices on Project Management offers insights, tips, advice and personal stories from project managers in different regions and industries. The goal is to get you thinking, and spark a discussion. So, if you read something that you agree with--or even disagree with--leave a comment.

About this Blog


View Posts By:

cyndee miller
Lynda Bourne
Kevin Korterud
Conrado Morlan
Peter Tarhanidis
Mario Trentim
Jen Skrabak
David Wakeman
Wanda Curlee
Christian Bisson
Ramiro Rodrigues
Soma Bhattacharya
Emily Luijbregts
Sree Rao
Yasmina Khelifi
Marat Oyvetsky
Lenka Pincot
Jorge Martin Valdes Garciatorres

Past Contributors:

Rex Holmlin
Vivek Prakash
Dan Goldfischer
Linda Agyapong
Jim De Piante
sanjay saini
Siti Hajar Abdul Hamid
Bernadine Douglas
Judy Umlas
Abdiel Ledesma
Michael Hatfield
Deanna Landers
Kelley Hunsberger
Taralyn Frasqueri-Molina
Alfonso Bucero Torres
William Krebs
Marian Haus
Shobhna Raghupathy
Peter Taylor
Joanna Newman
Saira Karim
Jess Tayel
Lung-Hung Chou
Rebecca Braglio
Roberto Toledo
Geoff Mattie
Dmitri Ivanenko PMP ITIL

Recent Posts

The Path of Paperless Projects: Finding What You Need

2020 PMO of the Year: Innovation Meets Efficiency

The First Rule of Engagement? Set the Ground Rules

Need a Little Motivation? Start with the Why

Why We Need EPMOs and EDMOs—Now More Than Ever

There's no single definition of leadership. Whether they opt to emulate Sun Tzu or Steve Jobs, project professionals should assess their teams and organizations to carve out their own leadership strategies, plenary speaker Andy Craggs told project professionals at the PMI® Global Congress 2012 -- EMEA in Marseille, France.

Mr. Craggs, a global business consultant at The Learning Partnership, dubbed today's business world as VUCA: volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous.

As a result, the top-down, individual-driven leadership style prevalent 10 years ago is no longer as effective. Instead, leadership must happen at four levels: society, organization, group and individual.
That means leaders must cross boundaries to encourage interdependence, collaboration and innovation among three types of people:

  • Conservers tend to be reliable, promoting the organization's underlying system and values while striving for constant improvement.
  • Pragmatists build cooperation and gather input from as many sources as possible to seek common ground.
  • Originators have long-range vision and seek to lead via new approaches and systems.
Mr. Craggs emphasized to the attendees that they must tailor their message to their audience, as each of the three groups will react differently.

Drawing on his time working with Disney and Apple, Mr. Craggs demonstrated how different leadership styles can be effective in the proper context.
At Disney, the bulk of activity takes place in the operations sector, with the focus on protecting intellectual property and the brand. In the modern VUCA world, though, Disney's top-down leadership doesn't always work. Although the company did enjoy a record box office debut for its movie The Avengers, it has struggled to compete in the application and video game development fields.
Apple takes the opposite approach. The organization's leadership, being more agile and connected across the organization, is more responsive to market changes -- which has allowed it to thrive.
Mr. Cragg concluded his presentation by identifying three types of organizational leadership cultures:

  • Dependent: A top-down, hierarchical structure that can be effective in very large, siloed organizations, like Disney
  • Independent: Characteristic of organizations with specialized but not necessarily connected functions, such as Apple
  • Interdependent: Typically function with agile, interconnected networks within the organization, a style common at companies like Twitter
 By knowing the characteristics of themselves, those around them and their organizations, project professionals can tailor their leadership approach to maximize their chances of success.

Posted by cyndee miller on: May 09, 2012 05:13 AM | Permalink

Comments (6)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
Folks: Great piece, on the importance of developing one's own individual leadership style rather than blindly aping great leaders.
As a graduate of PMI's Leadership Institute Master Class (LIMC) and keen follower of Leadership myself, I have read a lot on the topic.
VUCA is a very interesting concept. "Servant Leadership" is indeed very important rather than being dictatorial.
Do keep contributing to enrich our community here!

At least in projects, top down leadership 'doesn't' work. In my experience. Leadership needs to get to the where the work is being done. Successful outcomes are what we ultimately want to drive and the only place to get those results is working where the work gets done. Leading from the top down won't get us the level of involvement we need to drive excellence.

I'm not sure I have as pessimistic a view of the business world as Mr. Craggs. I do appreciate, however, is insight.

At the end of the day, leadership is always situational. Not just at the organization level but all the way down to the individual contributors.

Thanks for sharing great article

Wonderful perspective.
Thanks for sharing!!

Will this kind of approach help us to lead the VUCA world?
Thanks for sharing

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.


"A nod's as good as a wink to a blind bat"

- Eric Idle, Monty Python's Flying Circus