Project Management Central

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Practice Areas: Agile
Can Agile Project Management Co-Exists with traditional Project Management?
Network:8543



Can Agile Project Management Co-Exists with traditional Project Management?
Sort By:
Network:271



Yes, I think so.

The obvious example is a product development project including both new hardware and new software. The main project and the hardware development sub-project may be traditional, while the software development sub-project may be agile.

Having said that. The best ways to interface between agile and traditional projects are not always obvious. Different organisations have developed different ideas about the best way to do these interfaces.
Network:573



It will be interesting how the next few years play out. Will Agile and Waterfall become more polarized, or more blended? "Bimodal" organizations are becoming more common. Is it a fad, or the future?
Network:602



Like my peers already wrote, I also can imagine a co-existence both in an organization and even in the same project. And I also think that a mix can work; my experience actually being that some of the best traditional PMs always intuitively used agile practices in the day-to-day manging of their projects...What probably won't work is to alternately assign team members to projects using different frameworks and have them switch back and forth between traditional and agile...
Network:885



I can certainly see both having their benefits dependent on your project circumstances and a blend of both styles can benefit organizations. I also wonder if one will overtake the other in the future in terms of organizational preference.
Network:1648



Yes, I discuss this topic in my article earlier this year. It's called the "shared leadership model" developed by Kitty Haas. https://www.projectmanager.com/blog/manage-a-complex-project

Projects are moving towards greater complexity so a shift must occur to a hybrid approach that is lean, agile and more flexible. Will certain projects still require waterfall approach? Yes. Will other projects require agility focused on more lean methods? Yes, Will the most complex require a new model/approach? Yes. It's already occurring so time to ramp up your skill sets.
Network:1638



Even though I'm a dedicated agilist and 100% support agile project management, I fully understand that there are still projects that fair better with traditional project management. I feel that both methods HAVE to co-exist because both have the same level of importance to project management.
Network:101



Absolutely, although in our case, it has not been an easy road. But we are very close to the "sweet spot" utilizing both methodologies.
Network:217



Yes very much because both will fit in different situation/conditions , One doesn’t fit everywhere
Network:177



I'd prefer to state it as "predictive project management can coexist with adaptive product development."

I don't change the words just to be a jerk. I can make a very thorough predictive plan that looks nothing like a waterfall, because I'll take the time to compress the schedule and find efficiencies. I don't trust plans that look like a waterfall.

Also, as we've seen, the phrase "Agile project management" leads to misunderstandings. "Predictive" and "adaptive" are the actual terms used by the PMBOK to differentiate between the two approaches. I didn't like that word choice at first, but I've come to appreciate the distinction.

But yes, in an Agile organization, there is room for predictive projects. It's an efficient way to get things done when the scope is well-defined. You can also run a successful project that's adaptive or emergent within a more traditional organization, but it will be more successful within an Agile environment.

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Technology is a gift of God. After the gift of life it is perhaps the greatest of God's gifts. It is the mother of civilizations, of arts and of sciences."

- Freeman Dyson

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors