Project Management Central

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Topics: PM in Academia, Schedule Management, Scheduling
Critical path using Start to start
Network:841



Are there any scenarios we need to calculate critical path for Start to start types
Of activities. Please share.
Sort By:
Network:1558



With an SS dependency, unless there is a significant lead or lag, generally only one of the two activities would be on your critical path...

Remember that CP relates to the overall network diagram for the project and not just to a pair of tasks.

Kiron
Network:0



0. Start to start is a type of relationship/restraint/dependency, not a type of activity.

1. There are many scenarios where SS relationships are useful to model workflow in summary, where the detail necessary to use FS relationships is not justified. Then SS+lag is applied where the lag represents a certain volume of predecessor work that must be done before the successor can start. The lag may be only a millisecond, but the precedence exists nonetheless.

1a. A negative lag (i.e. a "lead") with a SS relationship seems almost exclusively for date-manipulation. I would question the underlying logic basis.

2. Whether one or both activities are on the Critical Path depends on upstream (predecessor) and downstream (successor) logic for both activities. There is nothing special about the SS relationship in the CPM/PDM calculations.

3. If a) the SS relationship actually drives the successor and b) the successor's downstream logic places it on the critical path, then most modern CPM software will also assign the predecessor to the critical path. The whole bar is colored red, though in fact only the start should be considered "critical."
Network:15


Retained Logic vs Progress Override In Primavera P6 PDF
https://bibloteka.com/retained-logic-vs-progress-override/
Network:319



Start to Start is a very common relationship. The most common types I can think of are where Group B requires some input from Group A to begin their own tasks, prior to the completion of Group A's deliverable. For example:

Group A is responsible for the design of a product. Group B is responsible to plan the production of the product. Group B cannot start planning production, until Group A has started the design, or there is nothing to base the production plan on.

This is often on the critical path, because the two were scheduled in parallel rather than series in order to save time. Otherwise, Group A could complete their work prior to Group B beginning.
Network:0

Sorry, to break the chain.
I have a question on best method to calculate forwards and backwards pass. My exam is a few days away but I still cannot resolve my challenge on these passes. Any help somewhere will be appreciated.

Regards
Network:117



Start to start is indeed quite often the "natural" link but if it is used without proper care then it generates open networks!
PDM will generate a critical path!
But, if you only use this link type then the critical path will be based largely on dependencies and not on tasks!
regards

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

A celebrity is a person who works hard all his life to become known, then wears dark glasses to avoid being recognized.

- Fred Allen

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors

Vendor Events

See all Vendor Events