Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Is change evaluation a part of the process "perform integrated change control"?

linkedin twitter facebook  
avatar
Yan Wu Trainer/Consultant| Changeway Management Consulting Co., Ltd. Beijing, China, Mainland
When talking about perform integrated change control and overall change control process, we always tell that we need to have a formal-written change request from external stakeholders, and then evaluate the request to make the decision; or have a change from team members, evaluate it first, then write it down and put it for approval.
But what is then meaning of change request as an input for process 4.6 of PMBOK? Does it contain the evaluation (schedule, cost, resources, risks,etc.) or we just evaluate it during 4.6?
Some people told me that the same group of people get the evalutaion done and approve them. I consider it impossible.
What's your point or your idea of training this point?
Sort By:
< 1 2 >
avatar
Yan Wu Trainer/Consultant| Changeway Management Consulting Co., Ltd. Beijing, China, Mainland
Dec 02, 2019 4:55 PM
Replying to Keith Novak
...
The PMBOK is written to cover all cases from the largest to the smallest so in reality not everything applies every time.

Not all changes require a formal request or approval. What is required depends on the organization's standards, and the specifics of the change. Consider a very small change early in a project. It might be within the authority of a work group to make that change on their own authority.

To decide that they can make the change without any other approver requires that they actually reviewed it themselves to determine that it meets the organization's requirements. It is still an integrated change, because you decided that no external impacts mean no further integration is necessary. Even if another group must authorize the change, ALL changes must be reviewed by the party requesting the change before they are presented to anyone else for review.

You woudn't ask someone else to review your work before first checking it for errors. If a change had to go through multiple boards such as team level, functional level, and executive level, each reviews their own change request prior to moving to the next level. Often, there may be a checklist or some set of requirements such as cost data, schedule impact, etc. that accompany the change request.

In fact, how well you review your own work will set the expectations for how much others feel they need to review it. If you always go to a change board with all important aspects considered, you will have more trust and get less oversight over time than if you are someone who requests changes with many open questions.
Great many thanks to your detailed explaination, and got clearer about how to explain the communication to stakeholders during change control flow. See, I used to pratice it the very same way, but don't got a clue about how to train it in PMP training:)
Really appreciate your sharing!
avatar
Yan Wu Trainer/Consultant| Changeway Management Consulting Co., Ltd. Beijing, China, Mainland
Dec 02, 2019 5:45 PM
Replying to Komal Mathur
...
Dear Yan

A change can be requested by any stakeholder.

the impact of change on project objectives is evaluated by the project team

the CCB gives approval

so change request is input to 4.6 Perform ICC and approved CR is output
Thanks for your reply, Komal.
You're right, it's clear what 4.6 does. I just confused about when CR comes to 4.6, what we are willing to do. I wonder if when a CR goest to 4.6, we want a decision right away, so we need to finish the evaluation before 4,6.
avatar
Sergio Luis Conte Helping to create solutions for everyone| Worldwide based Organizations Buenos Aires, Argentina
Dec 03, 2019 9:59 PM
Replying to Yan Wu
...
Thanks for you reply, Sergio.
So you mentioned about any formal change request need to be applied to the project manager, and pm will leader the analyze and make a decision. Got it somehow.
You are welcome. Not exactly. What I said is the PM is accountable for running the defined project change mangement process.
< 1 2 >

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

I don't have a good apartment for an intervention. The furniture, it's very non-confrontational.

- Jerry Seinfeld

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors