Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Putting a Project On-Hold, pros and cons, how much to accept a cost increase?

linkedin twitter facebook   Cost Management   Portfolio Management   Strategy  
avatar
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones Program Manager Director| Independent Professional - Sr Project Management Advisor Cuautitlán Izcalli, Estado De Mexico, Mexico
Does anyone has any definition or criteria to declare a Project on hold, what could be pros and cons of putting it on hold (as sometimes due to regulatory issues or Customer delays, it is not possible to progress with Project) and also any criteria to accept cost increase as a maximum in a Project already in progress?
Sort By:
< 1 2 3 >
avatar
Drew Craig Sr. Agile & Product Coach| Vanguard Philadelphia, Pa, United States
I'd be cautious with the inherent risk associated. What will the cost of delay be? Will the same team be available once the project begins again? With the intent of the project remain viable? Should the project be postponed or canceled?

Questions to consider....
...
1 reply by Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
Jan 06, 2020 7:12 PM
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
...
Hi Andrew,

Assuming no more activities will be done until it is resumed, how do you think there would be a cost for delay? it shouldn´t, or do you foresee any reason in particular?

Also, what happens here is that project is postponed only, and the same team is expected to be available when it is resumed.

Thank you for your comments

Best regards
MC
avatar
Asif Gul Consultant Project Manager| Energoprojekt Entel Muscat, Oman
Project can be halted due to several internal as well as external reasons/factors and the its halting declaration clauses can be defined in its plan or contract .Putting a project on hold have many pros & cons. In my opinion i summarize few below:

Pro: 1-No further Cost and resources to be invested. May be some minor cost involved in post halt review & monitoring.
2- Manpower, Equipment & other resources engaged on Project can be diverted to other projects or objectives
3- Time to review & decide on the Business Case, feasibility & Alignment of Project its strategic objectives.

Cons:1- Lost of Key Project Team, historical data or information due to any reason during halt.
2-Increase in Cost of Project due to Inflation or any other change of external condition.i.e. Economic, Legal , Approval & Permits
3- Any contractual , legal or Statutory repercussion of Project halting decision.

Increase in cost due Project on hold can be defined in contract or if not then should be evaluated on the basis of actual factors therein.i.e. Inflation, Imposition of taxes, new requirements introduced. One party can claim Idle charges also if it has kept resources on hold.
...
1 reply by Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
Jan 06, 2020 7:21 PM
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
...
Hi Asif

Thank you for your comments, we usually maintain our costs to Customer as per the Contract clausules so, in case of internal resource costs are increased we could talk about a real impact that the Business unit should absorve, projects usually are declared on hold for 3 to 6 months the most... so far

Best regards
MC
avatar
Sergio Luis Conte Helping to create solutions for everyone| Worldwide based Organizations Buenos Aires, Argentina
Dec 04, 2019 4:49 PM
Replying to Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
...
Muchas gracias Sergio,

En este caso aplica

¿ Tiene sentido estratégico, técnico, financiero ? SI,
¿ Se obtiene la calidad esperada ? SI hasta ahora lo que se ha evaluado.
¿ Tenemos el dinero y gente disponible ? SI:
Prioridad alta, entonces Continue, pero hay dependencias externas que lo impiden.
Prioridad baja, entonces Hold, Es prioridad Alta
Que un proyecto pase a Hold no quiere decir que ocasiones mayores costos. De hecho, no deberia ser asi.... Coincido totalmente aunque se perdería lo invertido hasta ahora mientras se define si continua, pero al no haber recursos asignados no debería haber mayor costo o incrementos.

Saludos cordiales,
Si lo pones on hold no se pierde lo invertido hasta ahora porque generaste entregables de algun tipo y eso fue inversion. Esto es valido a menos que estes generando algo que se degrada con el tiempo y entonces el periodo de on hold debe ser considerado en ese sentido. Como vos estas contestando a todo SI entonces no deberia estar on hold. Las prioridades externas, cuales son? Por ejemplo, nos pasa casos donde hay relacion con otras iniciativas y entonces vamos a los otros program managers/project managers a acordar sobre las prioridades y a veces resulta que "on hold" tiene que ser puesto el programa/proyecto que ellos llevan (vos sabes como es, todos quieren terminar el proyecto. No es mi caso, para mi el objetivo de todos esta por encima porque si no todos nos hacemos mal). Pero bueno, para ser sincero, yo estoy dando datos sin tener mas infomracion para evaluar. Sobre todo que, como diria mi abuela "cada lugar es un mundo". De todas formas, el script que puse ahi es el proceso estandar que se sigue en cada stage gate no mas que eso. Es decir, hay que ajustarlo "al hogar" de cada uno. Te digo, en el ultimo año, he estado a cargo de programas/proyectos prioridad uno (por ejemplo, eran imposiciones del gobierno tales como cambio de moneda) en paises de la region y de algunas partes del mundo donde la situación del país era un infierno. Asi y todo, salieron en tiempo y forma con el menor impacto para la gente que participaba del proyecto. Quiero decir, en mi experiencia personal, las circunstancias externas siempre pueden tener una mitigacion.
avatar
Abdelhamid CHELGHOUM Project construction manager | Sonatrach group Batna, Batna, Algeria
Dear Mario,
Not an easy question, but depending on situations, the best is to finish the project or close out, on hold can cost a huge money
Thanks
Hamid
...
1 reply by Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
Jan 06, 2020 7:23 PM
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
...
Hi Adbelhamid

What are the specific reasons or circumstances you think we could have a cost increase?

Thank you in advance,

Best regards
MC
avatar
Melissa Antoniano Technical Project Manager| Nokia Colorado Springs, CO, United States
In my world, there are a few reasons we put projects on hold. I work on In-Building Cellular projects, so we've had instances where the customer contracts with us to do the work, awards us a PO, but then is unable to gain access or agreement from the venue to allow them/us to do our work. So we keep it on our books as something that "might" happen, and do regular check-ins with the customer via email. We don't assign resources or expend time on projects like this.

We have another flavor of "on hold" in that we've done our work, and we're waiting on customer response. In essence we are still "working" the project because we have to do follow-ups frequently to nudge them to respond/accept. In that case, it's more that the project team is on hold, rather than the project itself.

The other reasons projects can be put on hold is simply because we can't accomplish the work at this time due to resources or access or lack of documentation, but we can schedule it for a month from now.


1) the customer is waiting
...
1 reply by Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
Jan 06, 2020 7:34 PM
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
...
Hi Melissa

Those cases you listed are very similar to us, we don´t assign any project resource until we have the official go and project scope and schedule is already agreed and formalized.

for the other flavor you mention, that´s the specific example I wanted to hear about as we do the same but was not sure if that´s the best practice, actually I´d add due to regulatory issues, we need to wait for a decision.

Thank you,

Best regards
MC
avatar
Wade Harshman Scrum Master| GDIT Indianapolis, In, United States
There are many valid reasons for putting a project on hold. The reason I've most often seen is that the people or resources needed for the project are needed more on a different, more important (or more urgent) project. The stakeholders don't want to cancel the project, but they accept their lower priority.

There are many costs of delay. After all, projects typically have some sort of financial goal or metrics. But any project that's been placed on hold has a very significant risk that it will never resume. It's already been de-prioritized once, and will take significant effort to resume activities.
...
1 reply by Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
Jan 06, 2020 7:48 PM
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones
...
Hi Wade,

Thank you for your comments, would you mind to list some costs of delay you are referring to?

Thank you in advance,

Best regards
MC
avatar
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones Program Manager Director| Independent Professional - Sr Project Management Advisor Cuautitlán Izcalli, Estado De Mexico, Mexico
Dec 04, 2019 7:52 PM
Replying to Drew Craig
...
I'd be cautious with the inherent risk associated. What will the cost of delay be? Will the same team be available once the project begins again? With the intent of the project remain viable? Should the project be postponed or canceled?

Questions to consider....
Hi Andrew,

Assuming no more activities will be done until it is resumed, how do you think there would be a cost for delay? it shouldn´t, or do you foresee any reason in particular?

Also, what happens here is that project is postponed only, and the same team is expected to be available when it is resumed.

Thank you for your comments

Best regards
MC
avatar
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones Program Manager Director| Independent Professional - Sr Project Management Advisor Cuautitlán Izcalli, Estado De Mexico, Mexico
Dec 04, 2019 11:44 PM
Replying to Asif Gul
...
Project can be halted due to several internal as well as external reasons/factors and the its halting declaration clauses can be defined in its plan or contract .Putting a project on hold have many pros & cons. In my opinion i summarize few below:

Pro: 1-No further Cost and resources to be invested. May be some minor cost involved in post halt review & monitoring.
2- Manpower, Equipment & other resources engaged on Project can be diverted to other projects or objectives
3- Time to review & decide on the Business Case, feasibility & Alignment of Project its strategic objectives.

Cons:1- Lost of Key Project Team, historical data or information due to any reason during halt.
2-Increase in Cost of Project due to Inflation or any other change of external condition.i.e. Economic, Legal , Approval & Permits
3- Any contractual , legal or Statutory repercussion of Project halting decision.

Increase in cost due Project on hold can be defined in contract or if not then should be evaluated on the basis of actual factors therein.i.e. Inflation, Imposition of taxes, new requirements introduced. One party can claim Idle charges also if it has kept resources on hold.
Hi Asif

Thank you for your comments, we usually maintain our costs to Customer as per the Contract clausules so, in case of internal resource costs are increased we could talk about a real impact that the Business unit should absorve, projects usually are declared on hold for 3 to 6 months the most... so far

Best regards
MC
avatar
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones Program Manager Director| Independent Professional - Sr Project Management Advisor Cuautitlán Izcalli, Estado De Mexico, Mexico
Dec 05, 2019 9:50 AM
Replying to Abdelhamid CHELGHOUM
...
Dear Mario,
Not an easy question, but depending on situations, the best is to finish the project or close out, on hold can cost a huge money
Thanks
Hamid
Hi Adbelhamid

What are the specific reasons or circumstances you think we could have a cost increase?

Thank you in advance,

Best regards
MC
avatar
Mario Ernesto Cadena Briones Program Manager Director| Independent Professional - Sr Project Management Advisor Cuautitlán Izcalli, Estado De Mexico, Mexico
Dec 05, 2019 12:51 PM
Replying to Melissa Antoniano
...
In my world, there are a few reasons we put projects on hold. I work on In-Building Cellular projects, so we've had instances where the customer contracts with us to do the work, awards us a PO, but then is unable to gain access or agreement from the venue to allow them/us to do our work. So we keep it on our books as something that "might" happen, and do regular check-ins with the customer via email. We don't assign resources or expend time on projects like this.

We have another flavor of "on hold" in that we've done our work, and we're waiting on customer response. In essence we are still "working" the project because we have to do follow-ups frequently to nudge them to respond/accept. In that case, it's more that the project team is on hold, rather than the project itself.

The other reasons projects can be put on hold is simply because we can't accomplish the work at this time due to resources or access or lack of documentation, but we can schedule it for a month from now.


1) the customer is waiting
Hi Melissa

Those cases you listed are very similar to us, we don´t assign any project resource until we have the official go and project scope and schedule is already agreed and formalized.

for the other flavor you mention, that´s the specific example I wanted to hear about as we do the same but was not sure if that´s the best practice, actually I´d add due to regulatory issues, we need to wait for a decision.

Thank you,

Best regards
MC
< 1 2 3 >

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Four be the things I am wiser to know: Idleness, sorrow, a friend, and a foe."

- Dorothy Parker

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors