Andrew SoswaTechnology leader| Leading global financial institutionElk Grove Village, Il, United States
I propose that we petition PMI to create "PMI Agile Project Manager".
Creating PMI-DA waters down PMI-ACP and creating PMPv7 with Agile component is muddling the understanding what each cert is. HR recruiters know what PMP is but when I try to explain PMI-ACP, they look at me crazy until I tell them "it's like CSM".
"PMI Agile Project Manager" is easier to market because it is more recognizable by everyone.
How can I create and run this petition? Saving Changes...
Interestingly they cite Shu- Ha- Ri, which theme I addressed in a topic
Luis -
That is the current state.
As I mentioned, those of us who participated in the train-the-trainer session were given a sneak peak at what's coming in 2020 and I can assure you that the plans they shared reflected a number of additional certifications...
Kiron Saving Changes...
Luis BrancoCEO| Business Insight, Consultores de Gestão, LdªCarcavelos, Lisboa, Portugal
After these news (confusion in my humble opinion) what will happen to PMI-ACP certification? What about the people who passed the PMI-ACP certification exam?
...
1 reply by Kiron Bondale
Dec 29, 2019 6:35 AM
Kiron Bondale
...
Luis -
I've previously shared concerns similar to yours with the PMI folks most directly involved with DA - they feel that there is room in the PMI "stable" for multiple agile certifications and that the ACP and DA certifications are not competing with one another.
My assumption is that 2020 will be an "inspect & adapt" year as is usually the case whenever an acquisition has been made...
Senior Projects Manager | Field & Marten AssociatesNew Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
Dec 28, 2019 5:46 AM
Replying to Alexandre Costa
...
After a little more of research I noticed this changes in the site of Discipline Agile, which are remarkable surprising.
How to Become a Certified Disciplined Agile Practitioner (CDAP) ___________________________________________________ Step 1: Earn your CDA designation after 31 December 2019
Step 2: Earn your PMI-ACP - or - Gain 2 years of agile team experience, in any role
Step 3: Submit your application form and pass your reference checks CONGRATULATIONS
Senior Projects Manager | Field & Marten AssociatesNew Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
Dec 28, 2019 5:22 AM
Replying to Alexandre Costa
...
I have both certifications PMI-ACP and CSM.
I will leave here my thougths, in a european comercial perspective and really try to bring the truth ( at least my true) before diplomacie, could be controversial, you may not agree but i believe that the general feeling in most of the european union. I am not trying to discuss the merit of the certifications but the actual comercial value in my environment.
- In Europe the CSM has more value (comercial) than ACP, never saw asking a certification of ACP as good to have in a job on the other hand CSM or CSPO are commonly asked in Agile projects jobs, many times are mandatory. - Spoke many times with HR recruiters they do not understand the meaning of the PMI-ACP, is a Agile leader, is a Agile project manager, is only someone who kowns how to work in Agile environments, is a practicioner, could be only a team member like a developer. - CSM like PMP are crystal clear roles. - PMI-ACP is an approach to several agile and lean frameworks, methodologies, lifecycles what ever you want to call, enphasizing the techniques being used, as a practicioner , leader ( several kinds of leadship), project manager, Scrum master, Agile leader, the performance of the team , the behavior of the leader etc.. ( so it's all, but at the same time nothing in specific, very generalist ) - At government level (at least in Portugal) where is mandatory to have a certification to lead a public project the PMI-ACP is not valid, only with PMP, PRINCE 2,IPMA level C you can apply or be selected to this position. - Due to market needs and demands, IPMA has developed the certification of Agile Leader becoming a step ahead of PMI in this domain in my opinion. The position is clear and the objective is to lead Agile projects. - Discipline Agile has no expression in Europe.
I have to agree with @Adrew Soswa, at least the PMI-ACP , should be called PMI Agile Leader at least in a comercial perspective, if you think that the certification evaluate that skills.
The DA Lean Project Manager annouced by @Kiron it will send to second plan the PM-ACP certification in a comercial perspective.
Alexandre Costa
Alexandre
Interesting. I am not very familiar of how things work in Europe. However, I am a member of a project management organization in Europe based out of Germany and they do value the PMI-ACP.
On another note, regarding your first point, how does CSM add value to industries like Real Estate Development or Construction ?
Senior Projects Manager | Field & Marten AssociatesNew Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
Dec 28, 2019 9:36 AM
Replying to Kiron Bondale
...
Rami - I definitely agree with not having the "PMI-" before the certification names. It is inconsistent (the PMP, PgMP & CAPM don't have these) and it makes it that much harder to list all achieved credentials when dealing with online forms that have fixed, low limit fields for names or suffixes.
Kiron
Kiron
I totally agree and that's why I was never in favor of it and if I would participate in a petition, it would be to drop this from ACP, RMP, SP and PBA certifications.
Senior Projects Manager | Field & Marten AssociatesNew Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
Dec 28, 2019 9:52 AM
Replying to Alexandre Costa
...
@Kiron
I'm sure that removing the PMI in the beginning it will not improve the knowledge of the HR recruiters about what is ACP. I think that is the concern pointed by Andrew S.
The main problem i see here is when the time comes, the members will decide if spent money in renewing the certification brings value or if the same money spent in other certification more well known by the market will be a best bet.
Alexandre Costa
Alexandre
Again, in North America, ACP is reasonably known. Don't forget that it is also a fairly new certification.
On another note, the driver for reneweing shouldn't be the market but how much this credential adds value to you as a professional. If my voice counts, the I can confidentantly assure you that it added lots of value to me as a professional.
RK
...
1 reply by Alexandre Costa
Dec 28, 2019 6:30 PM
Alexandre Costa
...
Rami, I always appreciate your toughs,
You should know for a fact that in most of Europe, generally outside software area, the big companies give great value to IMPA or PRINCE2 project management certifications on the other side in Software PMI takes advantage in project management. There is fierce competition between the two institutions.
In Europe in Software domain ACP has not build reputation yet, this does not mean that in one or other country of Europe it has no value or is not known. But I am currently seeing ACP certification being a platform for DA certifications and I am not comfortable with that path.
PMI-ACP in Portugal and adjacent countries is not known in fact i am constantly explaining to HR and to my pears the meaning of the certification, It's not really valued in UK my company head quarters and much less in Japan where is the main heart of my organization ( mechatronics ).
So imagine that now i decided pursue DA certification i will suffer the same problem 1 - Is not generally known by my pears and by HR in my country and near by. 2 - Has not an installed training base, only through virtual classes or workshops is possible to take certifications. 3 - It was going to take the trouble to evangelize others in DA (A lot of hard work, and i am not a recognized coach in the area like @Kiron and i understand is position because is defending is bet) 4 - If PMI is making ACP a ramp for DA certifications what is the future objective of this certification, I did valued the certification when I toked but now the current path is showing that value is being loosed in favor of DA.
Certainly you understand my concerns in this area, now it's all a bit confused, without perception of direction in the future. Probably in the future i will choose my certification more careful, because they must worth our time, money and at same time be an investment in our career and knowledge.
Do not forget the value of a PMI-ACP certification is 400 dollars with 200 dollars you can take the CDAP- Certified Discipline Agile Practitioner if I am not mistaken.
Alexandre Costa
Saving Changes...
Alexandre CostaScrum Master| Integer Consulting - Pictet technologiesLoures, Portugal
Dec 28, 2019 4:23 PM
Replying to Rami Kaibni
...
Alexandre
Again, in North America, ACP is reasonably known. Don't forget that it is also a fairly new certification.
On another note, the driver for reneweing shouldn't be the market but how much this credential adds value to you as a professional. If my voice counts, the I can confidentantly assure you that it added lots of value to me as a professional.
RK
Rami, I always appreciate your toughs,
You should know for a fact that in most of Europe, generally outside software area, the big companies give great value to IMPA or PRINCE2 project management certifications on the other side in Software PMI takes advantage in project management. There is fierce competition between the two institutions.
In Europe in Software domain ACP has not build reputation yet, this does not mean that in one or other country of Europe it has no value or is not known. But I am currently seeing ACP certification being a platform for DA certifications and I am not comfortable with that path.
PMI-ACP in Portugal and adjacent countries is not known in fact i am constantly explaining to HR and to my pears the meaning of the certification, It's not really valued in UK my company head quarters and much less in Japan where is the main heart of my organization ( mechatronics ).
So imagine that now i decided pursue DA certification i will suffer the same problem 1 - Is not generally known by my pears and by HR in my country and near by. 2 - Has not an installed training base, only through virtual classes or workshops is possible to take certifications. 3 - It was going to take the trouble to evangelize others in DA (A lot of hard work, and i am not a recognized coach in the area like @Kiron and i understand is position because is defending is bet) 4 - If PMI is making ACP a ramp for DA certifications what is the future objective of this certification, I did valued the certification when I toked but now the current path is showing that value is being loosed in favor of DA.
Certainly you understand my concerns in this area, now it's all a bit confused, without perception of direction in the future. Probably in the future i will choose my certification more careful, because they must worth our time, money and at same time be an investment in our career and knowledge.
Do not forget the value of a PMI-ACP certification is 400 dollars with 200 dollars you can take the CDAP- Certified Discipline Agile Practitioner if I am not mistaken.
Alexandre Costa
...
1 reply by Rami Kaibni
Dec 28, 2019 7:52 PM
Rami Kaibni
...
Alexandre
Thanks for your clarification. Of course I do understand and appreicate your conern about the ACP but I can't comment much until their official announcement is there and we know exactly how things will shape up so we shall wait and see.
Senior Projects Manager | Field & Marten AssociatesNew Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
Dec 28, 2019 6:30 PM
Replying to Alexandre Costa
...
Rami, I always appreciate your toughs,
You should know for a fact that in most of Europe, generally outside software area, the big companies give great value to IMPA or PRINCE2 project management certifications on the other side in Software PMI takes advantage in project management. There is fierce competition between the two institutions.
In Europe in Software domain ACP has not build reputation yet, this does not mean that in one or other country of Europe it has no value or is not known. But I am currently seeing ACP certification being a platform for DA certifications and I am not comfortable with that path.
PMI-ACP in Portugal and adjacent countries is not known in fact i am constantly explaining to HR and to my pears the meaning of the certification, It's not really valued in UK my company head quarters and much less in Japan where is the main heart of my organization ( mechatronics ).
So imagine that now i decided pursue DA certification i will suffer the same problem 1 - Is not generally known by my pears and by HR in my country and near by. 2 - Has not an installed training base, only through virtual classes or workshops is possible to take certifications. 3 - It was going to take the trouble to evangelize others in DA (A lot of hard work, and i am not a recognized coach in the area like @Kiron and i understand is position because is defending is bet) 4 - If PMI is making ACP a ramp for DA certifications what is the future objective of this certification, I did valued the certification when I toked but now the current path is showing that value is being loosed in favor of DA.
Certainly you understand my concerns in this area, now it's all a bit confused, without perception of direction in the future. Probably in the future i will choose my certification more careful, because they must worth our time, money and at same time be an investment in our career and knowledge.
Do not forget the value of a PMI-ACP certification is 400 dollars with 200 dollars you can take the CDAP- Certified Discipline Agile Practitioner if I am not mistaken.
Alexandre Costa
Alexandre
Thanks for your clarification. Of course I do understand and appreicate your conern about the ACP but I can't comment much until their official announcement is there and we know exactly how things will shape up so we shall wait and see.
Happy New Year.
RK Saving Changes...
Luis BrancoCEO| Business Insight, Consultores de Gestão, LdªCarcavelos, Lisboa, Portugal
Getting back to the PMI-ACP issue
An analysis perspective:
In September 2019 PMI-ACP certified 30,507 people
Certification costs per person: 21 hours of training + hours of study + $ 495.00 (exam) = $ 2500.00 (lowest cost)
About $ 77,000,000.00 cost for certificates and $ 15,101,000.00 direct to PMI
Can PMI afford to end this certification?
...
1 reply by Rami Kaibni
Dec 29, 2019 12:53 PM
Rami Kaibni
...
Luis
Not sure those calculations are very accurate. It does cost much lower than that. This is how much it did cost me:
Exam Fee: $435 (PMI Member) Course on Udemy: $25 Simulation Exams on PM PrepCast: $100 Hours of Study: $0 (This is personal time, not working hours)
Total = $560 USD
By the way, just for your info, as per the 2018 financial report of PMI (Which is published publicaly), there received $203,532,837 Million just from Dues and Professional Examination Fees. That's almost 25 Million more than 2017.
Hope this makes sense.
RK
Saving Changes...
Luis BrancoCEO| Business Insight, Consultores de Gestão, LdªCarcavelos, Lisboa, Portugal
My take on PMI certification rebranding
PMI had one key product of its offering (PMP Certification)
Following a product line extension strategy created: CAPM, PgMP, PfMP
Pursuing its strategy of increasing supply, now extending the range (but being careful to offer the PMI brand as a quality assurance), it created PMI-RMP, PMI-SP, PMI-ACP and PMI-BA.
Care has always been taken to update the PMBOK Guide, the project management reference guide, including new techniques and tools and / or processes and / or approaches to projects, ensuring that PMP certification remains the reference product for PMI.
Care was also taken in the content of the certification exam questions, ensuring high selection criteria.
What will the new PMBOK Guide look like?
What will the new PMP certification exams look like?
What will come next after the acquisition of DA and Flex?
In my humble opinion, DA and Flex certifications should not be included in the PMI offering. Should stay in AD
The risk of losing focus and losing market value has to be equated
...
1 reply by Alexandre Costa
Dec 29, 2019 7:19 AM
Alexandre Costa
...
I am waiting to see what surprises PMI will anouce, but for sure my plans for the next year are already made with several possible paths, I will evaluate possible scenarios until March ( time to renovate membership).
I love PMI reputation, knowledge and community, but i can tell you as confidence that one of the paths( pessimitisc path) is if PMI-ACP becomes a subset of Discipline Agile, if that really happens i have no alternative in pursuit other certification as replacement. It will not be Discipline Agile for sure, i love the concept but in europe, it as no expression is mostly unknown and does not add value to the eyes of HR and labor market at least for now.
I was expecting as strategy that PMI start using the local chapters to increase reputation of DA and dissiminate trainings options, using local experienced members and turn them into trainers, but until now that is not a reality. My feeling until now is that neither PMI knows exactly the path that will follow. Without information we only can backup in feelings and perceptions.
For me it's a weekness PMI not involve more the local chapters in
the training of new certifications.
I whish you the best and to all community and a great 2020 for everybody.