Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Process Automation Vs Human Resource Dilemmas

linkedin twitter facebook   Change Management   Construction   Ethics  
avatar
Albert Agbemenu Managing Director| Seag Focus Ghana Ltd Accra, Ghana
As a project manager, you will face situations that would require making a difficult choice between two courses of action, neither of which might be acceptable nor preferable. Today, there are a reasonable number of mining company’s globally working towards achieving 100% automation and project managers leading these projects may encounter ethical dilemmas relating to technology and human resources.

These ethical dilemmas arise when situations conflict with the Project Manager's Professional Standards or moral values. How will a Project Manager create a balance between local content laws that requires hiring of majority of human resources from the local community as against 100% automation of process. Does the Ethical Decision-Making Framework (EDMF) create an opportunity to resolve this dilemma? Please share your thoughts….
Sort By:
< 1 2 >
avatar
Albert Agbemenu Managing Director| Seag Focus Ghana Ltd Accra, Ghana
Mar 19, 2021 5:09 AM
Replying to Adela Tataru
...
I do not believe that automation equals no more human resources.

Usually automation means changing the way things are done and may require different competencies for the human resources.

The key is to evaluate the impact of the automation on the current jobs and plan a training initiative to re-coach the employees who were there to fill in the gaps when automation didn't exist.

This is a continuous debate, most of the time in conjuncture of AI development in the past year. The thing is that everything in today's world moves at a hallucinating speed and we need to adapt. But it does not mean there will not be jobs, it just means that jobs will change and in order to survive, companies will have to train their employees into these new jobs, otherwise they loose. Having the latest technologies without having experts that can maintain, evolve or adapt them will not bring anything to an enterprise.
Adela,

You have very valid points there. However, the impact of this situation will vary for various geographical locations. For example, the impact in a developed country will be completely different from that of a developing or under developed country.
avatar
Anton Oosthuizen Senior Business Analyst / Project Manager| Self Employed Pretoria, Gauteng, South Africa
As many others have pointed out, automation does not need to mean reducing staff, it could mean reskilling. But that aside, automating processes should not create an ethical dilemma for the PM. It is the function of the PM to implement projects that will bring improvement. Improvement to whom? Primarily business. If the automation of a process means that there will be staff cuts it will be more a personal issue for the PM and not a professional ethical issue. Personally, you might feel differently about the impact that your project has on different individuals but that is a matter entirely.
...
1 reply by Albert Agbemenu
Mar 23, 2021 6:26 AM
Albert Agbemenu
...
Hello Anton,

Very valid point. Thanks for your feedback.
avatar
Albert Agbemenu Managing Director| Seag Focus Ghana Ltd Accra, Ghana
Mar 23, 2021 4:51 AM
Replying to Anton Oosthuizen
...
As many others have pointed out, automation does not need to mean reducing staff, it could mean reskilling. But that aside, automating processes should not create an ethical dilemma for the PM. It is the function of the PM to implement projects that will bring improvement. Improvement to whom? Primarily business. If the automation of a process means that there will be staff cuts it will be more a personal issue for the PM and not a professional ethical issue. Personally, you might feel differently about the impact that your project has on different individuals but that is a matter entirely.
Hello Anton,

Very valid point. Thanks for your feedback.
avatar
Albert Agbemenu Managing Director| Seag Focus Ghana Ltd Accra, Ghana
Mar 17, 2021 9:12 AM
Replying to Kwiyuh Michael Wepngong
...
Hi Albert, this is quite a hard nut to crack... I think deploying an automation process shouldn't translate to not filling resources with local content... I think getting a balance is better
I agree with you
< 1 2 >

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Don't play the saxophone. Let it play you."

- Charlie Parker

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors