Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Project Charter - Set in stone or living document?

linkedin twitter facebook   Agile  
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
We all are aware of what Project Charter is. For the most part, Project Charter is a formal document that marks the initiation of a project. It defines its objectives, scope, stakeholders, high-level risks, budget, etc. It serves as a foundational guide to get the project started and throughout the project, ensuring the project is aligned with initial goals. 

However, the static or dynamic nature of the Charter can create confusion amongst the project team and stakeholders, and more so with the organization. So, the question is, should the project Charter evolve through the project lifecycle, or should it be a document for one-time reference? A static charter can help prevent scope creep by keeping everyone focused on the initial objectives and agreed-upon points. However, projects rarely unfold exactly as planned. A dynamic charter allows adjustments to reflect changing circumstances.

Would like to know your thoughts. What factors impact the Charter and changes if needed?
Sort By:
< 1 2 3 >
avatar
George Freeman Thought Leader | Author | Architect| Florida, United States
Dr. Deepa,

Although the components of a “project charter package” vary dramatically based on industry, organizational structure, risk tolerance, maturity level, and the like. The core purpose of a charter, as generically derived from Merriam-Webster, is to “establish and convey the power and function of an entity,” which is how I have always understood and explained it to others in project management.

Hence, the static purpose of the charter is to “Authorize and Empower” a project.

===== My definition =====
A charter is a “corporate political device” that uses executive fiat to authorize a project and commission its chief executive (i.e., the project manager) with explicit bounded authority to assemble, manage, and direct organizational resources to achieve the project’s defined objectives, deliverables, and goals.

Although the above is the core purpose, the project charter can also contain the functional project collaterals known at its creation. Bound together as a package (i.e., the project charter package) via a single document with a well-formed table of contents or as individual documents.

George
...
1 reply by Dr. Deepa Bhide
Jul 31, 2024 12:06 PM
Dr. Deepa Bhide
...
Thanks George for your comment and I agree with you on the definition and proposed form of the Charter.
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Jul 21, 2024 4:35 PM
Replying to Keith Novak
...
I completely agree with Sergio that it depends on how your organization uses the charter but more importantly, how can YOU use the charter to your best advantage.

Often, it is a static document that is never revised however the specifics of what is to be done are governed by the change management processes. As a PM, I look at the charter as my tool to gain the support of senior stakeholders. The names on the charter are who formally agreed to support the project so that is who's help I will seek if and when necessary.

Revising the charter is tantamount to the "nuclear option". It is where I would formally ask all the senior stakeholders who already signed up to supporting the project to either make a major change in scope, or force the hand of another senior stakeholder who isn't providing adequate support.

I'm not just asking for the support of the needed organization at that point. I am elevating an issue to the highest level of authority who already approved my plan of action and formally asking them to declare, in writing to their peers and superiors, and in front of everyone involved that they WILL provide the support so that I, as the executor may complete my assigned job.
Keith, I agree with you. Your comment brings up a valuable point of stakeholder buy-in on a continual basis, holding them accountable for the project objectives. I also agree that the Charter is not what it means to the stakeholders but what it means to you as a project manager and what of it will help you make the project a success. Thanks for your valuable comment.
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Jul 21, 2024 10:24 PM
Replying to Dr. Widline Compere
...
I concur with the comments made by others, and I would like to add that project charters help maintain the core project goal. When an organization is using an Agile framework, for example, there may be some adjustments to the project charter without compromising the core objectives that have been agreed upon.
Widline, that's exactly my point too. It is that sacrosanct document that got the project formally started. Let alone the changes that will take place and will do so should they be needed, there has to be one point that someone can reference as an "original copy"! Thanks for your valuable comment.
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Jul 22, 2024 4:59 PM
Replying to Sergio Luis Conte
...
That´s because it is an "art" to write the charter. Objectives must be write with a level of abstraction good enough that what change are the things derived from them but not the objectives itself. If the objectives change then the initiative has not sense and must be canceled. So, it has not sense that the charter has to be modified.
Thanks again for reinforcing the point. Having a few examples of how we can write a good charter that lends itself to its objectives and changes as needed...downstream would be good. It will help project managers see where they may be going regarding creating a Charter.
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Jul 22, 2024 3:32 PM
Replying to Chitranshu MANDHAR
...
Dr Deepa,
Personally I like to keep project charter static. Usually, I work on multiple projects at a time and I need to frequently refer to initial goals and objectives. In case of any major changes in the project, I prefer to put it on table and discuss with the project sponsor and steering board to formalise the changes in the charter.
Mandhar, I agree with you. Does this help you in in a PMO type of role too? since you mentioned you manage multiple concurrent projects. How would multiple charters help manage or optimize a PMO?

Thanks for your valuable comment
...
1 reply by Chitranshu MANDHAR
Jul 28, 2024 6:50 AM
Chitranshu MANDHAR
...
Deepa, More frequently, its helps in keeping us within the scope and time, and see if we are able achieve the desired objectives and goals. Sometimes, activities are identified during the later project execution stage that may fall with in the scope of project but performing those activities might lead to major impact on project time and cost. So, this also helps in saying NO to activities and tasks which were not initially agreed upon.
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Jul 22, 2024 5:48 AM
Replying to Thomas Walenta
...
Deepa,
in my experience a Charter may serve several purposes.

The main purpose for me is the governance decision that there is a project authorized by an organization agent (the sponsor), naming the person authorized to implement the project (the PM).
I have seen charters just being an email or even a verbal request by the sponsor (which then should be confirmed by the PM with a document).

Beyond that, there is a wish to put as much information as possible into the charter to describe the project, yet this will always be the information as we know it before the project (and analysis, planning, etc.) starts. I believe it is better to put that information into a business case before the charter is developed.

I have never seen a charter that was revised or updated. If it just documents the existence of a project it is like a birth certificate. Even if things change later, like gender, name, or parents, these changes are also documented elsewhere.
Thomas, thank you for your perspective. YOu bring a very valuable point on the non-changeable aspects of the Charter. I have always maintained that we have that one "original copy" of what and why did we start the project. Changes can happen if they need to but why reflect them in the original Charter? Yet, I think there are multiple flavors of the Charter and I have, in my experience, seen changes made in the Charter. I have also seen an email designated as a Charter much later after the project has started. :)
avatar
Shakeel Anwar Bhatti Abu Dhabi, , United Arab Emirates
Deepa, I advocate for a stable project charter as a foundational document for effective project management. Given the concurrent nature of my project portfolio, frequent reference to the original project goals and objectives is essential. To ensure alignment with evolving project needs, I propose a formal amendment process involving the project sponsor and steering board for any significant deviations from the charter.
...
1 reply by Dr. Deepa Bhide
Jul 31, 2024 12:07 PM
Dr. Deepa Bhide
...
Thanks Shakeel. I guess you propose having a single document that you can reference as the "original". Thanks for your comment
Jul 22, 2024 10:52 PM
Replying to Dr. Deepa Bhide
...
Mandhar, I agree with you. Does this help you in in a PMO type of role too? since you mentioned you manage multiple concurrent projects. How would multiple charters help manage or optimize a PMO?

Thanks for your valuable comment
Deepa, More frequently, its helps in keeping us within the scope and time, and see if we are able achieve the desired objectives and goals. Sometimes, activities are identified during the later project execution stage that may fall with in the scope of project but performing those activities might lead to major impact on project time and cost. So, this also helps in saying NO to activities and tasks which were not initially agreed upon.
...
1 reply by Dr. Deepa Bhide
Jul 31, 2024 12:08 PM
Dr. Deepa Bhide
...
Thanks for your comment and I agree with you Mandhar. Yes, it serves as a guardrail.
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Jul 22, 2024 5:08 PM
Replying to George Freeman
...
Dr. Deepa,

Although the components of a “project charter package” vary dramatically based on industry, organizational structure, risk tolerance, maturity level, and the like. The core purpose of a charter, as generically derived from Merriam-Webster, is to “establish and convey the power and function of an entity,” which is how I have always understood and explained it to others in project management.

Hence, the static purpose of the charter is to “Authorize and Empower” a project.

===== My definition =====
A charter is a “corporate political device” that uses executive fiat to authorize a project and commission its chief executive (i.e., the project manager) with explicit bounded authority to assemble, manage, and direct organizational resources to achieve the project’s defined objectives, deliverables, and goals.

Although the above is the core purpose, the project charter can also contain the functional project collaterals known at its creation. Bound together as a package (i.e., the project charter package) via a single document with a well-formed table of contents or as individual documents.

George
Thanks George for your comment and I agree with you on the definition and proposed form of the Charter.
avatar
Dr. Deepa Bhide Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Jul 28, 2024 6:26 AM
Replying to Shakeel Anwar Bhatti
...
Deepa, I advocate for a stable project charter as a foundational document for effective project management. Given the concurrent nature of my project portfolio, frequent reference to the original project goals and objectives is essential. To ensure alignment with evolving project needs, I propose a formal amendment process involving the project sponsor and steering board for any significant deviations from the charter.
Thanks Shakeel. I guess you propose having a single document that you can reference as the "original". Thanks for your comment
< 1 2 3 >

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"[Musicians] talk of nothing but money and jobs. Give me businessmen every time. They really are interested in music and art."

- Jean Sibelius, explaining why he rarely invited musicians to his home.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors