Hi Sandra Nelson
Great to hear that your EPMO is evolving, integrating project, change, and program management (with portfolio management on the way) is a strong step toward delivering enterprise-wide value.
As part of implementing KPIs and performance scorecards for project managers, here are some commonly recommended indicators, aligned with principles advocated by Jim Highsmith, a key contributor to agile thinking and value-driven project leadership:
KPIs focused on value, learning, and strategic alignment:
- Business Value Delivered
ROI or realized strategic benefit
Percentage of deliverables adopted or actively used by stakeholders
- Stakeholder Satisfaction
Post-delivery feedback (e.g., internal NPS or survey scores)
Perceived alignment between project outcomes and business needs
- Adaptive Capacity and Responsiveness
Average time to respond to significant change
Number of successful strategic pivots during the project lifecycle
- Continuous Learning and Innovation
Number of hypotheses or experiments tested and validated
Improvements implemented based on retrospectives or stakeholder input
- Team Engagement and Health
Participation in ceremonies and shared decision-making
Indicators of psychological safety and collaboration
- Complexity vs. Adjusted Performance
Categorize projects by complexity to calibrate expectations accordingly
Useful for identifying best practices and contextual success factors
These KPIs are intended to move beyond traditional metrics like “on time and on budget.”
While such measures can be useful for health checks, they often fail to capture what really defines success.
Highsmith encourages focusing on outcomes, adaptability, and strategic alignment, rather than solely on deliverables or rigid control.
Regarding scorecards:
A composite scorecard could be used to weight these indicators (e.g., 30% value, 25% satisfaction, 25% learning, 20% team health).
Alternatively, vertical dashboards for each function (PM, Change, Program, Portfolio) can reflect specific dynamics and maturity levels.