Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Are Mentoring and Counseling the same or different?

linkedin twitter facebook  
avatar
Suhail Iqbal Suhail Iqbal PMIATP CIPM FAAPM MPM MQM CLC CPRM SCT AEC SDC SMC SPOC PRINCE2 MCT| PM Training School Rawalpindi, Punjab, Pakistan
Mentoring and counseling are usually thought as synonymous to each other. My personal opinion is they are very different from each other, though they may share some characreristics. What is your opinion about this?
Sort By:
avatar
Pravin Kumar Shrivastava Associate Vice President| Aithent Technologies Pvt Ltd Gurgaon, Haryana, India
I see them as different though they carry the same meaning.

Mentoring involves nurturing the talents and Counseling involves to bring talent on right track.

avatar
Suhail Iqbal Suhail Iqbal PMIATP CIPM FAAPM MPM MQM CLC CPRM SCT AEC SDC SMC SPOC PRINCE2 MCT| PM Training School Rawalpindi, Punjab, Pakistan
I feel they are two different concepts and have diverging purposes. They may seem to have some common features but the purpose of mentoring is to lend an empathetic ear to the mentee and let him or her speak out loud and ramble around to find a solution, Mentor just provides encouragement and a bit of direction as if mentee finds his/her own way. Counseling is more directive in nature and you need to treat the person seeking guidance as a subject, he might be advised and guided actively. Mentoring is rather a passive role as compare to counseling.
avatar
Manas De Amin Director| Computer Technology Group Kolkata Kolkata, West Bengal, India
Both are different in nature though both are aimed to do good. In counseling, the counselor sits in the opposite side of the table, asking questions or lets the person talk his/her heart. It's a direct process of correcting things.
A mentor holds the hand of the mentee to nurture and polish his/her talents and inherent capabilities, many times without letting feel the mentee, the process.

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Teachers open the door, but you must enter by yourself."

- Chinese Proverb

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors