You are an experienced project manager that specializes in aircraft charter and contract management for rotation of troops in UN peacekeeping missions in a West African country.
Current rotation to UN missions is done using Airbus A320 from Ethiopian airlines. Military High Command is considering using CASA C 295 aircraft belonging to its Air Force. Your task is to identify potential risks in this project to use medium lift aircraft CASA C295 belonging to its Air Force to rotate troops in UNIFIL Lebanon, considering the aircraft has been used to rotate troops in ECOWAS missions in West Africa successfully.
Create a risk register with the project’s potential risks in table format.
Risk Register – Troop Rotation to UNIFIL Using CASA C-295
Risk ID Risk Category Risk Description Probability Impact Risk Level Mitigation Measures Risk Owner
R1 Aircraft Range C-295 lacks the range to fly directly from West Africa to Lebanon, requiring multiple refueling stops. High High Extreme Develop detailed routing plan with approved fuel stops and contingency airfields. Air Operations
R2 Mission Duration Increased transit time compared to A320 may delay troop rotations and relief schedules. High High High Conduct detailed scheduling and deploy aircraft earlier. Project Manager
R3 Aircraft Availability National operational commitments may conflict with troop rotation requirements. Medium High High Allocate dedicated aircraft and establish priority policy. Air Force HQ
R4 Aircraft Reliability Technical defects during long international missions may cause delays. Medium High High Increase pre-deployment inspections and carry critical spares. Engineering Directorate
R5 Crew Fatigue Long flight durations with multiple sectors may exceed crew duty limitations. High Medium High Implement crew rotation plans and rest periods. Flight Operations
R6 Maintenance Support Lack of maintenance support facilities along route or in Lebanon. Medium High High Deploy maintenance team and establish support agreements with partner nations. Engineering Directorate
R7 Spare Parts Availability Difficulty obtaining spare parts during overseas operations. Medium High High Pre-position critical spare parts package. Logistics Directorate
R8 Overflight Clearance Delays or denial of diplomatic clearances from transit countries. Medium High High Initiate clearance requests well in advance through Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Diplomatic Liaison
R9 Landing Permits Host nation restrictions may delay operations. Low High Medium Coordinate early with Lebanese authorities and UNIFIL. Mission Coordination Cell
R10 Geopolitical Tensions Regional instability in the Middle East may affect flight routes. Medium High High Maintain alternate routes and monitor intelligence reports. Operations Directorate
R11 Security Threat Potential missile, drone, or terrorist threats in transit or destination areas. Low Very High High Conduct threat assessments and coordinate with UN security. Security Officer
R12 Airport Infrastructure Certain refueling airports may not support military operations. Medium Medium Medium Conduct route surveys and airport assessments. Air Operations
R13 Weather Disruptions Adverse weather may affect flight safety and schedules. Medium Medium Medium Use weather forecasting and alternate planning. Flight Operations
R14 Passenger Capacity C-295 capacity (~70 troops) is significantly lower than A320 (~150–180 troops). High High Extreme Increase number of sorties or use multiple aircraft. Project Manager
R15 Cost Escalation Multiple sorties may increase operating costs beyond charter option. High High Extreme Conduct cost-benefit analysis before project approval. Finance Department
R16 Fuel Costs Increased fuel consumption due to multiple legs. High Medium High Negotiate fuel agreements and optimize routing. Finance & Logistics
R17 UN Reimbursement UN may not reimburse all operational costs for military aircraft rotations. Medium High High Clarify reimbursement policies with UN before execution. Finance Department
R18 Medical Emergencies Limited onboard medical facilities during long transit. Medium Medium Medium Deploy medical personnel and emergency response procedures. Medical Services
R19 Troop Welfare Long travel times may reduce troop morale and comfort. High Medium High Schedule adequate rest periods and welfare support. Contingent Commander
R20 Cargo Constraints Passenger and baggage limitations may require additional flights. High Medium High Optimize load planning and deploy cargo separately. Logistics Directorate
R21 Crew Qualification Flight crews may have limited experience operating in Middle Eastern airspace. Medium Medium Medium Conduct route familiarization training. Flight Operations
R22 Air Traffic Congestion Busy Middle Eastern airspace may cause delays. Medium Medium Medium Coordinate with ATC authorities and file early flight plans. Air Operations
R23 Emergency Diversion Limited diversion options in some regions. Medium High High Identify and coordinate alternate airports. Flight Operations
R24 Insurance Liability Increased liability exposure during international military transport operations. Medium Medium Medium Review insurance and government indemnity arrangements. Legal Department
R25 International Regulations Non-compliance with ICAO, UN, or host nation requirements. Low High Medium Conduct regulatory compliance review. Legal & Aviation Safety
R26 Safety Management Increased operational complexity elevates accident risk. Medium Very High High Implement comprehensive Safety Management System oversight. Aviation Safety Office
R27 Mission Failure Aircraft unserviceability may leave troops stranded. Medium High High Develop backup charter arrangement. Project Manager
R28 Political Risk National leadership may redirect aircraft for domestic priorities. Medium High High Obtain strategic commitment before project initiation. Air Force HQ
R29 Financial Sustainability Long-term use of military aircraft may be economically unsustainable. Medium High High Periodic cost-performance reviews. Finance Directorate
R30 Reputational Risk Delays or failures could affect the country's credibility with the UN. Medium High High Establish robust contingency and communication plans. National Contingent Leadership
Key Strategic Risks Requiring Senior Leadership Attention
The five most critical risks are:
Priority Risk Reason
1 Passenger Capacity Limitation A C-295 carries less than half the passengers of an A320, requiring more flights and resources.
2 Aircraft Range Limitation Multiple international stops significantly increase complexity and risk exposure.
3 Cost Escalation More flight hours, crew days, fuel, and maintenance may make the option more expensive than chartering.
4 Aircraft Availability National military commitments may affect troop rotation schedules.
5 Mission Reliability A single aircraft technical failure can disrupt an entire UN rotation cycle.
Project Manager's Recommendation
From a project management and contract management perspective, the use of the CASA C-295 for UNIFIL troop rotations should only proceed after a detailed feasibility study, cost-benefit analysis, aviation risk assessment, and UN reimbursement review. While the aircraft has demonstrated success in ECOWAS regional missions, the significantly longer distance to Lebanon, increased diplomatic clearances, lower passenger capacity, and higher operational complexity may reduce the expected benefits when compared with the current Airbus A320 charter arrangement. A hybrid model—using the C-295 for regional missions and retaining commercial charter aircraft for UNIFIL rotations—may provide a more balanced and lower-risk solution.
Show more Copy Try prompt on PMI Infinity
