Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

How to best select a PM App?

linkedin twitter facebook  
avatar
Juan Carlos Perez Chateauguay, Quebec, Canada
I have an assignment to evaluate and select one PM tool out the six Apps listed below. I’m planning to write a critical comparative review with one or more recommendations which I’ll share with this group.

Could you please advise on?

• Your experience with any of these tools if any.
• The criteria to select a PM App
• Your recommendation (justified with a couple of arguments if possible).

Tools under consideration:

1. Wrike (https://www.wrike.com/tour-wa/)
2. Dapulse (https://dapulse.com/)
3. Activecollab (https://activecollab.com/)
4. Asana (https://asana.com/)
5. Mavenlink (https://www.mavenlink.com/)
6. Yanado (https://yanado.com/)

Thank you very much for your advice and comments.
Sort By:
avatar
Daniel Swaim Program Manager| TycoIS Evergreen, Co, United States
Out of the six, the only one I have first hand experience with is #2. dapulse.

dapulse is powerful from a tracking and customization standpoint as you can do a lot with the table format that they use. Each row, called a "pulse", can be moved around the same sheet, called a "board", or even moved in between different boards. You can add columns to the board that are formatted for text, date, drop down colors/fields, etc. Each text based column even keeps a cache of the previous used values of that field so you can select it without having to retype it each time. An example would be using a text field for a salesperson's name; once you enter the name the first time you can quickly pick it out of the recently used names or it will pull up automatically after typing the first few letters. In addition to the table based view, each pulse has a journal feature allowing you to post updates, reply to updates, attach documents, etc. in a running narrative for that pulse. Paid team members can choose to receive and reply to these updates via email. You can export records to excel for reporting and they have integrations with many other applications and websites.

The downsides are that there is no workflow creation with dapulse so it is just for tracking projects, not really assigning tasks unless you get super granular in how you create your boards and pulses. Also, non paid team members cannot interact with dapulse in any capacity outside of a view only.

We use it as a dashboard/repository of status updates that compliments our other tools and systems, but I'm not sure anyone could get away with just using dapulse by itself to manage projects.

You can also check out this link for a comparison of popular PM apps:

https://zapier.com/learn/ultimate-guide-to...ement-software/
...
1 reply by Juan Carlos Perez
Jun 28, 2016 5:16 PM
Juan Carlos Perez
...
Daniel thank you very much for your generous and extensive comment.
avatar
Elizabeth Harrin Director| RebelsGuideToPM.com London, England, United Kingdom
My review of activeCollab is here, if that's any help.
...
2 replies by Juan Carlos Perez
Jun 28, 2016 5:19 PM
Juan Carlos Perez
...
Elizabeth, Thank you very much for your reply. However, I don't see a URL or a reference to your review.
Jun 29, 2016 10:27 AM
Juan Carlos Perez
...
Elizabeth, Very useful review. Thank you very much.
avatar
Juan Carlos Perez Chateauguay, Quebec, Canada
Jun 23, 2016 2:25 PM
Replying to Daniel Swaim
...
Out of the six, the only one I have first hand experience with is #2. dapulse.

dapulse is powerful from a tracking and customization standpoint as you can do a lot with the table format that they use. Each row, called a "pulse", can be moved around the same sheet, called a "board", or even moved in between different boards. You can add columns to the board that are formatted for text, date, drop down colors/fields, etc. Each text based column even keeps a cache of the previous used values of that field so you can select it without having to retype it each time. An example would be using a text field for a salesperson's name; once you enter the name the first time you can quickly pick it out of the recently used names or it will pull up automatically after typing the first few letters. In addition to the table based view, each pulse has a journal feature allowing you to post updates, reply to updates, attach documents, etc. in a running narrative for that pulse. Paid team members can choose to receive and reply to these updates via email. You can export records to excel for reporting and they have integrations with many other applications and websites.

The downsides are that there is no workflow creation with dapulse so it is just for tracking projects, not really assigning tasks unless you get super granular in how you create your boards and pulses. Also, non paid team members cannot interact with dapulse in any capacity outside of a view only.

We use it as a dashboard/repository of status updates that compliments our other tools and systems, but I'm not sure anyone could get away with just using dapulse by itself to manage projects.

You can also check out this link for a comparison of popular PM apps:

https://zapier.com/learn/ultimate-guide-to...ement-software/
Daniel thank you very much for your generous and extensive comment.
avatar
Juan Carlos Perez Chateauguay, Quebec, Canada
Jun 24, 2016 5:35 PM
Replying to Elizabeth Harrin
...
My review of activeCollab is here, if that's any help.
Elizabeth, Thank you very much for your reply. However, I don't see a URL or a reference to your review.
avatar
Eduard Hernandez
Community Champion
Product Operations Program Manager Barcelona, Cataluña, Spain
She used a hyperlink, just click on it or go to

http://www.girlsguidetopm.com/2014/09/soft...w-activecollab/
avatar
Juan Carlos Perez Chateauguay, Quebec, Canada
Eduard, Thank you for for the clarification. I saw the link but I thought it was the link to the tools itself (I should read more carefully) .
avatar
Juan Carlos Perez Chateauguay, Quebec, Canada
Jun 24, 2016 5:35 PM
Replying to Elizabeth Harrin
...
My review of activeCollab is here, if that's any help.
Elizabeth, Very useful review. Thank you very much.

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Don't compromise yourself. You are all you've got."

- Janis Joplin

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors