Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Shall a PM be specialized or jack of all?

linkedin twitter facebook  
avatar
Farhan Liaquat
Community Champion
Senior Consultant| Flicanada.com Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
How do clients, customer and organization see PMs, shall they be expert or know little bit of everything. What's essential and important for a PM to know
Sort By:
avatar
Rami Kaibni
Community Champion
Senior Projects Manager | Field & Marten Associates New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
PM's should have enough experience in Managing Projects regardless of what the project and industry is.
avatar
Sergio Luis Conte Helping to create solutions for everyone| Worldwide based Organizations Buenos Aires, Argentina
Trying to add something to @Rami comment above, the key is to perform a common activity usually missing by some PMs: Elicitation. You have not to be a subject matter expert but you have to gain knowledge about the domain where you are assigned as project manager. In my case I follow the CMU SEI Elicitation process to do that and it works for me.
avatar
Walter Pilimon CEO| Web Dev Experts SRL Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina
Knowledge about the subject matter is very important. He does not need to be a genius but he must be able to communicate with the technical experts in their language. Unless the project is too generic, a project manager that just strives for "efficiency" "milestones" "goals" etc but fails to choose the important tasks will lose credibility with the team. Unless he is exclusively hired to act as facilitator, no more.
avatar
Denise Canty Agile Coach, Life Coach, Author, Senior Project-Program Manager| Cenden Company Washington, Dc, United States
As busy as a PM is with managing projects, there isn't enough time in a day for the this role to be a "jack of all trades".
avatar
Prateek Gupta Gurgaon, Haryana, India
I think I will split the "trade" in two parts.
1. Project Management - No excuses here. You need to be on top of this
2. Domain/Technical Skills - in my experience I have seen that the decision making, probing skills become much easier if you can talk to your team/client/stakeholders in the same grammar. Hence it is important to be "Jack of all trades" from this perspective.

I changed my domain after working in one for about 11 years. There was an uphill task for first 1-2 years. But later when I got handle of the domain and tech part, I could see the obvious difference.
...
1 reply by Thomas Walenta
Sep 04, 2016 7:39 PM
Thomas Walenta
...
Prateek,
think if you change your domain again and then again, as I did, you will not need 1-2 years to get along and gain a comprehension what project management really is.
avatar
Anupam India
In large projects, experience and the awareness about PM role is required. A Jack of all trades cannot be the master in managing the project.

Projects that are small in nature & barely require a team, PM may be performing additional roles.

Please refer below links on Organizational Project Management –

http://www.pmi.org/learning/library/pmo-op...e-strategy-6075
https://www.pmi.org/business-solutions/ass.../organizational
avatar
Avinash Khare PM II| MAP-IT Consultant Project Management Ambernath (East), Maharashtra, India
It is not required for a PM to be a expert but he should be able to manage the project.I agree with Sergio a working knowledge of domain will be required.
avatar
Thomas Walenta Global Project Economy Expert Hackenheim, Germany
Sep 02, 2016 10:57 PM
Replying to Prateek Gupta
...
I think I will split the "trade" in two parts.
1. Project Management - No excuses here. You need to be on top of this
2. Domain/Technical Skills - in my experience I have seen that the decision making, probing skills become much easier if you can talk to your team/client/stakeholders in the same grammar. Hence it is important to be "Jack of all trades" from this perspective.

I changed my domain after working in one for about 11 years. There was an uphill task for first 1-2 years. But later when I got handle of the domain and tech part, I could see the obvious difference.
Prateek,
think if you change your domain again and then again, as I did, you will not need 1-2 years to get along and gain a comprehension what project management really is.
...
1 reply by Prateek Gupta
Sep 05, 2016 1:34 AM
Prateek Gupta
...
True.
avatar
Prateek Gupta Gurgaon, Haryana, India
Sep 04, 2016 7:39 PM
Replying to Thomas Walenta
...
Prateek,
think if you change your domain again and then again, as I did, you will not need 1-2 years to get along and gain a comprehension what project management really is.
True.
avatar
Daniel Krompholz Principal Maintenance Systems Specialist, Asset Management| The Port Authority of New York & New Jersey Jamaica, Ny, United States
Hahaha, a specialized jack-of-all-trades... I like the oxymoron

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Never hold discussions with the monkey when the organ grinder is in the room."

- Winston Churchill

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors