Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Methodology for project management

linkedin twitter facebook  
avatar
Pavithra Pannerselvam Cutover Management Planner| Danfoss Industries A/S Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
what would be the most preferred methodology in project management?
Sort By:
< 1 2 >
avatar
Peter Ambrosy Weinheim, Germany
It depends on industry and kind of project business.
To give a very generic answer: Framework is set by the PMBOK phases and process groups and enriched by company specific way of working and tools.
avatar
Tushar Shah Service Delivery Head-Mobile APPS & Software Development| Atlas Copco Pune, Maharashtra, India
It truly depends on following major criteria:
1. Industry
2. Complexity of the project
3. Organizational Culture
4. Matrix or Project based structure
5. Maturity of an organization following Project based approach (OPM3)
6. Sponsor and stakeholder involvement is the key for success of any project
avatar
Marciano Lie A Young Director| PRAGMATIC Wanica, Wanica, Suriname
I fully agree that for a great deal, it depends on the organization. Using the basic framework organizations adapt and evolve the methodology to fit their specific needs.
avatar
Sergio Luis Conte Helping to create solutions for everyone| Worldwide based Organizations Buenos Aires, Argentina
There is not a methodology for project management. What you have is a guide (the PMBOK Guide) that if you agree with that you will implement it by using a project life cycle model and a project life cycle process. Take a look to the new PMBOK Guide. There is very well explained (I worked on it a lot). What some people named project management methodology is a method to develop a product/service/result and it is not the same.
avatar
Stéphane Parent Self Employed / Semi-retired| Leader Maker Prince Edward Island, Canada
The best methodology is the one you've tailored to fit your project's requirements.
avatar
Vartika Kashyap Chief Marketing Officer (CMO)| ProofHub India
Every project manager follows a methodology to accomplish difficult projects. As they say, “ Project management is like science”. Similarly, project managers are like scientists, who try out different methods by trial and error to accomplish various projects. With so many different options, schools of thought and management tools, how do you know which method is right for your projects?
Let’s take a look at some of the most popular project management methodologies.
TRADITIONAL
Waterfall
This being a traditional methodology is the simplest and easiest to understand. In this methodology, there is a sequence of tasks which leads to the final deliverable. One task must be completed before the next one begins, in a connected sequence of items that add up to the overall deliverable. The effectiveness of this methodology is that every step is pre-planned. Any changes in customer’s need or priorities will disrupt the entire sequence of tasks, making it very difficult to manage.
Critical Path method (CPM)
The critical path method was developed in the 1950s. It follows the ideology where you can’t start one task until a previous one has been finished. When you join these dependent tasks together, you plot your critical path.
Identification of the critical path allows project managers to prioritize and allocate resources to get the most important work done. It helps the project managers to optimize team’s work in case of any changes without delaying the end results. It is optimal for projects with short deadlines.
MODERN
Agile
This project methodology focuses on visualizing end state. Agile?—?a refinement of earlier methodologies provide rapid continuous delivery. Agile’s four main values are expressed as:
Individuals and interactions over processes and tools
Working software over comprehensive documentation
Customer collaboration over contract negotiation
Responding to change over following a plan
Teams following Agile methodology work in cycles of planning, executing and evaluating results at the end. Depending upon the results of these evaluations, the final deliverable may be modified in order to create a better end result for the customer. It mainly emphasizes on continuous collaboration both within the project team members and with project stakeholders.
Scrum
Scrum is the most famous agile methodology because it is relatively simpler to implement. In this methodology, a small team is led by scrum master often called Subject matter experts (SME) who makes way for effective collaboration and deliver high results. The team works in short cycles of two weeks called “sprints,” where daily discussions are held to discuss the latest developments. This methodology allows quick developments with intense communication, especially for smaller teams.
Kanban
It was developed by Toyota during the 1940s and in Japanese, the word “Kanban” stands for visual system of cards. A Kanban board is mainly a workflow visualization tool that maximizes the productivity of a team by reducing the idle time. Over the span of years, it has grown as a methodology that has been accepted as a tool to manage tasks in projects.
This visual approach to manage a project is well-suited to work that requires steady output. Here, the team members often create a visual representation of their tasks and move them through various stages in the process. It helps the teams to improve efficiency by visualizing where time is actually being spent.
PROCESS BASED
Lean
Lean is a methodology that is focused on streamlining and cutting out waste. The first step is to create a work process breakdown to identify and eliminate bottlenecks, delays, and all forms of waste (“muda”). The goal is to do more with less i.e. deliver value to the customer using less manpower, less money, and less time.
Six-sigma
This is a data-driven process-improvement methodology focused on eliminating defects and errors. Six Sigma is a formal, highly structured scientific and mathematical approach to problem-solving. A process can attain a rating of Six Sigma if 99.99966% of the final product is defect-free.
Lean six sigma (LSS)
LSS combines the best of Lean and Six Sigma, LSS concentrates on what is critical to quality in a process while removing waste and reducing defects. Lean Six Sigma focuses on eliminating waste so that projects are more efficient, cost effective, and truly answer customers’ needs.
HYBRID
Disciplined Agile Delivery (DAD)
This is an agile/lean approach borrows principles from Scrum, Kanban, Extreme Programming, and others. DAD extends the short cycles, lean, and visual approaches found in the other frameworks and provide and non-prescriptive approach. This allows teams to fully consider viable alternatives. This ultimately helps you to find an approach best suited to your project management style.
All of these methodologies will bring benefits to an organization, but choosing, training and implementing a new methodology is no small task, so take time to ensure you select the best fit for your team. You can also take opinions from your fellow employees which methodologies they’ve used and had the most success with. So leverage the experience of your colleagues. Choose a methodology that reflects your management and leadership style and build the right team so that you can accomplish every project with aplomb.
...
2 replies by Sergio Luis Conte and Stéphane Parent
Sep 18, 2017 9:05 AM
Stéphane Parent
...
Brace yourself,Vartika! When Sergio sees your post is going to tell you that Agile is not a methodology and independent of project management.
Sep 18, 2017 10:26 AM
Sergio Luis Conte
...
@Vartika, sorry but what you stated is not correct. What you stated are life cycle models and life cycle process but not methodologies. Methodologies (in fact, that word is incorrectly used because the right word is Methods) are based on life cycle models and life cycle process. Project life cycle models (predictive and adaptive) are based on practices like Lean, Agile, TQM, etc. So, Lean, Agile, TQM, etc are not methods or methodologies at all. But it is not matter what I said (believe me, I have made research for years and I am working with it from years including with the PMI) my recommendation is take a look to new PMBOK Guide. This is critical to understand to be successful when you perform the program/project manager role.
avatar
Stéphane Parent Self Employed / Semi-retired| Leader Maker Prince Edward Island, Canada
Sep 18, 2017 5:52 AM
Replying to Vartika Kashyap
...
Every project manager follows a methodology to accomplish difficult projects. As they say, “ Project management is like science”. Similarly, project managers are like scientists, who try out different methods by trial and error to accomplish various projects. With so many different options, schools of thought and management tools, how do you know which method is right for your projects?
Let’s take a look at some of the most popular project management methodologies.
TRADITIONAL
Waterfall
This being a traditional methodology is the simplest and easiest to understand. In this methodology, there is a sequence of tasks which leads to the final deliverable. One task must be completed before the next one begins, in a connected sequence of items that add up to the overall deliverable. The effectiveness of this methodology is that every step is pre-planned. Any changes in customer’s need or priorities will disrupt the entire sequence of tasks, making it very difficult to manage.
Critical Path method (CPM)
The critical path method was developed in the 1950s. It follows the ideology where you can’t start one task until a previous one has been finished. When you join these dependent tasks together, you plot your critical path.
Identification of the critical path allows project managers to prioritize and allocate resources to get the most important work done. It helps the project managers to optimize team’s work in case of any changes without delaying the end results. It is optimal for projects with short deadlines.
MODERN
Agile
This project methodology focuses on visualizing end state. Agile?—?a refinement of earlier methodologies provide rapid continuous delivery. Agile’s four main values are expressed as:
Individuals and interactions over processes and tools
Working software over comprehensive documentation
Customer collaboration over contract negotiation
Responding to change over following a plan
Teams following Agile methodology work in cycles of planning, executing and evaluating results at the end. Depending upon the results of these evaluations, the final deliverable may be modified in order to create a better end result for the customer. It mainly emphasizes on continuous collaboration both within the project team members and with project stakeholders.
Scrum
Scrum is the most famous agile methodology because it is relatively simpler to implement. In this methodology, a small team is led by scrum master often called Subject matter experts (SME) who makes way for effective collaboration and deliver high results. The team works in short cycles of two weeks called “sprints,” where daily discussions are held to discuss the latest developments. This methodology allows quick developments with intense communication, especially for smaller teams.
Kanban
It was developed by Toyota during the 1940s and in Japanese, the word “Kanban” stands for visual system of cards. A Kanban board is mainly a workflow visualization tool that maximizes the productivity of a team by reducing the idle time. Over the span of years, it has grown as a methodology that has been accepted as a tool to manage tasks in projects.
This visual approach to manage a project is well-suited to work that requires steady output. Here, the team members often create a visual representation of their tasks and move them through various stages in the process. It helps the teams to improve efficiency by visualizing where time is actually being spent.
PROCESS BASED
Lean
Lean is a methodology that is focused on streamlining and cutting out waste. The first step is to create a work process breakdown to identify and eliminate bottlenecks, delays, and all forms of waste (“muda”). The goal is to do more with less i.e. deliver value to the customer using less manpower, less money, and less time.
Six-sigma
This is a data-driven process-improvement methodology focused on eliminating defects and errors. Six Sigma is a formal, highly structured scientific and mathematical approach to problem-solving. A process can attain a rating of Six Sigma if 99.99966% of the final product is defect-free.
Lean six sigma (LSS)
LSS combines the best of Lean and Six Sigma, LSS concentrates on what is critical to quality in a process while removing waste and reducing defects. Lean Six Sigma focuses on eliminating waste so that projects are more efficient, cost effective, and truly answer customers’ needs.
HYBRID
Disciplined Agile Delivery (DAD)
This is an agile/lean approach borrows principles from Scrum, Kanban, Extreme Programming, and others. DAD extends the short cycles, lean, and visual approaches found in the other frameworks and provide and non-prescriptive approach. This allows teams to fully consider viable alternatives. This ultimately helps you to find an approach best suited to your project management style.
All of these methodologies will bring benefits to an organization, but choosing, training and implementing a new methodology is no small task, so take time to ensure you select the best fit for your team. You can also take opinions from your fellow employees which methodologies they’ve used and had the most success with. So leverage the experience of your colleagues. Choose a methodology that reflects your management and leadership style and build the right team so that you can accomplish every project with aplomb.
Brace yourself,Vartika! When Sergio sees your post is going to tell you that Agile is not a methodology and independent of project management.
...
2 replies by Mayte Mata Sivera and Sergio Luis Conte
Sep 18, 2017 10:22 AM
Sergio Luis Conte
...
JAJAJAJA. See my reply...
Sep 18, 2017 4:56 PM
Mayte Mata Sivera
...
hahaha I was thinking the same before scroll down...omg
avatar
Eric Simms Senior Program Manager Baltimore, Maryland, United States
Project Management isn’t a science like mathematics, where one can apply the same formula to solve every problem of a particular type. Rather, project management is an art. Each Project Manager must decide how to best utilize project management methodologies and other related knowledge to successfully execute a project.
In general, Project Managers need to focus much more on learning how to apply their knowledge instead of simply accumulating it. No amount of knowledge about project management can ever replace practical Project Management experience.
avatar
Sergio Luis Conte Helping to create solutions for everyone| Worldwide based Organizations Buenos Aires, Argentina
Sep 18, 2017 9:05 AM
Replying to Stéphane Parent
...
Brace yourself,Vartika! When Sergio sees your post is going to tell you that Agile is not a methodology and independent of project management.
JAJAJAJA. See my reply...
avatar
Sergio Luis Conte Helping to create solutions for everyone| Worldwide based Organizations Buenos Aires, Argentina
Sep 18, 2017 5:52 AM
Replying to Vartika Kashyap
...
Every project manager follows a methodology to accomplish difficult projects. As they say, “ Project management is like science”. Similarly, project managers are like scientists, who try out different methods by trial and error to accomplish various projects. With so many different options, schools of thought and management tools, how do you know which method is right for your projects?
Let’s take a look at some of the most popular project management methodologies.
TRADITIONAL
Waterfall
This being a traditional methodology is the simplest and easiest to understand. In this methodology, there is a sequence of tasks which leads to the final deliverable. One task must be completed before the next one begins, in a connected sequence of items that add up to the overall deliverable. The effectiveness of this methodology is that every step is pre-planned. Any changes in customer’s need or priorities will disrupt the entire sequence of tasks, making it very difficult to manage.
Critical Path method (CPM)
The critical path method was developed in the 1950s. It follows the ideology where you can’t start one task until a previous one has been finished. When you join these dependent tasks together, you plot your critical path.
Identification of the critical path allows project managers to prioritize and allocate resources to get the most important work done. It helps the project managers to optimize team’s work in case of any changes without delaying the end results. It is optimal for projects with short deadlines.
MODERN
Agile
This project methodology focuses on visualizing end state. Agile?—?a refinement of earlier methodologies provide rapid continuous delivery. Agile’s four main values are expressed as:
Individuals and interactions over processes and tools
Working software over comprehensive documentation
Customer collaboration over contract negotiation
Responding to change over following a plan
Teams following Agile methodology work in cycles of planning, executing and evaluating results at the end. Depending upon the results of these evaluations, the final deliverable may be modified in order to create a better end result for the customer. It mainly emphasizes on continuous collaboration both within the project team members and with project stakeholders.
Scrum
Scrum is the most famous agile methodology because it is relatively simpler to implement. In this methodology, a small team is led by scrum master often called Subject matter experts (SME) who makes way for effective collaboration and deliver high results. The team works in short cycles of two weeks called “sprints,” where daily discussions are held to discuss the latest developments. This methodology allows quick developments with intense communication, especially for smaller teams.
Kanban
It was developed by Toyota during the 1940s and in Japanese, the word “Kanban” stands for visual system of cards. A Kanban board is mainly a workflow visualization tool that maximizes the productivity of a team by reducing the idle time. Over the span of years, it has grown as a methodology that has been accepted as a tool to manage tasks in projects.
This visual approach to manage a project is well-suited to work that requires steady output. Here, the team members often create a visual representation of their tasks and move them through various stages in the process. It helps the teams to improve efficiency by visualizing where time is actually being spent.
PROCESS BASED
Lean
Lean is a methodology that is focused on streamlining and cutting out waste. The first step is to create a work process breakdown to identify and eliminate bottlenecks, delays, and all forms of waste (“muda”). The goal is to do more with less i.e. deliver value to the customer using less manpower, less money, and less time.
Six-sigma
This is a data-driven process-improvement methodology focused on eliminating defects and errors. Six Sigma is a formal, highly structured scientific and mathematical approach to problem-solving. A process can attain a rating of Six Sigma if 99.99966% of the final product is defect-free.
Lean six sigma (LSS)
LSS combines the best of Lean and Six Sigma, LSS concentrates on what is critical to quality in a process while removing waste and reducing defects. Lean Six Sigma focuses on eliminating waste so that projects are more efficient, cost effective, and truly answer customers’ needs.
HYBRID
Disciplined Agile Delivery (DAD)
This is an agile/lean approach borrows principles from Scrum, Kanban, Extreme Programming, and others. DAD extends the short cycles, lean, and visual approaches found in the other frameworks and provide and non-prescriptive approach. This allows teams to fully consider viable alternatives. This ultimately helps you to find an approach best suited to your project management style.
All of these methodologies will bring benefits to an organization, but choosing, training and implementing a new methodology is no small task, so take time to ensure you select the best fit for your team. You can also take opinions from your fellow employees which methodologies they’ve used and had the most success with. So leverage the experience of your colleagues. Choose a methodology that reflects your management and leadership style and build the right team so that you can accomplish every project with aplomb.
@Vartika, sorry but what you stated is not correct. What you stated are life cycle models and life cycle process but not methodologies. Methodologies (in fact, that word is incorrectly used because the right word is Methods) are based on life cycle models and life cycle process. Project life cycle models (predictive and adaptive) are based on practices like Lean, Agile, TQM, etc. So, Lean, Agile, TQM, etc are not methods or methodologies at all. But it is not matter what I said (believe me, I have made research for years and I am working with it from years including with the PMI) my recommendation is take a look to new PMBOK Guide. This is critical to understand to be successful when you perform the program/project manager role.
< 1 2 >

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"I'm sick and tired of hearing things from uptight, short-sighted, narrow-minded hypocrites. All I want is the truth. Just gimme some truth."

- John Lennon

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors