Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

The purpose of this Research study is to explore the factors associated with project complexity. This Questionnaire will only take your precious 10 minutes to complete.

linkedin twitter facebook   Governance  
avatar
Tahir Saeed Maqbool Planning Engineer| Essam Kabbani & Partners Co. (KSA) Pakistan
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLS...orm?usp=sf_link

Thank you for agreeing to take part in this Research study.
Sort By:
avatar
MARK A ANNUNZIATA, Sr VP/EXPERT CONSULTANCY TO THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY| ROMAN STRUCTURES, INC WELLINGTON FL Dammam, Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia
TSM-
I think you need to re-examine the quiz. Several questions repeat. Several questions don't reflect "who" you are referring to in the question.Technical uncertainty, Technical uncertainty, high quality- who are you referring to in these questions? Roles, Resource, and Motivation- if these are missing then it would be the fault of the person (PMP) answering your quiz!
Please rethink this quiz and give us something meaningful....

Good Luck!
M
...
1 reply by Tahir Saeed Maqbool
Nov 16, 2017 5:31 AM
Tahir Saeed Maqbool
...
Dear MARK Thanks for your kind review. That's the reason why i share my questionnaire here. Can you plz tell me in deatil? That actually which statement is not clear to you? And which questions are repeating?
avatar
Tahir Saeed Maqbool Planning Engineer| Essam Kabbani & Partners Co. (KSA) Pakistan
Nov 16, 2017 4:30 AM
Replying to MARK A ANNUNZIATA, Sr
...
TSM-
I think you need to re-examine the quiz. Several questions repeat. Several questions don't reflect "who" you are referring to in the question.Technical uncertainty, Technical uncertainty, high quality- who are you referring to in these questions? Roles, Resource, and Motivation- if these are missing then it would be the fault of the person (PMP) answering your quiz!
Please rethink this quiz and give us something meaningful....

Good Luck!
M
Dear MARK Thanks for your kind review. That's the reason why i share my questionnaire here. Can you plz tell me in deatil? That actually which statement is not clear to you? And which questions are repeating?
avatar
MARK A ANNUNZIATA, Sr VP/EXPERT CONSULTANCY TO THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY| ROMAN STRUCTURES, INC WELLINGTON FL Dammam, Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia
TSM-
I would like to see some questions that will elicit varying responses from the varying skill set levels of PM's. Most would be forced to answer these questions the same way- since the question is asking about his governance of his staff, however they would be valid if your target audience is not a PM....
Following are my comments, I hope the feedback helps:

1) THERE IS HIGH DEMAND OF CREATIVITY IN THE DESIGNS
(DEFINED HOW? IN MY WORLD-EVERY DESIGN IS CREATIVE-IT COMES FOR AN ARCHITECT)
2) ACCESSIBILITY TO PROJECT
(ALL PROJECTS HAVE ACCESSIBILITY ISSUES- THEY ARE BUILT IN THE DIRT-USUALLY BEFORE ROADS)
3) EXTERNAL POLITICAL INFLUENCE (AGAIN, EVERY PM THINKS HIS PROJECT HAS EXT POLITICAL ISSUES-AND MOST DO)
4) SENIOR…SUPPORT-THIS IS A VALID QUESTION-HOWEVER MOST PM’S THINK THEY NEED MORE SUPPORT
5) ZERO TOLERANCE REWORK ( I AM CONFUSED-ALL “REWORK SHOULD HAVE A ZERO TOLERANCE-IT IS CORRECTIVE WORK TO A FAILED DELIVERABLE ATTEMPT)
6) HIGH TECHNOLOGICAL UNCERTAINTY- IN CONSTRUCTION????
7) PEOPLE WITH TECH COMP- THIS IS OK TO ASK
8) HIGH QUALITY STANDARDS…CIVIL ( I DARE YOU TO FIND A PM THAT WOULD NOT AGREE)
9) UNCHANGEABLE BUDGET—(EVERY PROJECT HAS A CHANGEABLE BUDGET)
10) CUSTOMER REQUIREMENTS-OK
11) HIGH DEGREE OF TECH INNOVATION---OK
12) ROLES OF TEAM MEMBERS UNCLEAR- THE PM BETTER STRONGLY DISAGREE BECAUSE HE IS REPOSNSIBLE FOR THIS
13) TEAM MEMBERS LACK MOTIVATION-PM IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS
14) RESOURCE SHARING ---OK
15) SITES DEPENDENCY—OK
16) DEPARTMENTS DEPENDENT-OK
17) CONTRACTORS DEPENDENT –THIS IS OK BUT EVERY PROJECT MUST BE DEPENDENT
18) 18 CONTRUCTRION PROCESSES- OK- BUT EVERY PROJECT HAS THESE DEPENDENCIES
19) SHARED RESOURCES-OK
20) DIVERSE TEAMS- OK- BUT THIS DESCRIBES EVERY PROJECT
21) SCHEDULES ARE DEPENDENT-OK- BUT THIS DESCRIBES EVERY PROJECT
22) LACK OF COMM –OK
23) DELIVERABLES DEPENDENT ON EACH OTHER- THIS DESCRIBES EVERY PROJECT
24) DIFFERENT TASKS CONNECTED—THIS DECRIBES EVERY PROJECT
25) FACE TO FACE-OK
26) TASKS ARE INTERCONNECTED- YOU APPEAR TO ASK THE SAME QUESTION REPEATEDLY- SIMILAR TO A PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAM
27) PROJECTS HAVE ILL DEFINED SCOPE- AGAIN- THE PM IS MOSTLY REPONSIBLE FOR DEFINING AND COMMUNICATING SCOPE
28) OBJECTIVES UNCLEAR- THEN THE PM IS AT FAULT
29) TECHNICAL M,ETHODS UNCLEAR- THEN THE PM WOULD BE AT FAULT
30) PRICES CHANGE ---OK
31) RESOURCES—OK
32) TIME FRAMES—GOOD QUESTION
33) RAW MATERIALS – THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
34) STAKEHOLDERS- THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
35) VARIETY OF TECHNICAL SKILLS-THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
36) CULTURE-OK
37) CULTURE-ASKED TWICE/REPEATED
38) MULT STAKEHOLDERS- THIS IS TRUE OF EVERY PROJECT
39) CAPITAL INV- THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
40) DURATION-OK
41) LARGE NUMBER ACTIVITIES- THIS IS MOST PROJECTS
42) LARGE DEPARTMENTS-OK
...
1 reply by Tahir Saeed Maqbool
Nov 16, 2017 7:07 AM
Tahir Saeed Maqbool
...
Dear Sir MARK,
Your feedback is very helpful for seriously. Sir in some questions as you mentioned "THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS", my research objective is not to differentiate different types of the projects rather my objective is" To explore the factors associated with project complexity". So i think you should agree with these questions where your remarks are "THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS". What do you say?

1) THERE IS HIGH DEMAND OF CREATIVITY IN THE DESIGNS
(DEFINED HOW? IN MY WORLD-EVERY DESIGN IS CREATIVE-IT COMES FOR AN ARCHITECT)

If Design will be creative then chances of error in estimation will be more and ultimately this error will impact on project budget, time and quality. And it is just one aspect. Do you agree?

5) ZERO TOLERANCE REWORK ( I AM CONFUSED-ALL “REWORK SHOULD HAVE A ZERO TOLERANCE-IT IS CORRECTIVE WORK TO A FAILED DELIVERABLE ATTEMPT)

Sir, for example you are making a bridge, and you build two pillars for slaps support and bridge pillars are making by project team at another place. But unfortunately you slaps length is less than the total length between two pillars then how many chances to correct this mistake?
Similarly as I am an Electrical Engineer, I am making some electrical connections.If i do any mistake i can easily make it correct. And many more example i can give like IT projects etc...
avatar
Tahir Saeed Maqbool Planning Engineer| Essam Kabbani & Partners Co. (KSA) Pakistan
Nov 16, 2017 6:23 AM
Replying to MARK A ANNUNZIATA, Sr
...
TSM-
I would like to see some questions that will elicit varying responses from the varying skill set levels of PM's. Most would be forced to answer these questions the same way- since the question is asking about his governance of his staff, however they would be valid if your target audience is not a PM....
Following are my comments, I hope the feedback helps:

1) THERE IS HIGH DEMAND OF CREATIVITY IN THE DESIGNS
(DEFINED HOW? IN MY WORLD-EVERY DESIGN IS CREATIVE-IT COMES FOR AN ARCHITECT)
2) ACCESSIBILITY TO PROJECT
(ALL PROJECTS HAVE ACCESSIBILITY ISSUES- THEY ARE BUILT IN THE DIRT-USUALLY BEFORE ROADS)
3) EXTERNAL POLITICAL INFLUENCE (AGAIN, EVERY PM THINKS HIS PROJECT HAS EXT POLITICAL ISSUES-AND MOST DO)
4) SENIOR…SUPPORT-THIS IS A VALID QUESTION-HOWEVER MOST PM’S THINK THEY NEED MORE SUPPORT
5) ZERO TOLERANCE REWORK ( I AM CONFUSED-ALL “REWORK SHOULD HAVE A ZERO TOLERANCE-IT IS CORRECTIVE WORK TO A FAILED DELIVERABLE ATTEMPT)
6) HIGH TECHNOLOGICAL UNCERTAINTY- IN CONSTRUCTION????
7) PEOPLE WITH TECH COMP- THIS IS OK TO ASK
8) HIGH QUALITY STANDARDS…CIVIL ( I DARE YOU TO FIND A PM THAT WOULD NOT AGREE)
9) UNCHANGEABLE BUDGET—(EVERY PROJECT HAS A CHANGEABLE BUDGET)
10) CUSTOMER REQUIREMENTS-OK
11) HIGH DEGREE OF TECH INNOVATION---OK
12) ROLES OF TEAM MEMBERS UNCLEAR- THE PM BETTER STRONGLY DISAGREE BECAUSE HE IS REPOSNSIBLE FOR THIS
13) TEAM MEMBERS LACK MOTIVATION-PM IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS
14) RESOURCE SHARING ---OK
15) SITES DEPENDENCY—OK
16) DEPARTMENTS DEPENDENT-OK
17) CONTRACTORS DEPENDENT –THIS IS OK BUT EVERY PROJECT MUST BE DEPENDENT
18) 18 CONTRUCTRION PROCESSES- OK- BUT EVERY PROJECT HAS THESE DEPENDENCIES
19) SHARED RESOURCES-OK
20) DIVERSE TEAMS- OK- BUT THIS DESCRIBES EVERY PROJECT
21) SCHEDULES ARE DEPENDENT-OK- BUT THIS DESCRIBES EVERY PROJECT
22) LACK OF COMM –OK
23) DELIVERABLES DEPENDENT ON EACH OTHER- THIS DESCRIBES EVERY PROJECT
24) DIFFERENT TASKS CONNECTED—THIS DECRIBES EVERY PROJECT
25) FACE TO FACE-OK
26) TASKS ARE INTERCONNECTED- YOU APPEAR TO ASK THE SAME QUESTION REPEATEDLY- SIMILAR TO A PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAM
27) PROJECTS HAVE ILL DEFINED SCOPE- AGAIN- THE PM IS MOSTLY REPONSIBLE FOR DEFINING AND COMMUNICATING SCOPE
28) OBJECTIVES UNCLEAR- THEN THE PM IS AT FAULT
29) TECHNICAL M,ETHODS UNCLEAR- THEN THE PM WOULD BE AT FAULT
30) PRICES CHANGE ---OK
31) RESOURCES—OK
32) TIME FRAMES—GOOD QUESTION
33) RAW MATERIALS – THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
34) STAKEHOLDERS- THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
35) VARIETY OF TECHNICAL SKILLS-THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
36) CULTURE-OK
37) CULTURE-ASKED TWICE/REPEATED
38) MULT STAKEHOLDERS- THIS IS TRUE OF EVERY PROJECT
39) CAPITAL INV- THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS
40) DURATION-OK
41) LARGE NUMBER ACTIVITIES- THIS IS MOST PROJECTS
42) LARGE DEPARTMENTS-OK
Dear Sir MARK,
Your feedback is very helpful for seriously. Sir in some questions as you mentioned "THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS", my research objective is not to differentiate different types of the projects rather my objective is" To explore the factors associated with project complexity". So i think you should agree with these questions where your remarks are "THIS IS TRUE OF ALL PROJECTS". What do you say?

1) THERE IS HIGH DEMAND OF CREATIVITY IN THE DESIGNS
(DEFINED HOW? IN MY WORLD-EVERY DESIGN IS CREATIVE-IT COMES FOR AN ARCHITECT)

If Design will be creative then chances of error in estimation will be more and ultimately this error will impact on project budget, time and quality. And it is just one aspect. Do you agree?

5) ZERO TOLERANCE REWORK ( I AM CONFUSED-ALL “REWORK SHOULD HAVE A ZERO TOLERANCE-IT IS CORRECTIVE WORK TO A FAILED DELIVERABLE ATTEMPT)

Sir, for example you are making a bridge, and you build two pillars for slaps support and bridge pillars are making by project team at another place. But unfortunately you slaps length is less than the total length between two pillars then how many chances to correct this mistake?
Similarly as I am an Electrical Engineer, I am making some electrical connections.If i do any mistake i can easily make it correct. And many more example i can give like IT projects etc...

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

Corned Beef Forever!

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors