Project Management

When Should AI Influence a Construction Procurement Decision?

Delaware Valley Chapter +3
linkedin twitter facebook print Request to reuse this   Artificial Intelligence   Construction   Giga Projects   Procurement Management  

The procurement dilemma

Consider a subcontractor evaluation in which an AI tool ranks an established firm above a smaller competitor. The established firm has years of digitized project records; the smaller firm has fewer records but relevant capabilities and strong current safety documentation. Should the project team accept the ranking, investigate the missing information, or set the score aside? This is an illustrative scenario, not a report of a specific procurement.

AI should support, rather than replace, accountable human judgment in supplier and subcontractor selection. A ranking can help organize evidence, but it cannot take responsibility for a contract award.

Historical-data systems may favor established firms because they have richer records, while new firms, smaller firms, or firms entering a new geographic market may have limited historical data despite possessing relevant capabilities. At the same time, human-only selection is not inherently fair; it can reproduce familiarity, relationship, halo, or consistency biases.

The central issue, therefore, is not whether humans or machines are inherently fair. It is whether the overall decision process produces defensible, accurate, explainable, contestable, accountable, and respectful treatment of affected parties. Whether Alternative B can satisfy those conditions is a proposition to be tested, not a …


Please log in or sign up below to read the rest of the article.

Continue reading...

Log In
OR
Sign Up

Cyberspace: A consensual hallucination experienced daily by billions of legitimate operators, in every nation

- William Gibson

Sponsors