Program Manager, PPM&PMO Specialist.| Coppel, Mexico.Culiacán, Sinaloa, Mexico
Colleagues,
I'm curious to hear your thoughts on identifying risks during the business case phase of a project. In some situations, I've seen stakeholders request a risk assessment before the project is even approved, as part of the business case.
What are your experiences with this? Do you think it's beneficial to identify potential risks at this early stage, even if it might lead to the project being rejected?
What key information or risk categories do you typically evaluate at this stage to inform the business case?
I'm interested in hearing your perspectives on the pros and cons of this approach.
Thanks in advance for sharing your insights!
Francisco
Program Manager, PPM&PMO Specialist.| Coppel, Mexico.Culiacán, Sinaloa, Mexico
Sep 30, 2025 11:35 PM
Replying to Luis Cesar Medel Garcia
...
Hola Francisco,
En mi experiencia identificar los riesgos durante la fase de análisis es beneficioso ya que se pueden tener las siguientes ventajas y desventajas.
Ventajas:
- Ayuda a que se determine si la empresa tiene la capacidad para enfrentar los riesgos.
- Permite tener una planificación anticipada de planes de mitigación hacia los riesgos conocidos.
- Ver los puntos de dolor del proyecto.
Desventajas:
- Podría rechazarse el proyecto ya que los riesgos pueden ser mayores a los manejables.
- Un análisis incompleto, ya que el proyecto en esta etapa temprana no cuenta con todas las variables para realizar una evaluación precisa.
En mi experiencia que categorías de riesgo solemos evaluar serían las siguientes:
- Riesgos financieros: Esto por el tema de financiamiento, sobrecostos.
- Riesgos legales: Cumplimiento de las obligaciones contractuales
- Riesgos técnico: Integración de la solución con sistemas existentes.
Gracias por tus comentarios Luis Cesar, Saludos! Saving Changes...
Program Manager, PPM&PMO Specialist.| Coppel, Mexico.Culiacán, Sinaloa, Mexico
Oct 01, 2025 4:33 PM
Replying to JUAN ELIGIO
...
Buenas tardes estimado Francisco, en mi experiencia laboral al trabajar en un Banco en México, me consta que en los proyectos de inversión en dónde intervenimos con capital o financiamiento, se revisa con lupa el Riesgo en la etapa de análisis por nuestras diferentes áreas de Riesgos, Jurídico, Desarrollo de Negocios entre otros; Al tener presente y revisar los distintos riesgos del proyecto aunque sea con un enfoque de estratégicos y de alto nivel, realmente estamos coadyuvando con nuestros clientes en la toma de decisiones y cuidando nuestra cartera y reservas. Realmente se analizan diferentes categorías de Riesgos como el de Mercado, de Crédito, de Liquidez o el de Divisas., saludos, Juan Eligio Méndez
Gracias por tu respuesta Juan Eligio, saludos! FAHQ. Saving Changes...
Program Manager, PPM&PMO Specialist.| Coppel, Mexico.Culiacán, Sinaloa, Mexico
Oct 08, 2025 10:47 PM
Replying to Mahi - Mahesh Gundu
...
Identifying risks during business case phase is a critical step. May be it's high-level but those risks will direct you to choose right resources, delivery methodology, communication channels, planning schedule etc.. For example, in a project to build software, risk identified initially that the value proposition of the software is similar to the one which is currently in marketplace, then business case itself requires a review before even project commence. Hence Identifying Risks is a must step during business case phase. Hope this helps !!!
Mahi, in early risk identification in the business case is crucial for guiding project direction, it's not just about listing potential problems, but about how those risks inform key decisions like choosing the right resources, methodology, communication channels, and even whether to proceed with the project at all. This proactive assessment ensures a more informed and strategic approach from the very beginning./span Francisco.
Program Manager, PPM&PMO Specialist.| Coppel, Mexico.Culiacán, Sinaloa, Mexico
Oct 23, 2025 6:39 AM
Replying to FAIZA KHALIL
...
Well said, Kiron — early-stage risk assessment, even at a high level, is invaluable. It helps filter out unsuitable projects, align stakeholder expectations, and lay the groundwork for proactive risk management later.
FAIZA KHALIL in early-stage risk assessment, even at a high level, is invaluable for project selection and stakeholder alignment, it helps filter out unsuitable projects upfront, manage expectations, and lay the groundwork for proactive risk management throughout the project lifecycle.
Business case is not the project approval, for that charter is used, it is rather the justification of a project why we should do this? how it aligns with business strategy. Here are the main ingredients of a Business case
Executive Summary: A high-level overview of the problem, the proposed solution, and the expected ROI.
Problem Statement: A clear, factual description of the current challenge or opportunity.
Proposed Solution & Options: The options you explored and the rationale for choosing the recommended path. (here for each options you can raise high level risks associated with with options)
Cost-Benefit Analysis: The financial forecast, including operational costs, expected savings, and projected revenue.
Risk & Mitigation: Anticipated risks for various options
...
1 reply by Francisco Herrera
Jun 17, 2026 3:48 PM
Francisco Herrera
...
Vinod Singh thanks for this clear explanation! You made an excellent point by distinguishing a Business Case from a Project Charter—people confuse them all the time. Your breakdown of the main ingredients is a perfect, practical checklist for anyone needing to justify a project's value. Thanks for sharing! Francisco
Program Manager, PPM&PMO Specialist.| Coppel, Mexico.Culiacán, Sinaloa, Mexico
Jun 10, 2026 12:06 PM
Replying to Vinod Singh
...
Business case is not the project approval, for that charter is used, it is rather the justification of a project why we should do this? how it aligns with business strategy. Here are the main ingredients of a Business case
Executive Summary: A high-level overview of the problem, the proposed solution, and the expected ROI.
Problem Statement: A clear, factual description of the current challenge or opportunity.
Proposed Solution & Options: The options you explored and the rationale for choosing the recommended path. (here for each options you can raise high level risks associated with with options)
Cost-Benefit Analysis: The financial forecast, including operational costs, expected savings, and projected revenue.
Risk & Mitigation: Anticipated risks for various options
Vinod Singh thanks for this clear explanation! You made an excellent point by distinguishing a Business Case from a Project Charter—people confuse them all the time. Your breakdown of the main ingredients is a perfect, practical checklist for anyone needing to justify a project's value. Thanks for sharing! Francisco Saving Changes...
Risk analysis should be continuously performed throughout the project lifecycle—it is not a one-time activity. Identifying risks early enables better planning for effective mitigation and response strategies
Program Manager, PPM&PMO Specialist.| Coppel, Mexico.Culiacán, Sinaloa, Mexico
Jun 18, 2026 10:52 AM
Replying to Sreesudha Ayyalasomayajula
...
Risk analysis should be continuously performed throughout the project lifecycle—it is not a one-time activity. Identifying risks early enables better planning for effective mitigation and response strategies
Thanks for your answer Sreesudha! Francisco. Saving Changes...
Identifying risks in the business case is absolutely essential, not too early. In fact, it is arguably the most valuable time to identify risks because it directly informs the go or no-go decision and shapes the project's foundational assumptions.
Here is why early risk identification matters. The business case establishes the expected ROI, timeline, and resource requirements. Without understanding the key risks, these projections are based on optimistic assumptions that rarely survive contact with reality. Stakeholders deserve to make investment decisions with eyes wide open about what could go wrong.
Risks identified at the business case stage should focus on strategic and market risks that could invalidate the entire project rationale, technology risks that could make the proposed solution infeasible, organizational risks such as change readiness, resource availability, and political support, and regulatory or compliance risks that could delay or block the project.
The business case does not need a full risk register with detailed mitigation plans. What it needs is an honest assessment of the top risks that could derail the expected benefits, along with a preliminary understanding of their likelihood and impact. This gives decision-makers the information they need to set appropriate contingency reserves and make informed investment choices.
Projects that skip risk identification in the business case often discover during execution that the fundamental assumptions were flawed. By then, significant resources have been committed, making it politically and financially difficult to course-correct or cancel.
...
1 reply by Francisco Herrera
Jul 20, 2026 1:36 PM
Francisco Herrera
...
Zeinab you made a crucial point: identifying risks during the business case stage is essential for making an honest go or no-go decision.
Focusing on high-level strategic risks before committing major resources prevents companies from chasing unrealistic ROI. It is a fantastic reminder that early risk management saves both time and money!
"This planet has - or rather had - a problem, which was this: most of the people living on it were unhappy for pretty much of the time. Many solutions were suggested for this problem, but most of these were largely concerned with the movements of small green pieces of paper, which is odd because on the whole it wasn't the small green pieces of paper that were unhappy."