Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Have you experienced (or witnessed) a highly visible mistake that led to the dismissal of a Project Manager, and how do you feel about accountability in such cases?

linkedin twitter facebook   Leadership   Organizational Culture  
avatar
Eduard Hernandez
Community Champion
Product Operations Program Manager Barcelona, Cataluña, Spain

In many roles, accountability is closely tied to visibility.

Politicians who perform poorly are often asked to resign, and CEOs or highly paid employees may be dismissed for personal misconduct or for violating internal policies. In these situations, a mistake with high visibility can turn the responsible person into an easy scapegoat, regardless of broader systemic issues.

I’m curious whether fellow Project Managers have encountered similar “colossal” mistakes (either personally or as observers) and how they view the balance between fair accountability and the consequences of being highly visible in leadership roles.

Sort By:
avatar
Gwenola Michaud
Community Champion
Project Manager & Advisor| Geosciences & Monitoring Consulting Milano, Italy
Yes, I believe there is a balance between fair accountability and visibility in leadership.

With visibility comes responsibility and exemplarity—this is part of what we accept as project managers. However, accountability should not automatically mean blaming the most visible person, and I don’t think this is often the case. Many “colossal” "mistakes" are rooted in systemic issues such as governance, culture, or unrealistic constraints.

Fair accountability means owning decisions and outcomes, while also looking beyond individuals to understand root causes. The notion of mistakes is important here: they should be treated as learning signals, not just triggers for blame. Otherwise, visibility risks turning into scapegoating rather than improvement and inspiration.
avatar
Syed Ashir Riaz
Community Champion
AI-Powered Social Media Strategist
Yes, I’ve witnessed situations where a highly visible mistake led to a Project Manager's dismissal. While accountability is important, I feel that visibility often amplifies consequences, sometimes unfairly. Mistakes in complex projects are usually systemic, involving multiple factors, yet the person in the spotlight often bears the full burden. I believe fair accountability should consider context and team dynamics, not just the visibility of the error.

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Man, if you gotta ask, you'll never know."

- Louis Armstrong...when asked what Jazz is.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors