Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

What Happens When a Project Manager "Eliminates the Risk" by Removing the Engineer Who Reported it?

linkedin twitter facebook   Ethics   Leadership   Risk Management  
avatar
Aleksandar Loncar Niš, Serbia

This case study offers a lesson in project management, professional responsibility, and ethics.

Imagine the following situation on a construction site.

A Site Manager, while conducting a risk assessment, identifies a serious safety risk: the end column of a canopy is planned directly under live overhead power lines.

He acts professionally. He submits a formal letter to the Project Manager and proposes four urgent measures, including contacting the relevant electricity distribution company, to control the risk and protect people and property.

The Project Manager’s response?

Instead of implementing the proposed measures, the Site Manager is removed from the project site.

The problem is “solved” by removing the person who raised it.

Let us examine which project management principles this decision failed to uphold and how the case can be analysed through the lens of the PMBOK Guide – 7th Edition and the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct.

Five PMBOK 7 principles relevant to this case

1. Risk — Optimize risk responses

A specific physical hazard with potentially serious consequences has been identified.

Reporting a risk is the starting point of risk management — the next step is to assess it and take appropriate measures to manage and control it.

2. Stakeholders — Effectively engage with stakeholders

The situation required the involvement of relevant stakeholders, as well as external parties whose participation was necessary to manage the risk.

A risk requiring action from multiple parties cannot be resolved by removing the person who raised it.

3. Stewardship — Be a diligent, respectful, and caring steward

A Project Manager is entrusted with making decisions that affect people and project resources. Responsible stewardship requires serious risks to people and property to be considered promptly and appropriate measures to be taken.

4. Team — Create a collaborative project team environment

How an organisation responds when a team member raises a concern influences the behaviour of the entire team. If people conclude that reporting bad news puts them personally at risk, the next problem may never be reported.

5. Leadership — Demonstrate leadership behaviour

Leadership is not demonstrated only when decisions are easy or circumstances are favourable. It is demonstrated especially when someone delivers bad news or raises a concern.

What does PMI Ethics say?

The same case can be examined through the four core values of the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct.

Responsibility

What does responsible conduct look like when a serious risk to the safety of people and property has been identified?

Respect

How should a professional who raises a legitimate concern be treated, even when that concern is uncomfortable or requires an existing plan to be reconsidered?

Fairness

Are decisions affecting project team members made objectively and on the basis of relevant professional criteria?

Honesty

Relevant information about identified risks must be communicated accurately and completely to all relevant parties who have the responsibility, authority or ability to take appropriate action.

This case is therefore about more than an overhead power line.

It is about organisational culture, professional responsibility, and how a project team responds to bad news.

There is a simple principle every Project Manager should understand:

Good Project Managers do not punish bad news — they address the problems behind it.

Which other principles from the PMBOK Guide – 7th Edition are relevant to this case? Do you think any other project management principles were also not upheld? If so, which ones, and why?

Sort By:
avatar
Luis Branco CEO| Business Insight, Consultores de Gestão, Ldª Carcavelos, Lisboa, Portugal
Thank you, Aleksandar, for raising such an important issue.
I would add Systems Thinking, one of the 12 principles in the PMBOK® Guide – Seventh Edition.
The concern extends beyond the immediate electrical hazard. How an organization responds to someone reporting a serious safety concern may also affect its ability to identify, communicate and address future risks. That possibility deserves examination, rather than being assumed as an outcome.
I would also distinguish between the PMBOK Guide as a professional reference and the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct, which establishes specific standards of conduct.
The 2025 Code expressly prohibits retaliation against individuals who raise ethical concerns in good faith (Section 2.3.5). This provision could be relevant if the circumstances of the Site Manager's report and subsequent removal fall within its scope.
However, removal following a safety report does not, by itself, establish retaliation. We would need to understand who made the decision, on what grounds, and what measures were taken to address the original hazard. The absence of evidence that the proposed measures were adopted does not necessarily mean that no appropriate safety measures were implemented.
For me, the essential questions are therefore twofold: Was the electrical hazard adequately controlled? And what, if any, consequences did the organization's response have for its ability to identify, communicate and address future risks?
Both questions matter. Neither should be answered by assumption, and any ongoing safety exposure requires immediate attention, regardless of how the personnel decision is ultimately assessed.
...
1 reply by Aleksandar Loncar
Oct 27, 2026 5:42 AM
Aleksandar Loncar
...
Thank you, Luis, for your thoughtful and detailed comment, and particularly for adding Systems Thinking as another relevant principle from the PMBOK® Guide – Seventh Edition.
I agree with your observations, including the need to verify the circumstances presented in my scenario rather than draw conclusions based on assumptions.
The personnel decision also raises questions, as no formal written documentation was provided to explain the change. However, I deliberately left certain employment-related details out of the case study to keep the discussion focused on project management principles and professional ethics.
The matter has been reported to the relevant construction and electrical power authorities. Once the competent inspectorates have carried out their inspections and issued their reports, I expect to be in a better position to address your questions, particularly whether the original electrical hazard was adequately controlled.
avatar
Stelian ROMAN Project Manager| MicroSafety Carlingford, New South Wales, Australia
Interesting situation. Aside from the ethical aspect, which is very important, a project manager's first duty is to deliver the project. This example shows a very poor risk management skills. By removing the site manager, the PM not only doesn't eliminate a risk but also introduces a few more.
1) Team morale: Who will dare to speak if the site manager was removed for doing the right thing
2) Skills: A good (site) manager is not easy to find. It requires experience, knowledge, and skills that are common.
...
1 reply by Aleksandar Loncar
Oct 27, 2026 5:58 AM
Aleksandar Loncar
...
Stelian,

Thank you for your comment. I agree with both points.
Removing a Site Manager under such circumstances can seriously affect team morale, undermine trust and destabilise the project team. It may also discourage other team members from reporting problems and risks in the future.
Your second point is equally important. Even when a qualified replacement is available, a new Site Manager needs time to become familiar with the project, technical documentation, construction methods, ongoing activities and relationships with the project team, subcontractors and supervision.
Depending on the complexity and stage of the project, it may take weeks or even months for a new Site Manager to become as familiar with the project and as effective in managing site activities as the previous Site Manager.
avatar
Aleksandar Loncar Niš, Serbia
Oct 19, 2026 4:52 AM
Replying to Luis Branco
...
Thank you, Aleksandar, for raising such an important issue.
I would add Systems Thinking, one of the 12 principles in the PMBOK® Guide – Seventh Edition.
The concern extends beyond the immediate electrical hazard. How an organization responds to someone reporting a serious safety concern may also affect its ability to identify, communicate and address future risks. That possibility deserves examination, rather than being assumed as an outcome.
I would also distinguish between the PMBOK Guide as a professional reference and the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct, which establishes specific standards of conduct.
The 2025 Code expressly prohibits retaliation against individuals who raise ethical concerns in good faith (Section 2.3.5). This provision could be relevant if the circumstances of the Site Manager's report and subsequent removal fall within its scope.
However, removal following a safety report does not, by itself, establish retaliation. We would need to understand who made the decision, on what grounds, and what measures were taken to address the original hazard. The absence of evidence that the proposed measures were adopted does not necessarily mean that no appropriate safety measures were implemented.
For me, the essential questions are therefore twofold: Was the electrical hazard adequately controlled? And what, if any, consequences did the organization's response have for its ability to identify, communicate and address future risks?
Both questions matter. Neither should be answered by assumption, and any ongoing safety exposure requires immediate attention, regardless of how the personnel decision is ultimately assessed.
Thank you, Luis, for your thoughtful and detailed comment, and particularly for adding Systems Thinking as another relevant principle from the PMBOK® Guide – Seventh Edition.
I agree with your observations, including the need to verify the circumstances presented in my scenario rather than draw conclusions based on assumptions.
The personnel decision also raises questions, as no formal written documentation was provided to explain the change. However, I deliberately left certain employment-related details out of the case study to keep the discussion focused on project management principles and professional ethics.
The matter has been reported to the relevant construction and electrical power authorities. Once the competent inspectorates have carried out their inspections and issued their reports, I expect to be in a better position to address your questions, particularly whether the original electrical hazard was adequately controlled.
...
1 reply by Luis Branco
Oct 27, 2026 11:44 AM
Luis Branco
...
Thank you, Aleksandar, for the clarification and for sharing these developments.

I appreciate your agreement on the importance of establishing the facts before drawing conclusions, and I understand your decision to keep certain employment-related details outside the scope of the case study.

Reporting the matter to the competent authorities is an important development. Their findings may help clarify the electrical hazard, the measures taken to address it and whether further action is required.

One distinction remains essential: reporting a safety concern and establishing that the associated risk is adequately controlled are not the same thing. The involvement of the authorities is important, but it does not, by itself, establish the effectiveness of the measures in place.

I hope the inspections provide the evidence needed to clarify the situation. In the meantime, any continuing safety exposure should be addressed without waiting for the broader questions to be resolved.
avatar
Aleksandar Loncar Niš, Serbia
Oct 21, 2026 12:16 AM
Replying to Stelian ROMAN
...
Interesting situation. Aside from the ethical aspect, which is very important, a project manager's first duty is to deliver the project. This example shows a very poor risk management skills. By removing the site manager, the PM not only doesn't eliminate a risk but also introduces a few more.
1) Team morale: Who will dare to speak if the site manager was removed for doing the right thing
2) Skills: A good (site) manager is not easy to find. It requires experience, knowledge, and skills that are common.
Stelian,

Thank you for your comment. I agree with both points.
Removing a Site Manager under such circumstances can seriously affect team morale, undermine trust and destabilise the project team. It may also discourage other team members from reporting problems and risks in the future.
Your second point is equally important. Even when a qualified replacement is available, a new Site Manager needs time to become familiar with the project, technical documentation, construction methods, ongoing activities and relationships with the project team, subcontractors and supervision.
Depending on the complexity and stage of the project, it may take weeks or even months for a new Site Manager to become as familiar with the project and as effective in managing site activities as the previous Site Manager.
avatar
Luis Branco CEO| Business Insight, Consultores de Gestão, Ldª Carcavelos, Lisboa, Portugal
Oct 27, 2026 5:42 AM
Replying to Aleksandar Loncar
...
Thank you, Luis, for your thoughtful and detailed comment, and particularly for adding Systems Thinking as another relevant principle from the PMBOK® Guide – Seventh Edition.
I agree with your observations, including the need to verify the circumstances presented in my scenario rather than draw conclusions based on assumptions.
The personnel decision also raises questions, as no formal written documentation was provided to explain the change. However, I deliberately left certain employment-related details out of the case study to keep the discussion focused on project management principles and professional ethics.
The matter has been reported to the relevant construction and electrical power authorities. Once the competent inspectorates have carried out their inspections and issued their reports, I expect to be in a better position to address your questions, particularly whether the original electrical hazard was adequately controlled.
Thank you, Aleksandar, for the clarification and for sharing these developments.

I appreciate your agreement on the importance of establishing the facts before drawing conclusions, and I understand your decision to keep certain employment-related details outside the scope of the case study.

Reporting the matter to the competent authorities is an important development. Their findings may help clarify the electrical hazard, the measures taken to address it and whether further action is required.

One distinction remains essential: reporting a safety concern and establishing that the associated risk is adequately controlled are not the same thing. The involvement of the authorities is important, but it does not, by itself, establish the effectiveness of the measures in place.

I hope the inspections provide the evidence needed to clarify the situation. In the meantime, any continuing safety exposure should be addressed without waiting for the broader questions to be resolved.

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:

"Take care of the luxuries and the necessities will take care of themselves."

- Dorothy Parker

Sponsors