Central Question
How should a Project Director respond when a small group of team members has disproportionate influence over him, and he appears to accept their version of events without giving other team members a fair opportunity to present their perspective?
What can be done to ensure balanced communication, objective decision-making, and a healthy project team environment?
1. Team Management
How does a situation develop in which a few team members gain disproportionate influence over the Project Director and discredit other colleagues?
- Formation of informal groups and alliances.
- Erosion of mutual trust.
- Consequences for collaboration, information sharing, and team performance.
2. Stakeholder Management
How does the Project Director collect, verify, and evaluate information from different participants?
- Do all relevant participants have an opportunity to present their perspective?
- How are conflicts of interest between team members addressed?
3. Leadership
Why does the Project Director accept one version of events without hearing the other side?
- Premature conclusions.
- The influence of personal relationships on professional decision-making.
4. Decision-Making and Governance
How can the organization ensure that decisions affecting people and the project are based on relevant information?
- Verification of claims and examination of relevant evidence.
- Transparent decision-making criteria.
5. Project Performance and Risk
What consequences can one-sided decision-making have for the project?
- Loss of professional expertise and important information.
- Important problems and warnings being overlooked or dismissed.
- Poor decisions, conflicts, delays, and additional costs.
Ethical Analysis Through the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct
The situation can also be examined through the four core values of the PMI Code of Ethics: Responsibility, Respect, Fairness, and Honesty.
A. Project Director — Ethical Responsibilities
1. Responsibility
- 2.1 — Description of Responsibility: Taking ownership of decisions made or not made, actions taken or not taken, and their resulting consequences.
- 2.2.5: Taking prompt corrective action when errors or omissions are discovered and accepting responsibility for issues resulting from one's own errors or omissions.
2. Respect
- 3.2.3: Actively listening to others' points of view and seeking to understand them.
- 3.2.4: Encouraging and valuing diverse perspectives.
- 3.2.6: Avoiding gossip, spreading false or unconfirmed information, and making remarks that undermine another person's reputation.
3. Fairness
- 4.2.1: Transparency in the decision-making process.
- 4.2.2: Examining one's own impartiality and objectivity.
- 4.3.5: Applying organizational rules without favoritism or prejudice.
4. Honesty
- 5.2.1: Making a sincere effort to discover the truth.
- 5.2.2: Being truthful in communication and behavior.
- 5.2.5: Creating an environment in which people feel safe to speak the truth.
B. Members of the Informal Group or Alliance — Ethical Analysis
1. Responsibility
- Do group members contribute to resolving project problems, or do they use their conversations with the Project Director primarily to weaken the position of other team members?
2. Respect
- Do they respect the professional dignity of other team members?
- Do they encourage constructive exchanges of views or create an atmosphere of distrust and mutual disparagement?
- Do they try to understand other people's perspectives, or do they portray others in a way that undermines their professional reputation?
3. Fairness
- Do they seek to ensure that the Project Director hears only their version of events?
- Do they deny others the opportunity to present their perspective?
4. Honesty
- Do group members provide truthful and complete information?
- Do they present only part of an event, omitting facts that could change the Project Director's conclusion?
Relevant PMI Code of Ethics Provisions
Respect
- 3.2.6: Avoiding gossip, spreading false or unconfirmed information, and making remarks that undermine another person's reputation.
Fairness
- 4.3.4: Treating all individuals fairly and consistently.
- 4.3.5: Applying organizational rules without favoritism or prejudice.
Honesty
- 5.3.1: Not engaging in behavior designed to deceive others, including making misleading or false statements, stating half-truths, presenting information out of context, or withholding information that would make statements misleading or incomplete.
- 5.3.2: Not engaging in dishonest behavior with the intention of personal gain or at the expense of another.
Final Question
What practical steps can a Project Director take to prevent informal alliances one-sided communication, and personal relationships from undermining fair decision-making and project performance?
(The Author initially considered examining this topic through the principles of project management presented in PMBOK® Guide – Seventh Edition. However, the five project management perspectives used in this discussion provided a more suitable framework for exploring the issue and its implications for project management practice.)