Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

Project Director's Expectations vs. Site Manager's Professional Judgement

linkedin twitter facebook   Governance   Leadership   Teams  
avatar
Aleksandar Loncar Niš, Serbia

How should a Project Director manage situations in which a Site Manager must make operational decisions on site?

For example, a Site Manager makes a decision based on his professional judgment. When questioned by the Project Director, he explains that, in his opinion, it was the best approach under the circumstances. The Project Director responds:

"You should act in accordance with my opinion, not yours."

If the Project Director expects the Site Manager to act in accordance with his own judgment rather than the Site Manager's professional assessment, how should those expectations be communicated in advance?

Can a Site Manager be held responsible for not following an approach or decision that was never previously communicated to him?

Where should the boundary lie between delegated authority, professional judgment and the Project Director's decision-making authority?

avatar
Luis Branco CEO| Business Insight, Consultores de Gestão, Ldª Carcavelos, Lisboa, Portugal
Aleksandar, thank you for raising an important question about delegated authority, professional judgment and accountability in project management.

I would begin by distinguishing expectations, personal preferences, instructions and authorized decisions. They are not interchangeable, and a Project Director's hierarchical position does not automatically make every personal preference a binding instruction or the technically soundest approach.

Equally, a Site Manager's professional judgment does not, by itself, establish that a decision was appropriate or within delegated authority.

Before assessing either person's conduct, we need to understand the decision involved, the authority delegated to the Site Manager, the applicable technical, contractual, organizational and safety requirements, the information available at the time, and whether consultation or escalation was required and feasible.

This distinction is particularly important when considering accountability. A Site Manager should not be held responsible merely for failing to anticipate an uncommunicated personal preference. However, the absence of a specific instruction does not remove responsibility for complying with established requirements or exercising appropriate professional judgment.

Effective delegation should therefore clarify decision rights, boundaries, expected outcomes, consultation requirements and escalation mechanisms. Within those boundaries, professional judgment should be exercised responsibly, not replaced by an obligation to anticipate the Project Director's opinions.

When disagreements arise, consultation can help clarify the relevant facts, evidence and different professional assessments. Where legitimate interests or alternative compliant solutions need to be reconciled, negotiation can help establish workable commitments. If a decision or escalation is required, it should follow the established allocation of authority. Those providing information, advising, deciding and implementing remain responsible for their respective contributions and obligations.

Importantly, disagreement should not automatically be treated as insubordination, nor should delegated authority be interpreted as unrestricted autonomy. Professional objections must be considered on their merits, particularly when safety, compliance or significant project consequences are involved.

Implementation and consequences should also be monitored proportionately, with corrective action or a more formal review when justified. Disagreements may reveal not only problems with individual decisions but also weaknesses in delegation, communication or governance.

Perhaps the fundamental question is not whose opinion should prevail, but how the organization ensures that authority, professional judgment, consultation and accountability operate coherently, without requiring anyone to guess another person's expectations.

What practical safeguards have you found most effective in maintaining that balance?

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:

When someone is lying, is it true that their pants are actually on fire?

- Jerry Seinfeld

Sponsors