Project Management

Please login or join to subscribe to this thread

MBA vs. Master in PM

linkedin twitter facebook   Career Development  
avatar
Allan Mak Kowloon, Hong Kong
I am planning to pursue my PMP certification by Q1 2005. In the meantime, I am thinking to pursue a higher education, either MBA or Master in PM. Would PMP is good enough to proven one's PM professional? Necessary for Master in PM? What I consider is ... market value. Please advise!
Sort By:
avatar
Tom Welch PMP Mesa, Az, United States
Go for the PMP 1st and dedicate yourself to life long learning. I'm not sure there's a payoff for completing an advanced degree since 95% of the CIOs in the USA only have a 4 year college degree.
avatar
Mark Price Perry Business Driven PMO Evangelist| BOT International Orlando, Fl, United States
Dear Allan, I agree with Tom. If you are a project manager, go ahead and get your PMP. Regarding pursuing higher education, I would seek to align your professional aspirations with a plan and commitment to life long learning in support of those aspirations. You might ask your manager or HR executive at your company for a career counseling meeting. Additionally, if you don't have one already, identify and maintain a relationship with a mentor or two. This can be an expert or executive in your company or an outside professional relationship. If you ask, they will mentor - in fact, they won't stop mentoring..! Hope this helps. -- Mark Perry, VP of Customer Care, BOT International
avatar
Bethany Schoenick PMP Montgomery, Al, United States
Having already earned both my PMP and Masters' Certificate in IT Project Management, I am now working towards a Masters of Science in Project Management. The rational behind my thinking is two fold. 1. I am now a Project Manager but eventually I want to become a Program Manager and run a PMO. After that, I'd like to be a departent VP or CIO at a medium sized company. All the job postings I have seen for Program Manager and above have had a Masters Degree listed as a requirement(they don't always specify in what field, just that you have a Master's Degree). 2. Running a department, or for that matter, running a company, is like running a slightly larger program - Thus I determined that getting the Masters in Project Management would be better than the traditional MBA. I may be wrong but that is my thought. If you are a project manager now or are trying to become one and do not have any plans to go futher in the career path, than I would say getting your PMP is more important (and more cost and time efficient) than getting your Master's. However, if you want to go further, I would recommend both. bethany
avatar
Dennis Hermann Severna Park, Md, United States
I would recommend a PMP because the market for project managers is demanding this certification. I would highly recommend a Masters because you will demonstrate your ability to learn and apply knowledge.
Having an MBA also puts you above the rest because it shows you are capable of setting a goal and accomplishing it. An MBA is also a requirement determined by the job market.
But with an MBA you are more likely to obtain skills for problem solving and look at the big picture.
HTH
Dennis
avatar
T Maxter Folsom, Ca, United States
I would have to agree with Dennis. Go with the PMP over a MS in Project Management. I also believe an MBA will give you a much better advantage over an MS of Project Management since it will make you much more versatile to companies should you want to grow beyond being a project manager or a program manager at some point in your career.
avatar
Kevin Friedel Project Manager| BNP Paribas Cortlandt Manor, Ny, United States
Allan,
In my experience, your education should be aligned with your career goals. If you aspire to be a PM, then an MBA is not required. I have an MBA and as a PM, the MBA has not really mattered. An MS, in any discipline, is a cheaper alternative and takes a lot less time to complete but again, you should only pursue a degree if the career that you eventually want to have demands it. My SME is in financial services, specifically trading and investment banking. My ability to get new work as a consultant is based on two things: my previous experience/skills and networking. My MBA looks good, but rarely makes a difference.

Please login or join to reply

Content ID:
ADVERTISEMENTS

"Nearly every great advance in science arises from a crisis in the old theory, through an endeavor to find a way out of the difficulties created. We must examine old ideas, old theories, although they belong to the past, for this is the only way to understand the importance of the new ones and the extent of their validity."

- Albert Einstein

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors