Project Management

Are Your Team Members Less Engaged Than Ever?

From the Strategic Project Management Blog
by
As an "accidental" project manager, it's very satisfying to contribute to the project management community online with anecdotes and stories I've picked up from my own experience. I hope you enjoy our daily conversation.

About this Blog

RSS

Recent Posts

Tell Me You're Going to Get This Done

Quiting Isn't Easy if You Never Do It

Getting in the Way of Peak Performance

The Agony of Defeat?

Nobody Likes Being the Heavy

Categories

decision-making, empowering team members, project leadership, project management, project management fundamentals, project success, project teams, struggling projects, work management

Date

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


dominoesI think we can all agree that engaged team members are more productive, happier and more likely to contribute to the project team at a higher level, however a study conducted last year by Hewitt Associates suggests that employee engagement experienced the biggest decline in more than 15 years. Is this still true today? What do you see among your team?

"It's hard to pinpoint exactly why employees are so disconnected from their work these days," writes Toddi Gutner for the Business On Main section of MSN.com. "Industry experts cite any number of reasons, including management distrust, lack of job mobility in the recession, and CEO turnover, among other things."

Gutner suggests that the most important thing to consider (and I agree), is the "toxic" effect that disengaged employees can have on the rest of the workforce. My biggest concern, and I don't think I'm alone, is the upcoming talent migration that will negatively impact all those organizations that took advantage of their workforce or didn't do anything to keep their employees engaged during the tough economic times. I'm starting to see some of this happening now as the economy seems to be improving.

The good news is that it isn't money that keeps people engaged. Gutner writes about Teresa Amabile, a professor of business administration and a director of research at the Harvard Business School, who asked 238 people to write in an electronic diary every day for five months about how they felt about their work and how committed they were to do a great job. I think you might find the results interesting.

"We found that the most important indicators on employee engagement [were] not things that most managers think about," said Amabile. "The most important event that happened was simply 'making progress in meaningful work.' That's not what we expected."

When Amibile describes meaningful work, she talks about "work where the person is contributing something of real value, something they care about. If they could find meaning to the work—even contributing value to the team or the organization—this would make a difference."

This flies in the face of those who suggest that team members simply need to complete the tasks on their task lists. As project leaders, regardless of the work management tools we use, we need to be giving team members the opportunity to contribute at a higher level. And this means making sure everyone on the team understands what objectives their project might be designed to obtain, what their individual contribution might add to the project and how their efforts impact the rest of the team as they work towards a common goal.

Citing Lynne Sarikas, director of the MBA career center at Northwestern University's College of Business, Gutner writes, "There are two factors to employee engagement: How the individual feels engaged with their specific job, and how the individual feels engaged with the company."

When measured against that scale, how is your team doing?
 


Posted on: July 26, 2011 11:32 AM | Permalink

Comments (3)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
avatar
Julie Goff Brisbane, Q, Australia
I couldn't agree more and I wonder why it is surprising? Surely managers don't think that their staff are too different from themselves? If they themselves find job satisfaction by doing meaningful work, why should everyone else be different?

Too many managers treat their staff as just cogs in the wheel and then wonder why they are disengaged!

I worked for a small company who worked hard at trying to get employee engagement and loyalty, but in the end they failed because its business model was a "body shop". They hired staff to put into other companies as consultants. Everyone knew that there was no career path and no guarantee of long term employment, and this was proved true when the GFC hit and numerous people, including myself were laid off. I was "engaged" with the work because it was an interesting project but not "engaged" with the company. A real life example of the two aspects of engagement.

avatar
Ty Kiisel Manager Social Outreach| AtTask Lehi, Ut, United States
Julie,

Thanks for your comments. I've worked in places like that before too. Unfortunately, it's a short-sighted view of how to interact with the workplace. I once learned that your company's brand is not what you say you are. It's your values and how you act upon those values at every point of contact with your customers and your employees. You can say what you are all you want, but eventually what you really are will be exposed and you will be naked to the truth.

For those organizations that only give lip service to empowering their employees, they will never gain the full benefit of actually empowering their employees.

Thanks again,

—Ty

avatar
Wai Mun Koo PMO Director| Intergraph PP&M Singapore, Singapore
Most disengaged employees are usually in a 'lost' state. As a manager, we need to help them find their purpose when they are lost and not just throw them your purpose. Your purpose and what motivate you might not motivate your employees. Moreover, what you are doing might not be the same as what your employees are doing even all of you are in the same project. Do not expect your employees to be able to find their purpose themselves and re-engaged back. If they are able to, they will not get into the 'lost' state in the first place.

For those who are on the right path and engaged, it is important to occasionally give them a pat on the back and a few encouraging words to let them know they are doing fine and help them stay engaged. If you neglected them for too long, there is a likelihood that they will get 'lost' and start to disengage.

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

ADVERTISEMENTS

"No man who has once heartily and wholly laughed can be altogether irreclaimably bad."

- Thomas Carlyle

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors