Project Management

Does It Matter If It's Not Your Career?

From the Strategic Project Management Blog
by
As an "accidental" project manager, it's very satisfying to contribute to the project management community online with anecdotes and stories I've picked up from my own experience. I hope you enjoy our daily conversation.

About this Blog

RSS

Recent Posts

Tell Me You're Going to Get This Done

Quiting Isn't Easy if You Never Do It

Getting in the Way of Peak Performance

The Agony of Defeat?

Nobody Likes Being the Heavy

Categories

decision-making, empowering team members, project leadership, project management, project management fundamentals, project success, project teams, struggling projects, work management

Date

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


overworked and understaffedOver the last several months (if not the last year) I've expressed my concerns about the potential for a mass talent migration from organizations who have compelled the workforce to work and produce more for less. Anecdotally, I know of a number of people who are very frustrated at the hamster wheel the feel they are on. They complain that every day there is another crisis that requires them to work extra hours and feel extra stress. Although I agree (and support the notion) that there are times when it's important to put in some extra effort, when crunch time becomes all the time—I think there is something wrong.

In an article published on the Grapevine, Owen Morgan asks, "So why are so many employees currently thinking about changing employers—and at a time of such economic uncertainty?"

I don't know if you are seeing this in your organization or among the members of your project teams, but I predict that this could become a pretty big problem for many organizations who depend on their people to create and innovate. Which is why I ask the question, "Does it really matter if it's not your career?"

I think it does.

I work with a colleague who is a very talented and capable manager. One night last week as we were getting ready to leave the office, he commented that he felt like part of his responsibility as a leader was to help advance the career of those who worked on his team. Although I have never articulated it that way, I have to agree. In fact, some of the accomplishments I'm most proud of involve helping individuals on my team advance and succeed in their careers.

"Development is the key word here—while many employees will claim that another role offers greater rewards," writes Morgan. "In many cases these are unlikely to be solely of a financial nature. It's well known that people move roles for a variety of reasons, but the search for new experiences and challenges is often foremost among them—doubly so for those who are driven, innovate and unprepared to accept the status-quo—just the sort of people that organizations cannot afford to lose and who will be able to help their employer through the challenging times that lie ahead."

I'm convinced that people are less motivated by money than we might think. However, that doesn't mean that we can get away with poor pay and poor benefits. What it does mean is that if you're not the New York Yankees, you can still build a championship baseball team (without buying it).

In other words, according to Morgan, "Most forward-thinking organizations have identified their talent and even though some development opportunities are likely to have fallen along the wayside, effective and open conversations between line managers and their teams, articulating the importance of an individual to the future success of the organization can work wonders. Truly effective managers rise to the challenge here, and at the same time as ensuring that the team is deployed to achieve the short and medium-term organizational objectives that are set, they never lose sight of the longer term and how their individual team members might play a part in it."

Unfortunately, this type of behavior seems to the be the exception rather than the rule. Do the members of your project team know that you value what they do and that their contributions to the team are important to the success of your organization? If they don't, it might be time to do something about it.

In a nutshell, Morgan sums it up this way, "So telling people they have a career with their current employer and not just a job can reduce the instances of those looking to leave."

This doesn't mean that I'm advocating that we tell our team members that we expect them to treat what they do as more than a job. That will happen naturally when we treat them as something more than mindless employees compelled to do mindless tasks.

Does it matter if it's not your career? It absolutely does.
 


Posted on: September 07, 2011 11:48 AM | Permalink

Comments (5)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
avatar
Kenneth Katz Release Train Engineer/IT Project Manager| UnitedHealth Group Enfield, Ct, United States
"I'm convinced that people are less motivated by money than we might think." If that is true, why do corporate executives, management consultants, and investment bankers earn so much? Presumably their employers could save money by reducing their pay from astronomical to merely high.

avatar
Thomas Soam Project Manager| BDA Seremban Ns, Ns, Malaysia
Hi Ty,
I agree with your thought. Also this depand on the individual, for me to complete and success a project i fell self satisfying.

avatar
Ty Kiisel Manager Social Outreach| AtTask Lehi, Ut, United States
Great comments.

Kenneth, I agree that money is important, but it''''s not what really motivates people. I agree that there are some folks that make obscene amounts of money—there are days when I wouldn''''t mind being one of them. However, money isn''t a primary motivator. I''''m not sure where it is, but at some point you make enough money—at that point it''''s the challenges of the job, the team you work with, the environment you work in and your perceived value to the effort that really motivates.

avatar
Kenneth Katz Release Train Engineer/IT Project Manager| UnitedHealth Group Enfield, Ct, United States
Ty, people continue to assert what you say, but their behavior says otherwise. I doubt that being an investment banker is all that interesting. Have you ever actually seen what an associate at a high-powered corporate law firm does? Grinding, deadly dull work is what they do. But investment bankers and attorneys at high-powered corporate law firms make tons of money, and lots of people aspire to those jobs.

Being an IT project manager is a fine job, and I certainly have a strong sense of loyalty to my company, my boss and my colleagues, all of whom have treated me very well for a long time. But being an IT project manager is also well-compensated work, not as well-compensated as an investment banker or attorney but still relatively highly paid. That is a huge consideration and there is no way that the field would attract the capable people that it does if that were not the case.

That''s not to say that high pay can or should substitute for other things like treating people with dignity and respect. But to minimize the importance of high pay is a mistake.

avatar
Ty Kiisel Manager Social Outreach| AtTask Lehi, Ut, United States
Kenneth,

I'm not suggesting that compensation is not an important part of the package. What I am saying is that money is not what motivates performance long term. Sure, the potential for a bonus or a pay raise might increase performance for the short term, but it is not the primary long-term motivator some people think it is. For example, I know that stock brokers and investment bankers made gobs-o-cash, but I wonder what the expected longevity of those careers might be. How much burnout do they have to deal with.

How much burnout is there among IT project managers?

Compensation is an important factor, however there are many professions (that require college degrees) that make substantially less that investment bankers, and they seem to have a pretty steady stream of people who are willing to spend their lives in those careers.

However, I totally agree with your last statement, "That's not to say that high pay can or should substitute for other things like treating people with dignity and respect. But to minimize the importance of pay is a mistake."

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

ADVERTISEMENTS

Do, or else do not. There is no 'try'.

- Yoda

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors