Project Management

Scrum, it's not you, it's me and hope we can still be friends

From the Agility and Project Leadership Blog
by
A contrarian and provocative blog that goes beyond the traditional over-hyped dogma of "Agile", so as to obtain true agility and project leadership through a process of philosophical reflection.

About this Blog

RSS

Recent Posts

Has Scrum outlived its usefulness? Should Scrum just go away?

The rise of Agile’s SAFe is like a bad episode of the movie Groundhog Day

Marcel Proust’s recursive novel: Why the concept of iteration in Agile is shortsighted

Forecast for 2015: The beginning of the end of Agile?

Google considered the best US company to work for due to HR agility

Categories

Date

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


(NOTE: The post below is not really my personal view, more of a sentiment I'm seeing amongst those practicing Scrum, though I agree much with it.)

I really loved the idea of Scrum, really I did!  But I’m starting to realize that in reality, what was supposed to release me from the shackles of the tyranny of my Gantt chart cum waterfall ways is the fact that I’m now feeling the very same burden and overhead for which I wished to escape!

The fact is that Scrum ass-u-me’s that we are good at estimating.  In fact very good, because only then could you finish a working deliverable at the end of each Sprint.  The problem was that we’re not, yet the irony is that by breaking things down into Sprint iterations that were badly estimated, we ended up jerry rigging the estimation for the next Sprint which cause Sprint after Sprint to miss their deliverables.  Rather than get frustrated over a prolonged period of time after a traditional planning process, we would get bursts of frustrations that started making us exhausted.

On exhaustion, while it initially seemed a great idea to have daily stand-up meetings, Sprint planning meetings and all that good stuff, like anything else people show up and are enthusiastic at first, but then as time moves on and the bottlenecks start to occur as described above, you as ScrumMaster will become quite prickly and everyone working around you demoralized or bored.

And for all you “Certified Scrum Coaches”, don’t tell me that “we’re just doing it wrong” as that’s starting to sound trite.  I harbor no grudge against the Scrum framework, but like all good things it must come to an end and someone (maybe me!) will come up with a new twist to an old trick and get us all moving and excited again (Kanban anyone?).

Scrum, it's not you, it's me and hope we can still be friends.


Posted on: January 31, 2014 02:04 PM | Permalink

Comments (3)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
avatar
Madhava Verma Dantuluri IT company Delhi, India
It is Scrum!

avatar
Wayne Mack Retired| Retired South Riding, Va, United States
The letter writer has missed the key concept in agile, that scope can be, and may expected to be, deferred. A Sprint is not a mini-Firm Fixed Price contract and there is no guarantee that everything specified will be completed.


Scrum or Kanban are not silver bullets that cause the development team to be drastically more efficient. They do provide, however, a way to track progress. The major difference is that management is expected to define the minimal baseline for delivery early in the project and not at the end when the project is already months late.


There are no guarantees that initial estimates are accurate. What will be known accurately, though, is how much progress has been made to date.

avatar
Alaa Hussein Program Manager| MEMECS Baghdad, Iraq
Thanks for sharing

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

ADVERTISEMENTS

"Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest."

- Mark Twain

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors