Project Management

On Going Too Far, Part II

From the Game Theory in Management Blog
by
Modelling Business Decisions and their Consequences

About this Blog

RSS

Recent Posts

On Going Too Far, Part II

The Problem With PM Audit Standards

On Going Too Far…

Are We Having Fun Yet?

The Management Genius Of Abraham Lincoln

Categories

Game Theory, PMO, Politics, Risk Management, Strategic Management

Date

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


Last month I wrote about those instances where Project Management principles have been pushed past the point of true efficacy, or have “gone too far.” But it’s not just PM that does this – the other two aspects of Corner Cube theory, Asset and Strategic Management, are also very capable of going too far. For this blog I will address the easier of the two, when the over-pursuit of Asset Management narratives ends up harming the organization.
There is a Japanese restaurant in my home town that I used to love patronizing, every year on my birthday. For the first few years it was a delightful experience, and was well-known for providing a delightful experience. Attempting same-day reservations was not a good idea, leading me to believe that it was a popular destination. While no formal dress code was articulated or enforced, most of the men were in slacks and collared shirts, at least. The waiting room was spacious and well-furnished, and we were always seated within minutes of our reservation time. Upon being seated our drink orders were taken, and we were presented with oshibori (warmed, as my birthday is in late Autumn). The Japanese accoutrement appeared authentic, the service great, and the chefs both highly skilled and entertaining. Like I said, a delightful experience.
But then something happened after those first years. We would have to wait for ten, then fifteen, then more minutes from the reservation time to actually being seated. They had moved, and the new facility had a smaller waiting area. Also, there were more chairs around the teppan grill, meaning that one was more likely to find themselves shoulder-to-shoulder with a complete stranger. No oshibori was presented, and drink orders were being taken later than before. Still, the food was good enough to justify continued patronage; but, after some time, even that began to deteriorate. The décor also appeared to never change, and patrons were often in shorts and sports jerseys. The online reviews reflected the drop in quality. Disappointingly, after years of looking forward to having my birthday celebrated there, we simply stopped.
Of course, I have no way of knowing this, but it’s easy for me to speculate that some accountant, or a believer in their mantra about how the point of all management is to “maximize shareholder wealth,” told this establishment’s management that they could save money by, say, eliminating the oshibori, or reducing the payroll by getting rid of wait staff, or paying less for their cooks. But here’s the thing about cashing in (so to speak) on opportunities to save costs: while it’s easy to quantify how much money is being “saved,” it’s next to impossible to capture the trade-off in marginal disappointments to the customers. Indeed, of the list I provided above it’s hard to identify the exact point that the decision to not go back was attained. I just know that it was, and it's final. I’m never going back.
I’m confident that this experience is not uncommon. Almost every member of GTIM Nation will probably have a similar experience with a restaurant, café, or even coffee shop that they used to like to frequent, but ended up compromising quality in an attempt to “save costs.” But that’s the natural outcome of maintaining the Asset Managers’ belief that the point of all management is to “maximize shareholder wealth.” Even in the organization’s earliest phases, when a new product is being introduced, or a fresh approach to delivering a service is competing for acceptance, the Asset Manager’s focus is, generally speaking, not on satisfying customers. It’s on monetizing said product or service. Making the customer happy is in the PM’s wheelhouse, as all of our techniques and information systems are oriented towards that end. I would go so far as to assert that the key indicator of whether an organization is in its business ascendency or decline is to be found in ascertaining if the preponderance of its focus is on making its customers happy, or maximizing the monetization of its assets. As in the case of restaurants, this tipping point won’t be obvious in other organizations, and will usually not be recognized until after it has passed. But by then, of course, it will be too late.
So, how does one know if the Asset Managers’ narrative has gone too far, and has informed the formulation of the Project-based organization’s strategies to its own detriment? Projects being cancelled for cause is the most obvious sign, but a notable drop in proposal win rates – especially with established clients – would be another. But the leader of these signs, in many cases, will be an increase in the number of Projects in the portfolio that either project or experience over-budget or late completions.
And that indicator, that the Asset Managers have gone too far, is entirely in PM’s domain.

Posted on: November 19, 2026 08:23 PM | Permalink

Comments (0)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item


Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

"The golden rule is that there are no golden rules."

- George Bernard Shaw

Sponsors