Leverage diversity when boldly going where no one has gone before!
From the Easy in theory, difficult in practice Blog
by Kiron Bondale
My musings on project management, project portfolio management and change management.
I'm a firm believer that a pragmatic approach to organizational change that addresses process & technology, but primarily, people will maximize chances for success.
This blog contains articles which I've previously written and published as well as new content.
Recent Posts
Leading Through Crisis Means Leading Through Context
"It's the end. But the moment has been prepared for." - retirement lessons from the Doctor
Just because they are non-critical, doesn't mean they are not risky!
Just because they are non-critical, doesn't mean they are not risky!
How will YOU avoid these AI-related cognitive biases?
Categories
Agile,
Artificial Intelligence,
Career Development,
Change Management,
Communications Management,
Decision Making,
Governance,
Hiring,
Kanban,
Lessons Learned,
Personal Development,
PMO,
Portfolio Management,
Project Management,
Resource Management,
Risk Management,
Risk Management,
Schedule Management,
Scheduling,
Tools
Date
When Gene Roddenberry staffed the U.S.S. Enterprise with a highly diverse set of races, species & genders, he used Star Trek as his soapbox to challenge pervasive social injustices of the late Sixties. However, by doing so, he also provided another benefit of diversity: improved risk management.
When you consider the Enterprise’s original mission, it meets many of the criteria for a large, highly complex project:
- Scope – to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations.
- Schedule – five years.
- A unique endeavor – its original mission statement “to boldly go where no one has gone before” reinforces how unique the mission was.
In multiple episodes from the original series, and later through some of the movies, we saw instances of where diversity was a key contributor in helping the crew overcome dire situations. One such example comes from Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan. Of the entire crew, Spock was the only person strong enough to withstand the radiation within the matter/antimatter chamber to jump start the Enterprise’s engines. Anyone other than a Vulcan would likely have been overwhelmed before the process could have been completed.
So how does diversity facilitate more effective risk management?
When identifying risks, use of checklists and historical data can help surface uncertainties which would otherwise have been missed, but they are no substitute for a diverse range of expertise. If team members and stakeholders have similar educational and experiential backgrounds, there is a greater possibility of key risks remaining unidentified.
When analyzing risks or when monitoring early warning signs of risk realization, diversity is a good way to overcome risk biases and groupthink.
Finally, the quality of risk responses is constrained by the creativity and imagination of the team. It is well known that properly harnessed diversity promotes greater creativity.
So the next time you have the opportunity to tackle a challenging project, resist the temptation to staff the project with team members who are just like you by making diversity one of the key criteria for resource selection.
(Note: this article was originally written and published by me in September 2014 on my personal blog, kbondale.wordpress.com)
Posted on: April 20, 2018 07:00 AM |
Permalink
Comments (16)
Please login or join to subscribe to this item
Good article Kiron!
You make some good points on leveraging diverse project team members.
Kathy Castle
Author at https://www.projectcubicle.com/| Freelance
Tx, United States
Thank your for this informative post
Anish Abraham
Privacy Program Manager| University of Washington
Auburn, Wa, United States
Good insights on leveraging diversity, Kiron. I think bringing people together from a wide variety of backgrounds enrich project management with diversity of thought, skills and creative ideas.
Aaron Porter
Community Champion
IT Director| Blade HQ
Payson, UT, United States
This presents an interesting challenge. Job descriptions are usually written in a way that they are asking for something specific. You want to hire someone with specific education and specific project experience. People tailor their resumes and answer interview questions in such a way as to present a picture of how they will fit with the company. If the resume does not meet certain criteria, it won't make it past the initial screening; there won't be an interview. So, how do you demonstrate diversity of experience and diversity of thought on your resume, and still get an interview? How do you do this in an interview AND convince the interviewer that you are a good fit?
As an interviewer, I'm looking for the best qualified person. If I have two equally qualified candidates, the candidate that is more personable and gives better answers, in my opinion, is most likely going to be who I select. Unless the person I'm interviewing is absolutely brilliant, it's going to be very uncomfortable to hire someone if their thought processes or experiences are too different, and some people don't want to hire someone smarter than they think they are.
We may want diversity of thought and experience, but how many people really know how to recognize it and hire for it?
Dinah Young
Project Manager / Software Asset Manager| Prince William County
Springfield, Va, United States
Years ago, I worked for a couple of small start up companies. I realized that when you start a business together you often do so with people who are like you. So all of the executives (founders) with similar aged white men. They actually were making an effort to diversify their staff. I think the challenge was that people tend to be "attracted to" what they know, so they choose people like themselves at first. By the time I left they had a lot more diversity.
Thanks Kathy & Anish!
Aaron & Dinah - it's a great point that both of you make. Taking diversity into consideration when hiring is not a natural habit and hence we need to train ourselves to get comfortable with it. One approach might be to pair up not only on interviews but also on resume reviews so that a candidate we might have eliminated at the resume stage gets a second pair of eyes considering whether they might be worth speaking with...
Kiron
Rami Kaibni
Community Champion
Senior Projects Manager | Field & Marten Associates
New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
Good Points Kiron - Diversity is very important and I personally experienced this when I used to manage projects overseas and specifically in the middle east.
Very interesting, thanks for sharing
Paul Boudreau
President| Stonemeadow Consulting
Kanata, Ontario, Canada
Good article. Concise and clear. Thanks
Thanks Rami, Eduin & Paul!
Diversity produces better results, in almost all cases.
It's like the old saying, there is no valuable information gained when someone agrees with you. Diversity in opinions and viewpoints (and the ensuing conflict scenarios) are all vital elements to rapid progress in any endeavour.
As an aside, the writers of the follow-on Star Trek series have deeply embraced this concept of diversity. Take Guinan's, Worf's and Troi's viewpoints on TNG; or Kira, Dax(es), Odo, and Quark from DS9; or Neelix and Tuvok duking it out on VOY (or, indeed, any of the others) - there has always been an approach to welcome diverse viewpoints and consider all inputs before taking a decision.
They even have Q popping up periodically to remind us what can happen if diverse viewpoints are considered unimportant.
Thanks Karan - you are absolutely correct - while the FX and acting has improved over subsequent iterations of the franchise, Infinite Diversity in Infinite Combinations remains a core principle!
Wow, this is a really very good article, but I wonder how many people out there who really believe in diversity as "Diversity produces better results"
Thanks Kevin!
When discussing it in principle there are likely to be few who would argue this, but it's when they are faced with a decision to either pick those who are similar to them or purposefully pick who are not that we see if they truly believe.
Kiron
Please Login/Register to leave a comment.
|
"Technology is a gift of God. After the gift of life it is perhaps the greatest of God's gifts. It is the mother of civilizations, of arts and of sciences."
- Freeman Dyson
|