Project Management

Why project work doesn't get completed early...

From the Easy in theory, difficult in practice Blog
by
My musings on project management, project portfolio management and change management. I'm a firm believer that a pragmatic approach to organizational change that addresses process & technology, but primarily, people will maximize chances for success. This blog contains articles which I've previously written and published as well as new content.

About this Blog

RSS

Recent Posts

Think top-down and bottom-up for agile transformations

Why project work doesn't get completed early...

But what will our staff do if we don't focus on their utilization?

How does psychological safety relate to holding space?

Securing contingency reserves is the responsible thing to do!



I usually advise my students to encourage their team members to not provide padded work estimates, but rather to make schedule contingencies visible and tie these contingencies to milestones rather than to individual activities.

This is intended to counter the potential confluence of Parkinson's Law (work expands so as to fill the time available for its completion), Student Syndrome (let's wait till the very last possible moment to start an undesired activity) and Murphy's Law (anything that can go wrong will go wrong).

While this behavior might be true in some circumstances, it is based on a rather Theory X view of the world. Student Syndrome hurts no one other than the student procrastinating on starting their homework assignments or preparing for an exam. With projects, the impact of delays from one team member ripple downstream to others so with the exception of that small minority of Homer Simpson-like workers most of us want to do a good day's work.

So if the fault doesn't lie with the individual contributors, where else could we look for answers?

Today's Dilbert cartoon provides us with better root causes for this behavior - the system which people work in or the managers they work for.

How could the system affect work completion? Poorly thought out performance measures are one way:

  • If staff are measured based on utilization, then completing work in less time means they are either going to be reprimanded or handed more work which they might not be able to complete by working a sustainable pace.
  • If they are paid based on the hours they work, they could be tempted to work to plan to avoid being financially penalized for completing early.
  • If they are measured based on the accuracy of their predictions (I.e. they are penalized for being early or late), then the work will tend to be completed exactly on time.
  • If they are forced to fill out weekly timesheets and the process to do so is onerous, it might be easier for them to just copy planned time over as actual time within their time recording system.

Managers can also inadvertently cause staff to complete work on time, but rarely early by:

  • Penalizing team members who complete work early on their future tasks by setting unrealistic target dates
  • Giving them additional projects or operational activities to do rather than letting them use that slack time productively
  • Breaking their focus by interrupting their work with urgent but un-important tasks

If we recognize that project activity durations are more likely to follow a lognormal distribution than the nice symmetrical normal distribution which we hope for, then we should praise team members for completing work early (within quality, safety, health and other constraints) rather than introducing impediments which discourage them from doing so.

Posted on: October 11, 2020 07:00 AM | Permalink

Comments (7)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
Unfortunately I think Student Syndrome is the most common issue with the added risk of Murphy's Law on top! One of my managers says that nothing would ever be finished if not for the last minute!

But then I think that's one of the key benefits of and agile (small "a"), adaptive or iterative approach, you break activities into easily visualisable (if there's such a word) chunks with more immediate time frames. It helps keep focus but done well/properly is also realistic about what can be delivered in each chunk.

Thanks Kiron,
Managers can also inadvertently cause staff to complete work on time....

The challenge is always to find the balance between praising and penalizing team members

Thanks Eduin!

Ashleigh, the question is WHY does student syndrome happen in professional work settings? Is it the cause of delays or an effect of underlying causes...

Kwiyuh - correct, but our default position as leaders should be to not design systems for the very small minority of those who misbehave

Hi Kiron. As you ask, the question is why?

I believe it is the common(?) combination of, there is no need or reward for finishing early, timeboxes/time allocated being too long, and tasks not being on a critical path. This combination doesn't encourage *starting* in a timely manner (so minimises the likelihood of finishing early). Along with people usually/often underestimating the time required to finish a task adequately and/or not allowing for issues means that late is more common. Hence my suggestion that perhaps the iterative/agile sprint approach could help be more timely (external factors/delays aside).

At higher management levels (as you've suggested above) there may also be the idea that finishing early is the result of poor planning and will result in people "standing around doing nothing" so is not accepted either.

Your analysis is spot on with my experience. I've been both the victim and the perpetrator.

However, I wish to offer two simple answers to the initial question:

1) we are overly optimistic as to our ability to deliver. I see that in my personal life where I tend to promise unrealistic delivery - "I'll be home in 20 minutes dear" (knowing the rush hour traffic will delay me by at least 15 minutes), and

2) we are eager to meet expectations (please our audience) in order to facilitate approval or acceptance. We do that knowing that forgiveness (or an extension) is available and easier to obtain that an initial longer delivery period.

Thanks for the article, Kiron. This resonates with many of us, I'm sure.

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

ADVERTISEMENTS

"The only way to keep your health is to eat what you don't want, drink what you don't like and do what you'd rather not."

- Mark Twain

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors

Vendor Events

See all Vendor Events