Project Management

A Project Culture of Mass Hallucination?

From the People and Projects Blog
by
The source of your greatest joys as a project manager will be the same as your biggest challenges: people. This is a blog for discussing issues related to leading teams and delivering projects.

About this Blog

RSS

Recent Posts

The Increasing Influence of Women in Project Management

How To Connect With People In a World of Virtual Meetings

An Experiment That Can Significantly Improve Your Performance

A Practical Way to Build Relationships (Even When You’re Short on Time)

You Are Hurting Your Career (and Project) If You're Not Doing This

Categories

accountability, bias, career, conflict, constraints, culture, decision-making, Estimating, excellence, feedback, influence, Leadership, learning, Lessons Learned, meeting management, negotiation, networking, personal performance, priority management, project management, project planning, project sponsorship, stakeholder management, time management

Date

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


“You can hit this date, right?”

It’s Maria, one of your stakeholders from the other side of the business. She’s asking for a commitment to deliver a project by a specific date. You know the date is ambitious but the way she’s asking makes it clear that she’s only going to accept a Yes.

You pause.

“Sure!” is the word that slips out of your mouth. But if she could read your mind, she wouldn’t be walking away so confidently, leaving you once again with that sick feeling of “How in the world are we going to do this?”

After a day of ruminating about the project, you realize that you need something from her in order to deliver on the promised date. Your eyes brighten! She probably won’t be able to deliver on her part so that will give you some wiggle room! Brilliant!

You call her. “Hi Maria. You know that project we talked about yesterday? Well, in order to hit that date, this is what I need from you.” You elaborate on the needs.

It’s time to go for the ask. “I’ll need all this by the end of next week. Can you get that to me on time?” You pause, praying for a No.

Maria pauses. “Um. Well, let’s see. Yes, I can. Sure!”

Sigh.

Promises, Promises

Can you relate to the discussion with Maria? Perhaps you spend a lot of time in Maria’s role, receiving promises from people who you know won’t deliver. Or maybe you work with people like Maria, who press you with deadlines but don’t supply you with the information you need to deliver.

It’s important to note that you’re not alone. This drama plays out in organizations around the world, across industries. In a conversation with a high-level executive at a biotech firm, the discussion turned to how promises get made to investors and senior executives. He told me, “We make these date commitments but everyone knows we won’t hit them.”

I replied, “Kind of like mass hallucination, eh?” He smiled, but not with this eyes.

Project Culture

It is critical that you and your organization develop a culture that delivers. Relying on crossed fingers, hope, good intentions, and heroics doesn’t scale. The fundamentals of delivery need to be ingrained in the culture.

It’s rather fashionable these days to talk about organizational culture. Let me be clear: your organization has a culture of project management. It’s just a matter of whether or not that culture is helping or hindering your ability to deliver.

Yoda on Corporate Culture

Dr. Edgar Schein is the Society of Sloan Fellows Professor of Management Emeritus and a Professor Emeritus at the MIT Sloan School of Management. He’s widely credited with coining the term organizational culture. When I set up the interview to talk with Dr. Schein, I didn’t realize what a superstar the guy really was.

It didn’t take long in the interview for me to feel like I was talking with Yoda! He responded with ease to my questions about culture.

What is culture, according to Dr. Schein? In short, it’s what has worked. It’s the sum total of what a group has learned that works in solving problems. Whether you like it or not, the project culture in your organization exists because it has sufficiently worked in the past.

Dr. Schein suggests that culture can be broken down into three levels: artifacts, espoused values, and tacit assumptions.

What You Can See

If you walk through an organization, you can see the architecture of the building, the layout of the workspaces, the type of technology they provide for their employees, and the signs on the walls. These are artifacts—things that can be seen. For projects, you might see methodology binders, organization charts, process diagrams, and computer systems to manage project data. You could follow a project manager around and see their behavior—the actions they take. All of these help define the culture.

What We Say

As you continue walking through an organization, you might want to know why certain things are done. You see that a standard operating procedure is documented (the artifact), but you’re wondering why it’s done that way. These would be examples of espoused values—the stated beliefs that give a sense of what is truly valued in the organization?

For example, let’s say you find a form that seems like an unnecessary step in a process. You might ask, “Why do your project managers have to fill out this form?” Perhaps a response would be, “Because we’ve found that the extra step helps make sure we don’t start projects without a business rationale. A couple years back we found that we were wasting too much money on different executives’ pet projects.”

What We Assume

Yet beyond what we see and what is said, there are underlying assumptions that drive what and how things get done in an organization. They are not even stated—just assumed—as if they are obviously a fact or a matter of truth.

All these factors are like an iceberg. Above the water we can see the artifacts and discuss beliefs and values. But below the water we have the underlying assumptions. As with icebergs, these remain unseen and yet can be deadly if not taken into account.

Let’s say your executive team regularly sends e-mails late into the evening. It might be assumed by others that such activity is expected from everyone. There’s not a policy in writing (artifact) that directs people to do so. If you asked someone in HR whether employees are required to be on e-mail until midnight, they could not point to such direction in an Employee Handbook. Yet there’s this underlying assumption of the expectation, which leads to overflowing inboxes and red, baggy eyes amongst a workforce assuming that sleep is not a priority.

In a previous post I wrote about the written and unwritten rules. When considering culture, think of Dr. Schein’s artifacts and espoused values as the written rules—those things above the water. The underlying assumptions are the unwritten rules, those drivers that we cannot see under the water that drive everything above it.

In our next post, we’ll talk about how to make some progress in changing your project culture. But for now, here’s my challenge for you: take some time to consider your current project culture. What is above the water, so to speak, when it comes to projects? What are the written rules? The artifacts? The stated reasons for why things are done?

When we talk about this in our workshops and keynotes, people often reply with things like tools (e.g. Microsoft Project, AsanaXMind, etc.), their Project Management Office (PMO), templates, processes, executive level support, stated expectations, etc. How would you resond?

In addition, what are those factors under the water, so to speak: the underlying assumptions? What are the unwritten rules at your organization regarding how projects should be managed? See how many you can identify. I invite you to share your observations and questions in the comments below.

You can’t sustain a culture of mass hallucination. Hope is a wonderful thing for humanity but’s a lousy strategy for delivering projects. Let’s start with diagnosing your current culture. Next time we’ll talk about how to change that conversation with Maria.

If this post was helpful, I invite you to share it with your connections and LinkedIn groups.

Listen to the interview with Dr. Edgar Schein athttp://www.PeopleAndProjectsPodcast.com/25.


Posted on: March 04, 2015 05:35 PM | Permalink

Comments (31)

Page: 1 2 <prev

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
avatar
Abdullah Al Mamoon Deputy Managing Director & COO| United Commercial Bank PLC Dhaka, Bangladesh
It's a nice article. Thanks for sharing.

avatar
Carlos Patino CMO at Spaceharp. Product & Marketing Consultant at Roland| Roland Corporation U.S. Los Angeles, Ca, United States
I agree completely.

Thanks for sharing.

avatar
Juan Gabriel Gantiva Vergara IT PMO Manager| Private Madrid, Spain
Por eso antes de dar una fecha, por lo menos se debe realizar una análisis previo por muy pequeño que este sea, para ver si es posible cumplir ciertas fechas. Considero importante entender claramente siempre lo que esperan los stakeholders, porque sino siempre el malo será el gerente de proyecto

avatar
Juan Gabriel Gantiva Vergara IT PMO Manager| Private Madrid, Spain
So before giving a date, at least it should make a preliminary analysis however small it may be, to see if it can meet certain dates. Always I consider important to understand clearly what stakeholders expect, because it is always the bad project manager

avatar
Mike Frenette Manager, IT PMO| Halifax Water (retired) Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
That iceberg below the surface will get you every time! :)

avatar
Andy Kaufman Host| People and Projects Podcast Lake Zurich, Il, United States
I've spent too much time with icebergs over the years to disagree, Mike! :)

avatar
Austin Hundley Senior Consultant| Nordic Consulting Nashville, Tn, United States
I say no and have never had a problem doing so. I guess I'm comfortable saying No, but I back it up with why my answer is No and why No is the right answer.

I found the opening story pretty funny though. How could the person expect Maria to say anything other than Sure? They just finished doing the same thing themselves. Hilarious!

Thanks for the article!

avatar
Mike Frenette Manager, IT PMO| Halifax Water (retired) Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
Repeat after me:

"Hope is not a strategy."

"How long is a piece of string?"

"No!"

"I'm sorry. Your pre-determined scope, budget and schedule have very little bearing on what it will take to deliver this."

"You want WHAT? WHEN? Are you mad?"

Useful catch phrases? Or a sure way to get fired? Well... maybe the latter. But ask yourself - would you be better off?

:)

avatar
Andy Kaufman Host| People and Projects Podcast Lake Zurich, Il, United States
Hope is, indeed, not a strategy!

I wonder how often we "give in" on an impossible endeavor, with the mental rationalization that by saying "Yes" we'll avoid falling in bad graces--perhaps even getting fired--only to find ourselves not delivering when the unrealistic timeframe arrives (and THEN falling into bad graces and perhaps getting fired)!


avatar
Olalekan Lasisi Senior Project Manager IT| Jeraisy Computer and Communication Services Dammam, Eastern Region, Saudi Arabia
Commitment, clear communication and project sponsor support should constitute among others organization culture

avatar
Khalid A. Elzairy GM| ECO Consultant Office Elwasta, Bani Sweef, Egypt
Thanks Andy

Page: 1 2 <prev

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

ADVERTISEMENTS

"I don't know anything about music. In my line you don't have to."

- Elvis Presley

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors