Project Management

Scrum Gathering Day 2

From the Drunken PM Blog
by
Drunken Boxing for Project Managers “The main feature of the drunkard boxing is to hide combative hits in drunkard-like, unsteady movements and actions so as to confuse the opponent. The secret of this style of boxing is maintaining a clear mind while giving a drunken appearance.” Yeah... just like that… but with network diagrams and burndown charts… and a wee bit less vodka.
Agile | Agile 2010 | agile 2015 | Agile Alliance | agile transformation | agile2015 | AgileThinking | AOW4PM | apple | art of war | Bas De Baar | body language | branding | Brian Bozzuto | capacity | certified scrum trainer | Chris Li | cloud | cloud worker | commitment | Corkulous | CSM for PMP | cst | Dave Prior | David Bland | digitalpm | Docs to Go | Don Kim | dpm | dpm2013 | EMEA | emotional intelligence | Essential Scrum | facebook | field guide | FIRM REPORT | Flipboard | Global Economics | Greg Balestrero | GTD | Howard Sublett | Idea Wallets | IOS4 | iPad | iPad 2 | iPad2 | iPhone | IT&T SIG | Jesse Fewell | jim benson | kanban | Kathy Compton | Ken Schwaber | Kuala Lumpur | lacey | Leadership Meeting | LeadingAgile | lean | LeanKit | Livescribe | Livescribe Pulse | Mac | MacWorld | Macworld 2011 | Malaysia | Marshall Rosenberg | mashup | MDEC | Merlin | Mike Cohn | Mike Sutton | Mike Vizdos | mitch lacey | MITPM | modus cooperandi | Non-violent communication | Notes Plus | NVC | off shore | Offshore | Olaf Lewitz | Oredev | Øredev | overcommitment | Panda Transport | Papershow | personal branding | personal kanban | personal productivity | PMI | PMI Portugal | Product Owner | productivity | Project | project management | project manaqement | project planning | Project Potion | Projects At Work | projectshrink | ProjectWizards | pulse | Ricardo Vargas | Robyn Meredith | Scrum | Scrum Alliance | scrum but | scrum field guide | Scrum Gathering | ScrumFest | Shane Hastie | SK Khor | social media | sprint planning | SXSW | Thierry Holoweck | Things | Thushara | Tobias Mayer | Tom Perry | troy magennis | twitter | value | VCP | video conferencing | Vivek Angiras | vocal technique | waste | What We Say Matters | Wijewardena | WIzewerks | show all posts

About this Blog

RSS

Recent Posts

Certified Agile Leadership Training with Olaf

Don Kim - I Think, Therefore I Plan

Agile Coach to Agile Gamer - Peter Saddington

Scrum in School - A Case Study of Grandview Prep's Transformation

Forecasting Tools Based on Team Performance with Troy Magennis

Categories

20 Hour, 211, 4-Hour Body, 4-Hour Chef, 4-Hour Work Week, Aakash Srinivasan, Aaron Smith, Adam Weisbart, Adrian Howard, Agile, agile digitalpm, Agile 2010, agile 2015, Agile Alliance, Agile Classroom, Agile Enterprise, Agile Mindset, agile reporting, agile transformation, Agile Tribes, agile2015, AgileClassroom, AgileCraft, AgileScout, AgileThinking, Ainsley Nies, Al Goernor, Al Shalloway, Alistair Cockburn, Angela Harms, Anna Beatrice Scott, Ansley Nies, AOW4PM, apocalypse now, apple, art of war, Bas De Baar, Bas Vodde, Beyond Legacy Code, Big Visible, BigVIsible, bimodal, Blackie, Bob Sarni, body language, book review, braintrust, branding, breaking gantt, Brent Beer, Brett Pohlman, Brian Bozzuto, brian flatow, brian rabon, business agility, Business Model Canvas, CAL, Canvas, capacity, carson pierce, Catherine Louis, Center for Non-Violent Communication, Certification, Certified Agile Leadership, certified scrum trainer, Charter, Chet Hendrickson, Chris Li, Chris Spagnuolo, Christine Neidhardt, cloud, cloud worker, co-working, Coach's Clinic, Coaching, cochlear, commitment, conteneo, Corkulous, coworking, Craig Larman, Crystal, CSM for PMP, cst, DAD, Dan Brown, Dan Greening, dan markovitz, data, Dave Prior, David Anderson, David Bernstein, David Bland, David J Anderson, Dean Leffingwell, Dean Stevens, Declan Whelan, Denise Jacobs, Dennis Stevens, Designing Together Design, Dhaval Panchal, diana larsen, Digital Pm Summit, Digital Project Management, digitalpm, Disciplined Agile Delivery, Distributed Teams, Docs to Go, Don Kim, dpm, dpm2013, drunkenpm, drunkenpm radio, eduscrum, Eight Shapes, Elizabeth Harrin, Elizabeth Hendrickson, Elizabeth McClellan, EMEA, emotional intelligence, Enterprise Scrum, Essential Scrum, esther derby, EVEF, Evernote, Every Voice Engaged, Experience, Explore It!, facebook, field guide, FIRM REPORT, First 20 Hours, Flight Levels, Flipboard, FocusedObjective, forecast, Forecasting, Frank Illenberger, Fred George, fred kluth, funny garbage, Gil Broza, Github, Global Economics, Grandview Prep, Greg Balestrero, GTD, Happy Cog, Heartline, Howard Sublett, hybrid, I Think Therefore I Plan, Iain Frasier, ICAgile, Idea Wallets, improvisation, InfoQ, InspireMe!, International Consortium for Agi, IOS4, iPad, iPad 2, iPad2, iPhone, IT&T SIG, J.B. Rainsberger, James Tamm, Jason LIttle, Jean Tabaka, Jeff Patton, Jesse Fewell, Jessica Kerr, Jessie Shternshus, jim benson, Jim Tamm, johanna rothman, John D Cook, john miller, Judith Lasater, Jutta Eckstein, kamal manglani, kanban, kanbanfor1, kanbanpad, Kate Sullivan, Kathy Compton, Ken Rubin, Ken Schwaber, Kenny Rubin, Keynote, Kuala Lumpur, lacey, Large Scale Scrum, Larman, Larry Maccherone, Larsen, Lasater, Leadership Meeting, LeadingAgile, lean, Lean Kanban University, Lean Systems Engineering, LeanKit, Leffingwell, LESS, Liftoff, Linda Rising, Lithespeed, Livescribe, Livescribe Pulse, LSE, Luis Garcia, luke hohmann, lyssa adkins, Mac, MacWorld, Macworld 2011, Magennis, Malaysia, Malaysia Scrum User Group, Management, Managing the Unmanagable, Manny Gonzalez, Marc Johnson, Marshall Rosenberg, Martin Rosenqvist, mashup, matt barcomb, MDEC, Merlin, metrics, Michael Sahota, Michele Sliger, Mickey W. Mantle, Mike Cohn, Mike Cottmeyer, Mike Sutton, Mike Vizdos, mitch lacey, MITPM, Mode 1, Mode 2, modus cooperandi, Modus Institute, Nanette Brown, Natalie Warnert, Nic Sementa, NLP, Non Violent Communication, Non-violent communication, Notes Plus, NVC, off shore, Offshore, Olaf Lewitz, Open Space, Oredev, Øredev, oredev 2013, organizational agility, Organizational Change, overcommitment, pag, Panda Transport, Panel Picker, Papershow, Paul Hammond, personal agility canvas, personal branding, personal kanban, personal productivity, personal project management, personal projectmanagement, Peter Saddington First15, Petra Goltz, Philamade, pk, Planning, PM4Girls, PMI, PMI Portugal, PMP, podcast, Product Owner, Product Ownership, productivity, Project, project management, project manaqement, project planning, Project Potion, Projects At Work, projectshrink, ProjectWizards, Projet Chartering, pulse, rachel howard, Radical Collaboration, reach the peak, Rebecca Wirfs-Brock, review, riaan rottier, Ricardo Vargas, Robyn Meredith, Ron Jeffries, Ron Lichty, Rosenberg, SAFE, Safety, Sam Barnes, Sanjiv Augustine, Scaled Agile Framework, Schneider and Associates, School of Rock, Scott Ambler, Scrum, Scrum Alliance, scrum but, scrum field guide, Scrum Gathering, Scrum in Education, Scrum in Schools, scrum in waterfall, ScrumFest, Shane Hastie, Showing Up, SK Khor, social media, SolutionsIQ, sprint planning, Steffan Surdek, stephen denning, Steve Elliott, Stewart Copeland, Story Mapping, Sun Tzu, Swarming, SXSW, SXSW2012, Tabaka, Team Performance, Teams, Telecommunications, Telepresence, Temenos, Test Obsessed, the adstore, The Ron, theStrayMuse Louder than Ten, Thierry Holoweck, Things, Thushara, Tim Ferriss, Tim Ferriss Experiment, To Be Agile, Tobias Mayer, Tom Kealey, Tom Mellor, Tom Perry, Tom Smallwood, Tribes, Tricia Broderick, troy magennis, TrustTemenos, twitter, Unicat, User Stories, value, VCP, video conferencing, Virgin Digital, Vivek Angiras, VLC, vocal technique, waste, Weisbart, What We Say Matters, Wijewardena, WIzewerks, Woody Zuill, WWDC, yellowpencil, Zeldman

Date

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


Day 2 at the Scrum Gathering is about Open Space. If you’ve not been to one before, it is a very organic experience. There are very few rules, but one of them is that the attendees propose topics at the start of the day.

Jesse Fewell and I both stood up to propose topics. Jesse held a session for all the folks interested in PMIAgile and I held one that was intended to be a place where anyone who had issues or concerns with PMI attending the Scrum Gathering could come and talk about their issues with it. My hope was to capture the concerns and take them back to PMI.

There was a good turnout in the room and it was a very lively debate about the different ideas/concerns around the topic. These will all be posted to the wiki on the Scrum Alliance site as soon as I get home, but there were a few things that struck me today around the whole PMI and Scrum Alliance topic.

The first thing I noticed was that people keep getting hung up on the language issues and concerns about how to map which process to what in the other. This presents a significant hurdle for a lot of folks. “If I do X in your process what is that represented in my process?” The problem with this is that the real issue is not a semantic one, or a mapping one. The real problem is the fact that there is no focus on intent for the people in this conflict. Both approaches want to solve the project as quickly and efficiently as possible. There are different ways, but sadly, a lot of people are too busy making sure they are firmly planted in one camp or the other to understand that it really just does not matter because it is about doing the work.

Having typed all this, I should confess that I do have one concern coming out of day 2. I have had discussions with a number of folks about the role of a project manager in Scrum, or the role of a Scrum Master in project management. Each has a pure approach and for me, in what I do, I blend them together whenever and however I need to in order to get the work done. I do not feel compelled to take up for one side over the other and I don’t believe either is better than the other. I think it depends entirely on the people doing it. Two concerns here: 1) Most people are too caught up in semantics to worry about the intent to deliver and 2) How much of a threat is my approach to the purists? There are a lot of people worried about how PMI might impact the Agile space. There isn’t really anything in place to prevent something bad from happening beyond the people involved.

Anyway, I had some great conversations today, especially with Tobias Mayer, the folks who attended the Scrum Sessions and Michele Sliger.

One more day. I’m looking forward to getting some interviews tomorrow.

You can follow my twitter feed @pmiittelecom
Pictures will be posted to http://www.flickr.com/photos/pmiittelecom/
Or you can see both on the IT&T SIG website: http://www.pmi-ittelecom.org


Posted on: March 17, 2009 11:29 PM | Permalink

Comments (1)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
avatar
Alaa Hussein Program Manager| MEMECS Baghdad, Iraq
Thanks for sharing.

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

ADVERTISEMENTS

"Sacred cows make the best hamburger."

- Mark Twain

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors