Project Management

Ethics Bistro

by , , , , , , , , ,
We all tackle ethical dilemmas. Wrong decisions can break careers. Which are the key challenges faced? What are some likely solutions? Where can we find effective tools? Who can apply these and why? Dry, theoretical discussions don't help. Join us for lively, light conversations to learn, share and grow!

About this Blog

RSS

View Posts By:

Tara Leparulo
Shenila Shahabuddin
Juan Posada Toro
Albert Agbemenu
Ming Yeung
Kannan Ganesan
Yannick Arekion
Witold Hendrysiak
Stelian ROMAN
Laszlo J. Kremmer MBA, CSPO®, CSM®, PMP®

Past Contributors:

Dr. Deepa Bhide
Lily Murariu
Alankar Karpe
Bryan Shelby
Amany Nuseibeh
Mohamed Hassan
Fabio Rigamonti
Simona Bonghez
John Watson
Lissa Muncer
Valerie Denney
Majeed Hosseiney
Gretta Kelzi
Enrique Cappella
Rocio Briceno
Karthik Ramamurthy

Recent Posts

Pause Before You Post: Professionalism Under Pressure

Why might an ethics complaint be rejected or dismissed?

Ethics in PMI Certification Part III: Audit, Reviews and Credential Integrity

Ethics in PMI Certification Part II:  Experience and Education Requirements

Ethics in PMI Certification Part I – The Certification Process and the Code of Ethics

Categories

Aerospace and Defense, Agile, AI, Ambassadors, Artificial Intelligence, Ask the Experts, Behavior, bottom line, Business Acumen, Business Ethics, Business Ethics, CEO, CFO, Change Management, Chapters, CIO, code of conduct, code of ethics, Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct, communication, Conflict, Construction, courage honesty responsibility respect fairness, Cultural Diversity, Culture, CxO, Decision Making, Decision-making, Decision-making, Digital Project Management, Digital Transformation, Diversity, Do the right thing, dugutalization project manager professionalism social media, economy, EDMF, EMAG, empathy, Ethical Dilemma, Ethical Leadership, Ethics, Ethics, Ethics, Ethics, Ethics, Ethics, Ethics, Ethics as a competence, Ethics Bistro, Ethics in Communication, Ethics Insight Team, Fairness, fairness, Governance, Honesty, honesty, Human, Information Technology, Leadership, Legal Project Management, Legilsation, Lessons Learned, Negotiation, Nexus, Organizational Culture, Organizational Project Management, PMI Program Management, PMI Talent Triangle, PMIAA, Portfolio Management, Power Skills, practitioner, Product Management, Professional Conduct, professional conduct, Professional Responsibility, Professionalization, professonal conduct, Program Management, Project, Project Management, project manager, Regulatory, research, Respect, respect, Responsibility, responsibility, Risk Management, Stakeholder Management, Strategy, Sustainability, Team Assessment, Teams, Thought leadership, tools, Trust, trust, Values, Values, values, Virtual Experience Series, volunteers, Ways of Working

Date

Viewing Posts by Witold Hendrysiak

Why might an ethics complaint be rejected or dismissed?

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


Before filing an ethics complaint through pmi.org/ethics, review these requirements. They can help you determine whether your complaint is eligible for consideration and what you will need to support it.

Who is the Complainant?

The individual, group, organization, or the Institute submits the complaint. A group or organization must designate one individual to represent it and receive correspondence.

Who is the Respondent?

The Covered Individual whose conduct is the subject of the complaint or investigation.

Check out these requirements before submitting your complaint.

Is an ethics complaint the right process for your concern?

  • Check whether another PMI process is more appropriate for your concern.
  • If your allegation involves a conflict or complaint at the chapter level, review the Chapter Conflict Management Program to determine whether your issue should be addressed through that process.
  • If your allegation involves an organizational or policy matter involving PMI, a PMI program, product, or service, review the Complaint, Dispute and Grievance Policy to determine whether the grievance process applies.
  • Choosing the appropriate process before submitting your complaint can help ensure that your concern is directed to the right place.

What questions might arise during an ethics review?

1. Is the complaint against a Covered Individual?

The ethics complaint process applies only to:

  • PMI members
  • Non-members who hold a PMI certification
  • Non-members who apply to commence a PMI certification process
  • Non-members who serve PMI in a voluntary capacity

Complaints cannot be filed against companies or organizations themselves. You must identify the Covered Individual whose conduct is directly at issue.

2. Are you willing to identify yourself?

Complaints cannot be submitted anonymously. You may also need to provide additional information. The Respondent will know the details of the complaint filed against them as well as the identity of the Complainant. You may need to participate in a hearing; the Respondent will also attend and answer questions from the hearing panel.

3. Have you identified a mandatory Code provision?

A complaint must be based on one or more mandatory provisions of the Code. Aspirational provisions provide important ethical guidance but cannot serve as the basis for a complaint. A complaint alleging only violations of the aspirational provisions can be dismissed.

4. Can you support the complaint with facts?

Code section 2.3.4 states: “We file ethics complaints only when they are substantiated by facts.”

Describe the relevant facts, identify the mandatory Code provisions you believe may have been violated, and provide supporting evidence. Where appropriate, identify witnesses who can provide relevant information. Note: witnesses should be advised that they are named in the complaint and consent to be contacted should be obtained by the Complainant.

5. Is the matter already being addressed elsewhere?

The Institute may delay consideration of, reject, or dismiss a complaint when substantially related civil or criminal litigation or other proceedings are before a court, regulatory agency, or other governmental body.A case may also be rejected or dismissed if the matter is being pursued through another PMI process, including the Chapter Mediation, Dispute, and Grievance Policy.

6. What is considered when deciding whether a complaint should proceed?

The review considers whether:

  • The alleged conduct, if proven, would violate one or more specific Code provisions.
  • Relevant and reliable evidence is likely to be available through reasonable investigation.
  • The conduct occurred within the applicable timeframe. In general, complaints concerning conduct from three or more years before submission will be rejected unless the delay results from other proceedings.

7. Do you need to participate after filing?

Yes, the Complainant is expected to cooperate. Failure to cooperate may result in action under the applicable procedures, including termination of the complaint when the Complainant does not cooperate.

8. Can you withdraw a complaint?

Yes, a Complainant may withdraw an ethics complaint at any time by providing written notice.

In case of any doubts, you may always contact us at [email protected]. We’ll be happy to answer all of your questions.

Posted by Witold Hendrysiak on: November 10, 2026 02:48 AM | Permalink | Comments (5)

Looking for the most important information on pmi.org? Here are the key links.

Categories: Ethics

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  

Contact and Issue Reporting 
At the very bottom of the pmi.org homepage, the Contact Us link is the entry point to get help or report non-ethical but administrative issues, including membership, certification, and PDU issues, as well as exam security complaints, such as exam invalidation and membership payment issues. 


Volunteer Resources 
The Chapter and Volunteer Resources page (pmi.org/leadership-central/chapter-volunteer-resources) should be the favorite page for every PMI volunteer. It offers a well-structured collection of links to documents that every PMI volunteer should keep handy. 
Among many documents, you can find the Chapter Conflict Management Program for chapter-level dispute resolution. This document provides a fair and timely process for addressing conflicts that may arise among volunteers and/or members within chapters. 


Governance Documents and Grievance Policy 
All key PMI governance documents are consolidated under pmi.org/about/leadership-governance/documents. Among them, the Complaint, Dispute and Grievance Policy outlines how PMI receives, reviews, and resolves formal complaints, disputes, and grievances for members, volunteers, components, customers, employees, and other stakeholders. It can be used for policy-related issues (e.g., a nomination committee failing to follow procedures) and operational issues (e.g., system downtime affecting member registration). It does not address ethical matters. 


Ethics Complaint Process 
For ethics-related issues, go to pmi.org/ethics. Follow the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct and the Ethics Case Procedures documents. These provide the correct process for submitting and handling ethics complaints. In case you decide to file a complaint, be sure to start by identifying which mandatory sections of the code were violated.  
 
What are your favorite links on the pmi.org website? Which should be added to this short compendium? 
Posted by Witold Hendrysiak on: April 09, 2026 03:23 PM | Permalink | Comments (5)

Facing an ethics complaint? Don’t Panic: Hints for PMI Ethics Complaint’s Respondent

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  

Getting notice that you’re accused of violating PMI’s Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct is unsettling. Breathe. This is the moment to steady yourself, get clear on the facts, and respond thoughtfully. The path forward is practical and values-based.

Use the following steps to organize your response and act with responsibility, respect, fairness, and honesty.

  • Pause and get grounded
    • Don’t panic. Give yourself enough time to read the notice carefully and understand what’s being asked of you.
    • Note deadlines, requested information, and any instructions about confidentiality.
  • Assess your position against the Code
    • Ask yourself plainly: do you agree a violation occurred, in whole or in part?
    • Map the situation to the Code’s expectations. Where does your conduct align? Where might it fall short?
    • Keep judgment neutral and fact-based. Avoid speculation about others’ motives.
  • Reconstruct the facts
    • Gather objective materials that support your position (emails, messages, documents, system logs, meeting notes).
    • If it’s a “word against word” situation, identify witnesses who directly observed the event and can share their perspective.
    • Write a precise timeline: what happened, where, when, and who was involved.
  • Review what happened after the event
    • Document what you did between the event and receiving the notification.
    • Note any actions you took to address the issue, your initial reaction, and any steps to prevent recurrence.
  • Prepare a clear, complete response
    • Answer the questions you received directly and completely.
    • Explain the situation from your point of view, sticking to facts and timelines.
    • Acknowledge uncertainties rather than filling gaps with assumptions.
    • Keep your tone professional and cooperative.
  • Cooperate with the process
    • Meet deadlines, provide requested materials, and be responsive.
    • Maintain confidentiality and be respectful in all communications.
    • Avoid retaliatory behavior or commentary; let the process work.
  • If a violation occurred, own it and repair it
    • If you agree that a violation happened, state that clearly.
    • Propose concrete steps to make things right: clarifications or apologies where appropriate, restitution if harm occurred, corrective actions, and controls to prevent recurrence.
    • Share what you’ve learned and what will change in your practice (training, mentoring, improved procedures).
    • Openness and accountability matter. The Ethics Review Committee considers genuine ownership and corrective action.
  • Use your time during the hearing
    • Make the best out of your time during the hearing. You will have 10 minutes to present your position.

A steady, principled response demonstrates professionalism under pressure. Focus on facts, align with the Code, cooperate fully, and—if needed—make amends and show how you will do better. Don’t panic. Lead with integrity, and let that guide your next steps.

Familiarize yourself with the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct and refer to Ethics Case Responses & Findings for more details.

Let me know if you find this article valuable. What other hints would you add?

Posted by Witold Hendrysiak on: October 16, 2025 08:58 AM | Permalink | Comments (5)

PMI’s Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct – a document nobody reads or a powerful tool to elevate the profession?

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  

That little booklet, the "PMI's Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct (CoEPC)", usually ends up in a drawer somewhere, right? Most project managers get it when they renew their certifications and don't think much about it after. Sarah was one of them. But lately, a decision she made on a project just didn't feel right. She picked up the pamphlet, almost by accident. Could this thing, usually ignored like a fire safety manual until there's smoke, actually help her figure things out? Was it just another piece of paper, or could it really make being a project manager better? 

All PMI members, volunteers, certification holders, and certification applicants accepted the PMI’s CoEPC. Has this document been read, understood, and complied with, or was the checkbox confirming acceptance checked without reading it, like the legal clauses attached to contracts in small print? It is not easy to answer this question. We can however state that it is not a dead document covered with dust, having no impact on us.

  

Thanks to the complaint process in place and a group of PMI volunteers serving in the Ethics Review Committee (ERC) the CoEPC has become a powerful tool to enforce ethical behavior in the project management profession. Whenever an unethical behavior is observed anybody can file a complaint. This complaint will be carefully investigated, and appropriate actions will be taken.  

We are not helpless facing somebody bullying, cheating, being dishonest or not respecting rules and regulations. All that is needed is our courage to stand for truth and justice and simply state the facts by filing a complaint. From this moment the case is in the capable hands of the ERC, which will do whatever is necessary. 

Please visit the https://www.pmi.org/about/ethics/cases webpage to review the public reprimands recently published, which is just the top of the iceberg of the strongest sanctions applied. This is proof that PMI takes seriously the continuous effort to make project management an ethical profession. 

Your involvement in this process is, however, critical. Code section 2.3.3 says: “We bring violations of this Code to the attention of the appropriate body for resolution.” Do you have the courage to act if needed? 

Posted by Witold Hendrysiak on: April 27, 2025 04:37 AM | Permalink | Comments (3)

How to File a Good Ethics Complaint: A Simple Guide

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  

Ever found yourself in a situation where you witnessed unethical behavior by a covered individual (PMI Member, PMI Volunteer, PMI Credential holder, or Certification applicant) and wondered what to do next? Filing a complaint can be daunting, but it's an important step to maintain integrity in our professional community. Here's a straightforward guide to help you file a good Ethics complaint.

Find the Right Motivation

First things first, why do you want to file this complaint? Is it because you're upset and want revenge, or because you genuinely want to stop unethical behavior? The latter is the right reason. Filing a complaint takes courage as complaints cannot be anonymous.

Keep Perspective

Remember, filing a complaint is just about reporting what you saw. The Ethics Review Committee will investigate the facts and take action if needed. You're not accusing anyone; you're just sharing your observations.

Focus on Facts

This is crucial. Your complaint needs to be backed up with fact-based evidence. Strong supporting documents are essential for building a compelling and persuasive case. These documents should be specific, relevant, and verifiable, providing concrete proof of the ethical violation. Examples include emails, violation-related documents, records to point out the violation, and witness statements. Take screenshots with dates and times, as digital information can be altered or deleted, especially after the Respondent is notified about the complaint. Collect sufficient evidence to support your observation and keep it organized. It is critical to collect the evidence at the time a complaint is filed.

Refer to the Code of Ethics

A “good” complaint should refer to the Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct paragraph believed to be violated. This will help you gather the right evidence. Remember, you can't file complaints against aspirational standards, only mandatory ones.

Be Concise

Keep your complaint focused and to the point. Avoid adding unnecessary documents. A well-organized, concise complaint is much easier to review. If you have a lot of documents, provide an overview and sort them in chronological order.

Include Witnesses

In some cases, it can be very helpful to include witnesses. Especially in "word against word" situations, witnesses can provide additional perspectives that support your complaint.

Follow-up and closure

It's crucial to monitor the proceedings closely, answer the questions received, and attend the hearing, as this will provide a better opportunity to understand the complaint.

Act for the Greater Good

The Vision and Purpose section of the Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct starts with the sentence: “As practitioners of project management, we are committed to doing what is right and honorable. We set high standards for ourselves and aspire to meet these standards in all aspects of our lives-at work, at home, and in service to our profession.”

Walk the Talk

Follow the Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct:

2.3.2: “We report unethical or illegal conduct to appropriate management and, if necessary, to those affected by the conduct”

2.3.3: “We bring violations of this Code to the attention of the appropriate body for resolution”

2.3.4 “We only file ethics complaints when they are substantiated by facts”

 

Let's work together to uphold the highest standards in project management!

What recommendations can you give to make ethics complaints better?

Posted by Witold Hendrysiak on: December 13, 2024 01:26 PM | Permalink | Comments (6)

"Only two things are infinite, the Universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former."

- Albert Einstein

Sponsors