Project Management

ChatGPT Drank My Water

From the People, Planet, Profits & Projects Blog
by ,

About this Blog

RSS

View Posts By:

Richard Maltzman
Dave Shirley

Recent Posts

A citrus fruit schools us on material science and project leadership (Part 1 of 2)

Black Tape Over the Engine Light

Saving the Sahel (Part 1)

You Can't Get They-ah From Hee-yah

Floating an idea into reality: the other side of the AI Project Paradox

Categories

6th, 6th Edfition, 6th Edition PMBOK, 7th Edition, 7th Edition PMBOK, 8th Edition PMBOK, 8th Edition PMBOK Guide, Activism, actuarial, actuary, adapt, addition by subtraction, Africa, africa, agriculture, airforce, ajaita, Alaska, amazon, analogous, analytics, ancient, and more power, antarctica, anti-science, apple, apps, architecture, arctic, arrakis, Artificial Intelligence, asch paradigm, Assistant, asthma, astronomy, automobile, automotive, autonomous cars, b, bankhar, Banksy Crypto, basalt, baseball, bats, batter, beauty products, benefit, benefits, Benefits Realization, beyond epica, biases, bicycle, big data, big dfata, big dig, bike, biodiversity, biomedicine, birdhouse, blockchain, blood, blue blood, blue trees, bluefin, bluefin tuna, book review, boston, boston university, Boyce, Brazil, brazil, Breakdown Structures, BS, building, buildings, built environment, built environment, bumblebee, cake, capacitor, car, Carbon, carbon, carbon capture, carbon negative, carbon neutral, carbon pool, carbon sequestration, carbonate, careers, CEO, ChatGPT, chatGPT, chatgpt, chatgpt, chess, China, china, chopsticks, citrus, cli-fi, climate, climate change, climate resilience, climeworks, Clumsy, CO2, co2, CO2 Utilization, coalition, cobalt, coffee pods, cognition, cognitive, Collabortion, colombia, concrete, Conflict, construction 5.0, cool projects xyloscope, cooling, coral, corn, cost of good quality, cost of poor quality, cost of quality, crazy, criticism of project management, cryptocurrency, CSR, csr, data, data analytics, data privacy, datacenter, dataset, death spiral, Decision Making, decomposition, Defense and Climate, definition of a project, deforestation, dependencies, dependency, desert, DIKW, dikw, dimopoulos, disposal, dna, DOD, dogs, dolphins, dream, drilling, drink, dune, dune, dutch, early start, earth, eatlocal, eco-tourism, ecological, economic, economics, EKC, electric grid, electricity, electronics, elysis, embodied carbon, emerging technologies, empower, Energy, energy efficiency, environmental degradation, escalate, escalation, ESG, extreme weather, fallacy, FARC, farming, finance, fish, fish brains, fishing, fix, fixing the earth, flint water, Flint Water Supply, flood, flooding, Food supply chain, food waste, forest, forest for the trees, forestation, forrestgump, frank herbert, Fruitcake, fungus, fusion, Galvao, garage, gas, gasoline, geese, gender equality, gender partnerships, generational differences, Generative AI, gladwell, gold, Goodness, google, Government, GPT, great pacific garbage patch, green, green building, green buildings, green energy, green iguana, green project, green project management, greening, guest post, gyre, harkonnen, Harvesting Benefits, hawasina, hedgehogs, heursitics, historical data, hlb, holitsic, holland, horseshoe crab, human-caused climate change, hydrogen, hydrology, ice, iceland, ignition, iguana, imagery, impact, india, inequality, information, initiatives, injection, insurance, intelligence, interacting risk, internal combustion engine, invasive species, investment, isomer, issue escalation, issues, ITER, jobs, Jupiter, justification, kids, kill point, knowledge, koch brothers, Kuznets, laboratory, LAL, landscape mode, lapampa, launch, LCA, Leadership, Leadership, life cycle analyses, life cycle analysis, lifecycle, Linkedin, liquid, lizard, local, long term, long-term, long-term thinking, look up, loud, maintenance, maker, makermovement, malcolm gladwell, management, marathon, marine biology, market, mars, Martin Luther King, mean, megawatt, MeHg, melting, mercury, metal, Microgrid, microplastics, migration, military, millennial, mindset, minerals, mission, mitigate, MLK, mongolia, museum, museum of london, nature, nematodes, net gain, Net Project Success Score, net zero, netherlands, network, New book, New Jersey, New Practitioners, new york, NFT, nitrogen, noise, noreaster, norway, nova, NPSS, NREL, ocean, ocean cleanup, ocean life, oil rig, oil rigs, oklahoma, oman, only murders in the building, opportunity, overall risk, oxygen, packaging, pareto, PBS, permafrost, persistence, peru, Pharmaceutical, planet, planet.com, planning, plant, plasma, plastic, playground, pm, pm education, pmbok, pmbok guide, pmnetwork, PMXPO-2018, podcast, pollutants, pollution, poop, poor, portfolio, power, power skills, privacy, privacy concerns, professors, program, Program Management, project, project leader, project leadership, project management, project management 3.0, project on fire, project progress, Project Success, project success, projecticity, projectleadership, projectmanagement, projects, psychology, pulse of the profession, purple bacteria, purpose, quiet, rainforest, rationale, reef, refugees, renewable, renewables, Repair, repair, repeatable process, repeatable processes, repurpose, research, resource breakdown strucuture, Resource Management, reversing climate change, revisionist history, rich, rigs2reefs, ripe, risk, risk avoidance, Risk Management, risk mitigation, risk response, risk responses, river, robots, rocks, rules of thumb, rural, rural India, russia, Sarcasm/Irony, satellite, saudi, schedule, sci-fi, Science, science, science-fiction, scientific american, screaming monkeys, sea, sea life, Sea-Level Rise, sea-level rise, seagreens, seawall, seawater, seawater temperature, seaweed. beat;es. farming, secondary risk, selena gomez, sequestration, shipping, skyscraper, SLR, smart cities, smart city, smelting, social, social pressure, soil, solar, solar panels, solar perovkites, solar saheli, sonic, sponge cities, SRI, stage-gate, stagegate, stakeholder, stakeholder management, steward, stewardship, storage, strategy, stupid, success, suffer, sulphur, sunk cost, supercapacitor, supply chain, survey, Sustainability, sustainability, Sustainable Investing, Sustainable Tourism, sybiosis, symbiosis, system 03, TBL, temperature, terraform, terraforming, test, threat, threats, totem, touchscreen, tour, tower, Trains, transparency, transportation, trash, tree, tree species, trees, trillion, triple bottom line, triple constraint, truth to power, UMass, us army corps of engineers, USDA, vacuum, value, venus, vision, voice, voltage optimization, vw scandal, washing machine, waste, wastewater, water, we mean business, whales, Whirlpool, wind, wisdom, women, Women in Project Management, wood wide web, woonerf, Work Breakdown Structures (WBS), world breakdown structure, worms, xian, xylotron, Yale

Date

linkedin twitter facebook Request to reuse this  


I’ve previously posted “ChatGPT Ate My Brain”.  Now, here, I’m posting on AI’s increasing and seemingly unquenchable thirst for water.

I was triggered to write this based on an email exchange with fellow BU professor Dr. Dave Silberman, who went me a recent article from Forbes, “AI’S Unsustainable Water Use: How Tech Giants Contribute To Global Water Shortages” which quotes a to-be-peer-reviewed article (download here): which states:

"training GPT-3 in Microsoft's state-of-the-art US data centers can directly consume 700,000 liters of clean freshwater", which they calculate could be used to produce 370 BMW cars or 320 Tesla electric vehicles.

Furthermore, ChatGPT 'drinks' the equivalent of a 500ml bottle of water for a simple conversation of 20-50 questions and answers. Which may not seem like much... until you consider that the chatbot has more than 100 million active users, each of whom engages in multiple conversations.

So, I thought it would be a worthy use of a little H2O to ask ChatGPT what it thought of the situation.

It was surprisingly frank:


My question: As a person interested in sustainability, I am alarmed to see that AI is very 'thirsty' for freshwater, based on this article https://www-forbes-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.forbes.com/sites/federicoguerrini/2023/04/14/ais-unsustainable-water-use-how-tech-giants-contribute-to-global-water-shortages/amp/ . Is it true that AI consumes large amounts of water, and what is being done about it?


The answer from ChatGPT: Yes, it is true that AI systems consume significant amounts of water, especially in the training phase of machine learning models. This is because AI requires vast amounts of computational power, which generates heat that needs to be dissipated, and cooling systems that use water to maintain the necessary temperature. Additionally, data centers that host AI models require a lot of water for cooling and other operational needs.

The impact of AI on water resources is an important concern, and there are ongoing efforts to address this issue. One approach is to use more energy-efficient hardware, such as specialized processors that can perform AI computations with lower power consumption. Another approach is to develop more efficient cooling systems that use less water, and to use recycled water or other sustainable sources of water for cooling.

In addition to technical solutions, it's important to consider the environmental impact of AI in the design and deployment of AI systems. This means taking a holistic approach to sustainability and considering the entire life cycle of AI systems, including the raw materials used to manufacture hardware, the energy used to power AI models, and the disposal of electronic waste.

Overall, the AI industry and the broader technology sector are increasingly aware of the need to address the environmental impact of their activities, including water use, and are taking steps to reduce their impact on the planet.


The video just below from Amazon Web Services (AWS) tackles the issue and provides some ways that AWS is helping to battle this, wanting to be “water-positive” by 2030.  When you watch this video, note that what they are really discussing, without saying it directly, is that they have a portfolio of programs and projects which initiatives that execute the strategy aimed at that goal, which is in turn, aligned with their sustainability-oriented mission and vision statement.  This is very much in line with the model that (for example), folks like Gilbert Silvius, Alexandra Chapman, and others have been promoting for a long time.

Google recently shared a blog post revealing its water use – a staggering 4.3 billion gallons of water in 2021, which works out to an average daily water footprint approaching a half-million gallons per data center. 

https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/sustainability/our-commitment-to-climate-conscious-data-center-cooling/

It gets complicated as well, because there is a trade-off (we’re used to those as a project manager, though) between reducing water and reducing carbon.  The initiatives you see in the video, I’m sure you have already guessed, take energy and have their own impact.   From the Google blog post:

When used responsibly, water cooling can play an important role in reducing emissions and mitigating climate change. Water-cooled data centers use about 10% less energy and thus emit roughly 10% less carbon emissions than many air-cooled data centers. In 2021, water cooling helped us reduce the energy-related carbon footprint of our data center portfolio by roughly 300,000 tons of CO2."

 So it is a complicated, convoluted, higher-level, higher stakes balancing act that we must perform.

“Going Waterless” was one of the top eight trends identified by Data Center Frontier.  So at this point it seems we’re at least conscious of the problem.  Now – can we get the right amount of talented project, program, and portfolio leaders on the job?  It’s an important enough problem to pour over…

 

References:

  1. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03271.pdf
  2. https://www-forbes-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.forbes.com/sites/federicoguerrini/2023/04/14/ais-unsustainable-water-use-how-tech-giants-contribute-to-global-water-shortages/amp/
  3. https://www.newscientist.com/article/2342490-how-much-water-do-data-centres-use-most-tech-companies-wont-say/
  4. https://www.datacenterfrontier.com/sustainability/article/21438279/aws-targets-water-use-in-its-cloud-data-centers
  5. https://www.datacenterfrontier.com/cloud/article/21439020/the-eight-trends-that-will-shape-the-data-center-industry-in-2023

Posted by Richard Maltzman on: April 16, 2023 02:32 PM | Permalink

Comments (3)

Please login or join to subscribe to this item
avatar
Latha Thamma reddi Sr Product and Portfolio Management (Automation Innovation)| DXC Technology Mckinney, Tx, United States
Nice Question and answer, Very Good

avatar
Maxim Shevelev Haifa, Ta, Israel
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!!

avatar
Bryson Lee Program Manager| Western Shelter Services Eugene, Or, United States
Interesting to think about impact this way, thanks for this insight!

Please Login/Register to leave a comment.

ADVERTISEMENTS

"Bad artists always admire each other's work."

- Oscar Wilde

ADVERTISEMENT

Sponsors